I. INTRODUCTION
Far too many—if not most—of us in the legal profession who belong to both the disability and LGBTQ+ communities have known informally, through our own experiences and those of others like us, that workplace bias and discrimination on the basis of disability, sexuality, and gender identity is still widespread. The new study by Blanck et al. on diversity and inclusion in the U.S. legal profession provides empirical proof of this phenomenon, which might otherwise be dismissed as being based on anecdotal evidence.Footnote 1 Its findings lend credibility to our position that the legal profession must make systemic changes to address workplace ableism, heterosexism, and transmisia.Footnote 2 They also suggest possibilities as to where and how it might start to do so through providing information on who employers discriminate against most often and in what forms.Footnote 3
At the same time, though, more research is necessary to enable LGBTQ+, disability, and labor rights advocates to make truly data-driven recommendations for how to improve the working lives of queer and disabled legal professionals.Footnote 4 The data in this study informs the reader of what is happening in a general sense, but leaves a lot of room for more in-depth explorations of related issues, such as how experiences of discrimination differ across workplace settings and subsections of the affected communities.Footnote 5 Furthermore, developing effective diversity and inclusion measures requires that researchers analyze why the bias and discrimination they seek to address persists to such a significant extent. Developing an understanding of these reasons depends in turn on examining any underlying, unexamined assumptions researchers themselves may have about the degree of even abstract commitment to the principles of diversity and inclusion within the legal profession.
In this Comment, we will first discuss how the study’s authors assume a certain level of commitment to ending workplace discrimination to an extent that is not warranted, and how this assumption impedes a fully effective response to the problem. We go on to propose specific areas for further study, such as bias and lateral oppression against sub-populations within the LGBTQ+ and disability communities; discrimination across different types of organizations or employers; the response of victims of discrimination; and the efficacy of current anti-discrimination measures. Finally, in the absence of data on these particular subjects, we draw upon our knowledge and lived experience to propose short-term steps that employers, law schools, professional associations, and individual legal practitioners can take to begin the process of making the legal profession truly equitable and inclusive.
II. THE PROBLEMS WITH WISHFUL THINKING ABOUT OVERT DISCRIMINATION
The primary flaw in the study at issue is that the authors overstate the progress that the legal profession has made in rooting out structural oppression. In particular, the authors state that “overt forms of discrimination are viewed as unacceptable behavior in the workplace, and such behavior usually leads to consequences for the person(s) who commit it.”Footnote 6 As proof of this statement, the authors point to the existence of anti-discrimination provisions within the Americans with Disabilities Act.Footnote 7
The results of the study itself reveal that the existence of legal protections is not proof of adequate enforcement, or even widespread support for the law’s purpose. While the findings of the study support the position that overt discrimination by itself is less common than either subtle discrimination alone or the combination of both types, it provides no evidence of widespread accountability for acts of overt discrimination, nor even that overt discrimination in all its forms is widely frowned upon.Footnote 8 If anything, the fact that disabled people most often face both subtle and overt discrimination suggests that ongoing (acceptance of) overt discrimination is an open secret within the legal community.
Ignoring this data in favor of the common but evidently unfounded belief that open bigotry is no longer a significant issue comes at the price of misunderstanding the nature and scope of the problem, and of what the legal profession has to do to change it. This misunderstanding may be a significant contributing factor in why diversity and inclusion initiatives have not been as successful as many of us would have liked. If it also carries over into subsequent research efforts, it could prevent scholars from asking the right questions and accurately interpreting the results. While it’s uncomfortable to imagine that members of our profession continue to both hold and shamelessly act on harmful and backwards beliefs, confronting that fact honestly is the only way to have any hope of changing it.
III. AREAS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH
A. Discrimination In Public Interest Settings
It is critical to ensure that LGBTQ+ legal professionals with disabilities who use our legal training to fight on behalf of our communities do not have to simultaneously confront workplace discrimination at the hands of organizations and people who claim to represent our interests. Therefore, one crucial area for future study is the prevalence and dynamics of ableist, heterosexist, and transmisic discrimination in public interest settings, particularly those that primarily or disproportionately serve queer and disabled people. This category includes nonprofits dedicated to disability and LGBTQ+ advocacy; broader civil rights and legal aid organizations; private civil rights litigation firms; and government agencies tasked with enforcing civil rights protections.
