In this edited volume, an intergenerational group of scholars approaches ways that Indigenous musicians have articulated modernity through engagements with a wide variety of genres circulating within and beyond Indigenous communities. Expanding critiques of modernity from Latour as well as post-colonial studies, the authors displace narratives that define Indigenous people as passive receivers of modernity and reevaluate notions of Indigenous people as “walking in two worlds.” Inverting Latour’s well-known adage, they show how Indigenous people have always been modern, constituting modernity in active practices of articulating tradition as well as engagements with imported genres. Redefining tradition as an active enactment and not a thing, they suggest that we follow hybrid articulations across genres and publics in which musics become icons of new forms of cosmopolitanism, available for circulation in social media, or accessible to political projects and alliances. While focused on North America, the volume has broad implications for how we might conceive of music and modernity in both Indigenous and settler contexts.
Following Heidi Aklaseaq Senungetuk’s prologue, which defines the volume as a context in which scholars of different generations and communities can share research about Indigenous musics today, Victoria Lindsay Levine’s introduction describes the various frameworks employed in the volume. Later chapters by Beverley Diamond, David Samuels, and Trevor Reed situate the authors’ discussions within careful practices of listening as well as critical approaches to modernity. Throughout, these chapters ask—as do the other contributors—how ethnomusicologists might develop a decolonial practice responsive to “resurgent and culturally specific methodologies” (12). Reinterpreting the iconic portrait of Mountain Chief interpreting song alongside Frances Densmore, Samuels suggests that we juxtapose Mountain Chief’s regalia, signifying modern practices of pan-Indigenous alliance, to Densmore’s vanishing Edwardian world: How might we see the modernity of both?
Several chapters in the volume describe Indigenous modernity in genres that create new forms of alliance and activism. Chapters by Christina Leza and T. Christopher Aplin discuss hip hop, showing how Indigenous hip hop artists create spaces in which people might form solidarity while remaining aware of conflicting senses of history and identity. As both authors argue, Indigenous MCs and DJs conjure the “real” as a threatened space of multiple, overlapping forms of struggle which can never be reduced to a single, local identity. Rather, the “real” is both an ancestral home and a shared, cosmopolitan space of alliances.
If Indigenous hip hop musicians produce grounded yet expansive alliances through sampling, juxtaposition, and code switching, musicians described in other chapters articulate an Indigenous voice in classical music (Avery), singer-songwriter-inspired folk pop (Hoefnagels), or in experimental sound art (Robinson). These musicians often defy expectations of how Indigenous music should sound or where it should be performed, creating pieces in which Indigenous logics confront settler-dominated spaces. Similarly, in her analysis of Inuit musics that provided “audio-reelism” for a reality TV show, Jessica Bissett Perea highlights how avoidance of musics that sound “traditional” to settler ears paralleled the world-making practices of airplane travel across the circumpolar north depicted in the show. As Bissett Perea notes, “we have always been actively engaged in using American musical life to our own radical ends” (197).
Other chapters address the remediation of traditional musics for a variety of social and political ends. While Gordon E. Smith explores the ways videorecording technology has augmented Mi’kmaw funeral practices, standardising elements of funeral performance, John-Carlos Perea describes how a university powwow ensemble confronts dominant assumptions of Indigenous assimilation and disappearance with sonic presence. Byron Dueck examines complicated alliances between powwow educators and the settler state. Although educators highlight the cultural efficacy of traditional practices, settler bureaucracies focus on their expediency to produce desired outcomes. How might this hybrid of Indigenous ceremonial practice and neoliberal education reform cohere? Answering this question requires ethnomusicologists to rely on cultural logics that stress relatedness without unanimity.
These logics stand out most clearly in Elyse Carter Vosen’s chapter, which follows the movement of round dances across the borders of nation-states, social contexts, and media. Describing the mediagenic and portable quality of round dances, Vosen highlights problems of alliance. Unlike scholars who might see cultural practices as a vehicle of political activism, she argues that because round dances created conditions to articulate Indigenous concerns within and against settler institutions while also extending relatedness with settler allies, “cultural practice is the activism itself” (112). As suggested throughout the volume, listening to Indigenous modernities might provide a framework for a decolonised ethnomusicology in which we face a changing, fractured world and “do something about it” (30).
Readers of the volume familiar with critical Indigenous studies will find its contents useful but notice a few lacunae. Although the authors wish to challenge dominant temporal orientations which consign Indigenous people to the status of relics of a vanishing past, they do not engage conversations on temporality in current work on Indigenous media. Several essays in the volume approach imbrications of Indigenous musics within dominant temporalities, either through protest, complicity, or both. Generally, this imbrication accompanies entanglement with settler states. However, apart from Dueck’s chapter, none of the essays critically approaches the state or discourses of sovereignty. This issue is most notable in Diamond’s and Reed’s chapters, where a critique of post-colonial approaches to alternative modernities could better take on post-colonial critics, who assume the state and its cultural entailments—fixed borders, bureaucracy, economic rationality, linear time—as the natural order of things. If post-colonial studies bring the nation-state back in as a repository (and nursery) for fostering alternative modernities, Indigenous decolonial practice, which often opposes the state, may create a different set of articulations between modernity and music.
Readers interested in North American Indigenous musics will find this book an essential resource for teaching and scholarship. As an ethnomusicologist working on Indigenous musics in the Pacific, I also recommend this book widely. Its case studies will be valuable for courses on Indigenous media and modernity, and its theoretical frameworks will provide room for dialogue among scholars working on Indigenous musics globally. Finally, the volume’s critiques of modernity will engage readers with interests in modernity and musical life.
