Each of the twelve chapters in this edited collection – from historians, political scientists and a human geographer, spanning Independence to the present day – explores a different aspect of the South's complex and often tortured relationship with the federal government. The collection challenges the current historiographical trend (in the work of Matthew D. Lassiter, Joseph Crespino, Byron E. Shafer and Richard Johnston) that refutes the notion of southern exceptionalism. In his introduction, Glenn Feldman reasserts that southern distinctiveness, even as he restates the significance of the South's role in American politics, society and culture. Split into five sections, this collection addresses the contradiction at the heart of the relationship between the South and the federal government: southern states' willingness to accept a disproportionate amount of federal aid, while persistently objecting to the encroaching and overreaching federal government. In doing so, the chapters – individually and collectively – make a powerful case for southern distinctiveness and illustrate the southernization of the relationship between non-southern states and the federal government.
In the first section, political scientist Thomas F. Schaller provides a brief overview of South Carolina's contentious relationship with the federal government from Revolution to the present day, through secession, the state's role in the Confederacy as “rebel among rebels” and Thurmond's Dixiecrat revolt. Part Two of the collection explores the relationship of the South with the federal government through the prisms of race, war and culture. Historian Zachary C. Smith offers a reexamination of Georgia's Tom Watson, suggesting that C. Van Woodward's depiction of Watson as an uncompromising reactionary overlooks Watson's commitment to populist issues – a commitment, Smith argues, that led to Watson working with the religious and racial minorities he so vociferously opposed. Jason Morgan Ward traces the success of racialized opposition to the New Deal, first articulated by Georgia governor Eugene Talmadge in 1936 only to be dismissed as a demagogic stunt. In an eloquent and persuasive chapter, Ward clearly illustrates how, from this unsuccessful beginning, southern conservatives built a racialized opposition to the New Deal order that was clothed in layers of rhetoric and incorporated into decades of southern opposition to the expansion of federal power. The remaining two chapters of Part Two explore the demise of the Solid South, both of them exploring new dimensions of the role of race in the shift of Mississippi's whites from the Democratic to the Republican Party. Rebecca Miller Davis documents the state's slow move away from the Democratic Party in the twenty years prior to the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Chris Danielson takes up the story after 1965, exploring the schism in the growing Mississippi Republican Party over the issue of attracting newly enfranchised African Americans.
In Part Three, two authors explore the alienation of the South from the federal government from very different perspectives. Fred Arthur Bailey provides a fascinating insight into the background of M. E. Bradford and into the impact of his theories on successive generations of conservative politicians and intellectuals. Human geographer David Jansson analyses the email correspondence of two southern nationalist organizations – the League of the South and the Southern National Congress – to provide an interesting perspective on the constructed image of the federal government as an “evil empire,” and a compelling argument for the South's fundamentally different and separate nature. In Part Four, Martin T. Olliff and Matthew L. Downs explore the contradictions at the heart of the relationship between the South and the federal government, while Gregory L. Richard explores the origins of federal court judge J. Smith Henley's role in transforming Arkansas's prison system. Olliff provides an insight into Alabama's relationship with the federal government in its acceptance of federal aid to build its roads, while Downs explores the role of the Tennessee Valley Authority in Decatur, Georgia. Moving beyond the simple, if contradictory, acceptance of the TVA's assistance, Downs's compelling account illustrates the complexity of the local–federal relationship as the TVA moved beyond its ideological foundation to support Decatur's leaders in pursuing the industrialization and modernization that would become characteristic of the Sunbelt.
In the final part of the collection, political scientists Allan B. McBride and Natalie Motise Davis use opinion-poll data to explore the contemporary relationship between the South and the federal government. McBride uses the polling data to suggest, perhaps prematurely, that the Tea Party is not distinctively southern or expressly racist, while noting the “southern tenor” of many Tea Party ideals and providing an interesting analysis of the Party structure. Finally, in a compelling chapter, Davis illustrates how the southern contempt for the federal government – resulting from southern traditions of self-reliance and individualism combined with fundamentalist faith – has been exported to the rest of the nation. This edited collection provides a powerful restatement of southern distinctiveness, as well as highlighting the many remaining avenues for exploration in the state–federal relationship, particularly in exploring differences in this relationship in Upper and Deep South states.