Such research could begin with studies on how often discrimination takes place, how it manifests, and how effectively management responds in public interest and public interest adjacent settings as opposed to in the private sector. Alternately, researchers could take a more open-ended approach of collecting narratives from disabled and queer attorneys about their experiences working in nonprofit organizations and government agencies, and identifying common experiences that could form the basis for more targeted empirical research. It would be particularly interesting to learn the extent to which the reputation of public interest organizations as progressive and inclusive spaces influences marginalized attorneys’ ability to recognize workplace bias and discrimination as it is happening, and the legal profession’s willingness to believe that it is occurring there.
B. Intersected Experiences of Oppression Among LGBTQ+ and Disabled Legal Professionals
Legal professionals who belong to both the LGBTQ+ and disabled communities often face compounded discrimination that cannot necessarily be distinguished as either solely disability-based or solely based on gender or sexuality.Footnote 9 For instance, supervisors or co-workers of an openly trans person with known or perceived psychosocial disabilities might deprive that person of their job responsibilities, micromanage their work, and subject them to repeated comments about their supposed incompetence and unprofessionalism based on appearance, manner of speech, and work style. Those repeated slights, built up over time, may easily constitute a hostile environment, and could lead to that person eventually choosing to leave (in what we might recognize as a constructive firing) to escape the toxic situation. It would be difficult, if not impossible, however, to determine whether the discriminatory conduct was based on the employee’s disability, gender identity, or some combination of both.
Many disabled and LGBTQ+ legal professionals are multiply marginalized because of race, class, immigration status, religion, or other aspects of their identities or experiences. Our experiences are not adequately captured in the current study, but future research driven by scholars and advocates with lived experience can begin to identify ways that disabled and LGBTQ+ legal professionals experience discrimination across different marginalized identities and experiences.Footnote 10 It would be helpful to have disaggregated and disambiguated data identifying differences in experiences of discrimination between, for instance, Southeast Asian attorneys with disabilities and Indigenous Latinx attorneys with disabilities, or between trans attorneys with physical disabilities and neurodivergent trans attorneys. In particular, it would be helpful to have specific data about the ways that oppressive systems, processes, and policies impact multiply marginalized people on the basis of multiple marginalized identities.
C. Lateral Ableism and Less Well-Known Access Needs
Research, scholarship, and advocacy on disability invariably privileges disabled people with the most access to power and resources both as a general rule and within specific disabled communities. Many groups of disabled people remain severely underrepresented within the legal profession, in no small part due to lateral ableism and the hierarchy of disability.Footnote 11 These two concepts refer to the ways in which disabled people often adopt ableist socio-cultural values about other types of disabilities, and treat people with certain types of disabilities as more deserving of rights and recognition than others. For instance, many otherwise neurotypical people with physical disabilities (both congenital and acquired) often situate their claims to personhood by disavowing the personhood of people with intellectual or psychosocial disabilities.Footnote 12 At the same time, those whose disabilities may be perceived as more readily apparent or obvious may claim more legitimacy within disabled identity than those whose disabilities may be (perceived as) more hidden.Footnote 13
Further research on the experiences of those legal professionals who have disabilities subject to particularly intense ableism, even within disabled communities, is necessary to gain a full understanding of disabled people’s experiences. Such groups include (though are certainly not limited to) people with intellectual disabilities, deafblind people, nonspeaking people and people who use alternative and augmentative communication, people who experience psychosis or intense dissociation, people who require 24/7 attendant care because of physical disabilities, and multiply neurodivergent people such as autistic people with ADD and trauma.
All disabled people face the prospect of misunderstanding, refusal of accommodations, and denial of access needs. Nonetheless, those of us whose access needs are harder to explain than asking for access to a ramp or to Braille text (both of which are not necessarily guaranteed or even widely available) often face constant refusal or denial of lesser known or recognized accommodation requests like needing a private office space with a door due to sensory issues, chemical sensitivities, or psychosis, needing assistance with completing routine paperwork due to ADD, traumatic brain injury, or chronic fatigue, or needing a change of lighting because of photosensitive epilepsy, vision processing disabilities, or migraines.Footnote 14 Refusal to even recognize that these access needs are legitimate or real can and does lead to sidelining and pushout for disabled legal professionals whose disabilities do not prevent them from doing the work but do require them to do the work differently than nondisabled colleagues.Footnote 15
D. Marginalized Queer and Trans People Within the LGBTQ+ Community
Similarly, not all LGBTQ+ people are represented equally in the legal profession or in research about our lives and experiences. Groups of people within the LGBTQ+ community who face particular marginalization include transfeminine people—especially trans women—and Two Spirit people, asexual and aromantic people, as well as LGBTQ+ people who have done sex work, who have been homeless, who have been incarcerated, or who are living with HIV (which is also a disability). People from all of these communities or who have had all of these experiences can want to and do enter the legal profession.Footnote 16 Not surprisingly to us, multiply marginalized people within LGBTQ+ communities, including disabled people, fat people, immigrants, and people of color, face oppression both within and outside the LGBTQ+ community.Footnote 17 Researchers should intentionally seek out experiences of hyper-marginalized and multiply-marginalized LGBTQ+ people, including data on actual hiring and retention practices, as well as narratives of discrimination. Otherwise, research will continue to prioritize and privilege the experiences of wealth-privileged, white, abled, thin, and masculine-presenting people within the LGBTQ+ community—groups that are almost certainly the most likely to attain long-term success within the legal profession.
E. Complicity and Concealment
Toxic workplace cultures are just as essential to the pervasiveness of workplace bias and discrimination as individual bigots and bullies.Footnote 18 Therefore, researchers should also explore management and institutional complicity in workplace bias and discrimination. Relevant subjects could include how many complaints employers typically receive before disciplining or terminating individual employees who engage in discrimination, and what factors impact how quickly and robustly they respond. At the same time, it may also be useful to collect narratives from people and organizations accused of multiple instances of workplace discrimination to identify patterns of concealment and self-justification.
A related issue to examine is how often attorneys with disabilities and LGBTQ+ attorneys report discrimination against them, both internally and to outside bodies. This could in turn lead to further explorations on the subject of under-reporting, such as which populations tend to refrain from reporting discrimination and what factors make marginalized employees more or less likely to come forward about their experiences.
F. Effectiveness of Existing Anti-Discrimination and Equity Policies
Finally, researchers must consider the actual impact and effectiveness of extant practices in the field of diversity, inclusion, and equity, including anti-discrimination policies. Have creation of ombudsperson’s offices, chief diversity, equity, and inclusion executive officer positions, state anti-discrimination commissions, public or private bias incident reporting systems, or mandated diversity, cultural sensitivity, or awareness training programs actually led to any material changes in conditions for people who are most impacted by systems of oppression? In our own conversations with disabled friends and colleagues, it’s common wisdom that there is usually no point to filing any formal complaints about employment discrimination—whether with a state attorney general’s office or with an Equal Employment Opportunity office—because we do not typically expect an investigation, let alone a robust one that comes with consequences for wrongdoers. Many of us are focused much more on basic survival, including maintaining our ability to be perceived as hirable and not troublesome, so that we can pay the bills and stay alive, than we are on the remote possibility of securing a favorable administrative or judicial finding after being actually or constructively fired.
Future research could examine whether and to what extent disabled and LGBTQ+ employees’ perceptions of their workplace’s climate, infrastructure, and culture have changed after implementation of these types of equity and diversity-focused policies. Where research shows that such policies have not necessarily resulted in improved experiences, researchers could align with directly impacted community members to identify what policy and programmatic changes, if any, could have greater or longer-term positive effects. Such research will be useful regardless of whether it shows that such policies have worsened conditions, such as by leading to increased harassment or ostracism of marginalized people, made no significant changes to the working environment, or have significantly improved marginalized people’s experiences.
IV. IMAGINING A BETTER, FREER, MORE JUST FUTURE
Even if researchers were to explore each of the areas that we have outlined in brief in this Comment, however, we know that the path to a better, freer, and more just future for queer, trans, and disabled people cannot rely solely on policy change or reform. We are marginalized legal professionals working within systems that were created and expanded in large part to justify—among other atrocities—land theft and occupation, genocide of Indigenous and Native peoples, chattel enslavement of Black people, and subjugation, criminalization, and incarceration of many other marginalized populations across the United States.Footnote 19 Therefore, we know that the law cannot claim to be about justice, nor will it bring about justice. A future where ableism, heterosexism, and transmisia no longer exists is a future that our current legal system and jurisprudential histories cannot contemplate, because ableism, heterosexism, and transmisia are woven deeply into the law.Footnote 20 One need only look to the institution of guardianship, the entrenchment of subminimum wage, the legal history of the definitions of marriage and personhood, and the ever-expanding legal mechanisms of mass criminalization and mass incarceration.Footnote 21 Thus, such systems of oppression also inevitably pervade the legal academy and the legal profession.
The legal academy, as it is, requires adherence to strict standards of performance, achievement, and excellence that are in turn rooted in deeply ableist, classist, and racist expectations. For instance, students must complete a certain quantity of coursework within a compressed time period, while achieving certain grades, participating in certain prescribed activities, and demonstrating sufficient intellectual capacity in rigid examinations.Footnote 22 These expectations do not account for the high variability of marginalized students’ experiences, such as childcare and outside work responsibilities, disabilities that cause chronic pain and cognitive fatigue, constant trauma from racial terror and stress, or survival of abusive familial and intimate partner relationships, all of which can significantly impact ability to complete coursework at a specific pace, in a specific timeframe, and to a specific degree of excellence.Footnote 23
Success in the legal profession post-graduation, in turn, compels the ability to perform and function in rigidly structured interview processes, professional networking receptions, and intensely hierarchical workplaces in both public interest and corporate settings. Travel for networking events and interviews even within the same locality, social communication in white- and wealth-privileged environments, and elitist expectations for prestigious clerkship, summer associate, and fellowship programs all systematically and disproportionately exclude aspiring attorneys who are disabled, negatively racialized, queer or trans, or low-income.Footnote 24
Our aim must therefore be not to simply make adjustments to the work environment to allow more disabled and LGBTQ+ people to work within the system more or less as it is already, but rather, to create a legal profession and community that considers the needs of all of its members. In particular, the legal profession must dispense with a model of education, training, and early career mentorship that fails to support its most marginalized members—many of whom also come from the same communities as the people most in need of legal assistance and advocacy, and least able to receive it. Ultimately, the jurisprudential traditions that govern our profession as it is now must change from the roots on upward. It is not enough simply to seek to reform the system. We must replace it with one that is actually responsive and accountable to the people who have been harmed the most by the system as it is, and who have the most to lose from any changes to come. Justice requires nothing less.
V. RECOMMENDATIONS
Making this vision a reality will depend on research that allows for the development of effective solutions, along with the political will necessary throughout the legal community to implement such broad systemic changes. Unfortunately, there is no indication that discrimination will wait for research to catch up, or that the sort of measures that the profession has already tried will suddenly become more effective in the meantime.
In the interim, therefore, we as members of the disability and LGBTQ+ communities as well as the legal profession make the following recommendations for how to more effectively respond to structural oppression in the workplace:
1. Employers Must Develop a Broader Understanding of What Workplace Diversity, Inclusion, and Accessibility Mean
Employers, and more specifically recruitment and human resources staff, need to be clear on the fact that true diversity and inclusion require ongoing effort. An individual employer or manager should therefore engage in their own research, if on a smaller scale than the authors of this study. This effort is especially crucial for staff at nonprofit agencies that specifically or disproportionately serve members of the same communities they are trying to recruit from, as their knowledge or ignorance will also affect how well their organization can serve their client base.
Research can include educating oneself on specific types of disabilities and relevant accommodations as well as universal design practices. Human resources and diversity professionals should also take the time to learn more about the communities they are seeking to recruit from, and especially about the experiences (in the workplace and more generally) of people living at the intersection of multiple forms of structural oppression. Organizations can and should pay members of the affected communities for professional consultations where possible. There is also a wealth of free material available online in the form of countless people’s personal accounts, webinars, and community discussions on various social media platforms.Footnote 25
2. Attorneys at All Levels of Seniority Must Demonstrate Solidarity with Other Marginalized Attorneys, Including Across Communities
Unfortunately, within every marginalized community, there are internal hierarchies that we can easily fall into upholding despite ourselves. Within the disability community, for instance, conventionally attractive people with physical or sensory disabilities enjoy a higher status than neurodivergent people, particularly those with highly stigmatized conditions such as bipolar disorder or psychosis as discussed earlier.Footnote 26 Similarly, a distressing phenomenon within the LGBTQ+ community is for more privileged members to disavow subsections of the community, specifically those that fall in the categories following the “LG” part of the acronym (in decreasing order of recognition and acceptance).Footnote 27 This is to say nothing of the antagonism between entirely different marginalized populations, including between the disability community and LGBTQ+ community as a whole.
It is no surprise, then, that many people whose identities leave them with only conditional acceptance amongst their colleagues attempt to safeguard or improve their status by perpetuating these divisions and internal hierarchies.Footnote 28 Counterintuitively in the context of our current, competitive culture, though, our position as individuals can only begin to feel less precarious if we challenge this dynamic to ensure that no type of person is inherently inadequate or unworthy of respect and inclusion. Effective resistance to division and disavowal can be as direct as standing up for colleagues facing discrimination and as everyday as refusing to make efforts to “pass” as able-bodied, neurotypical, straight, or cisgender.
3. Law Schools, Affinity Groups, and Mentors Must Promote Self-Advocacy Rather than Respectability Among Attorneys from Marginalized Communities
At the same time that legal professionals and organizations may recognize that structural oppression is a problem in a general sense, many still make the mistake of encouraging individual disabled, queer, or otherwise marginalized attorneys to accept or ignore rather than challenge discriminatory beliefs and practices. People and organizations with power will rarely, if ever, make the effort and sacrifice necessary to fix widespread problems that are beneficial, or even just comfortably familiar to them, no matter how much those with less attempt to fit in and appease them.Footnote 29 Therefore, teachers, senior attorneys, and professional associations should make a practice of helping younger attorneys self-advocate, even where the current norms of respectability and professionalism would require the contrary.
4. Institutions Within the Legal Profession Must Use Their Influence to End the Culture of Silence Around Workplace Discrimination
Organizational leaders all too often do not live up to the responsibilities of their positions by failing to hold employees accountable for creating a hostile workplace, sometimes even after repeated instances of discrimination. The widespread practice of buying the silence of victims through nondisclosure agreements, or simply through the threat of harming their reputation, further covers up, and therefore enables, workplace discrimination.Footnote 30 If queer and disabled attorneys are lucky enough to learn about longstanding patterns of discrimination at a given organization in advance of working there, it is generally only through private conversations with people who have experienced it firsthand and wish to remain anonymous.Footnote 31
As long as employers shield their institutional reputations by protecting workplace abusers at the expense of their victims, other institutions within the legal profession must stand up for its most vulnerable members. This can include providing training and advocacy to attorneys on how to avoid effectively coercive gag clauses in cases involving discrimination.Footnote 32 It could also involve such institutions deliberately but confidentially collecting information about marginalized attorneys’ experiences with local and large nationwide employers.Footnote 33 From there, they could put pressure on employers with known histories of discrimination to change by refusing to allow them to participate in events such as recruitment fairs or trainings, effectively excluding them from the legal community, until they remedy the source of the problem.
