When Adam Smith wrote the introduction to his Wealth of Nations, he marveled at the fact that “the produce of the whole labour of society is so great, that all are often abundantly supplied, and a workman, even the lowest and poorest order . . . may enjoy a greater share of the necessities and conveniences of life than it is possible for any savage to acquire.” In this intellectual tradition, there was a sense that the problems introduced by modernity could be largely solved by growing the economy and meeting material needs in abundance. Yet in many ways, without downplaying the obvious importance of satisfying material needs, this appeal to the greater productivity supplied by the modern organization of the commercial economy was destined to be incomplete—individual happiness would ultimately rest on more than the mere satisfaction of material needs. Modern human beings required something less easily measured, but of equal or even greater importance: they needed, in the words of Benjamin Storey and Jenna Silber Storey, to find “contentment” in an increasingly unsettled age.
The Storeys’ book is framed by an introduction and conclusion that draw attention to students confronting existential questions: in a world characterized by “an excess of options” (181), young people can quickly become overwhelmed. By freeing individuals from caste prescriptions, modernity has made it easy to get lost amid the vast landscape of life choices. But what students most want to achieve through their choices is this “contentment” or happiness that should be the “birthright” to “pursue happiness wherever it leads” (x). The pressing question facing people—young and old—however, is, Where do we find this elusive contentment? In appealing to some of the major modern Francophone writers—Montaigne, Pascal, Rousseau, and Tocqueville—the Storeys outline four distinct paths to contentment, each with its own set of virtues and vices. These four paths represent the book's core.
It should be said before proceeding that this book is aimed less at providing striking new readings of its four central figures than at using these figures to create a coherent and compelling narrative about the modern quest for happiness, one that will resonate with many readers in a personal way. Thus this book is likely to find its greatest impact in the hands of thoughtful undergraduates and lifelong learners than in dissertation footnotes. This is in no way intended to detract from the book. It is rather a statement of genre. In the words of Benjamin Storey in a recent interview with Jeffrey Church in his Political Theory Review podcast, the authors seek to craft a kind of philosophical self-help book.
The Storeys begin their narrative with a careful examination of Michel de Montaigne's quest for “immanent contentment.” It was Montaigne's fate to arrive amid countless social changes (sociopolitical, economic, geopolitical, etc.)—and it was his great challenge to provide a path to the contented life in this unsettled context. His response to this challenge was to lower humanity's aims, so to speak, abandon the quest for the transcendent, and embrace the “ordinary life.” The Storeys depict the figure of “immanent contentment” as one who eschews the lofty ambitions (or pretensions) of the ancients in favor one of who “delights in every human pleasure” (28), placing a premium on being “present in the moment but also dispassionate, at ease, and in balance” (3). As the Storeys skillfully observe, the life given to these pleasures presages the liberal and democratic character that would emerge more than a century after Montaigne.
While the portrait of “immanent man” suggests insouciance, the book's next figure, Blaise Pascal, suggests it rests perilously on a foundation of diversion from the deeper problems that plague humanity's inner life. While people may pursue pleasures in the way Montaigne advises, this conceals the fact that “they are secretly miserable” (64). The natural and proper condition of humanity, for Pascal, is grief. So for him, the quest for knowledge and thereby a contented soul “can begin only with the honest acknowledgement of our unhappiness” (66). It is only by coming to terms with our despondency that we can transcend Montaignean superficiality and achieve genuine happiness as true Christians (94). Happiness, for Pascal, is not to be found in running away from our problems, but only in confronting them.
For the Storeys’ Rousseau, there is some truth in both Montaigne and Pascal. From Pascal, Rousseau accepts that humanity is prone to a “dismal psychic condition” (102), placing particular emphasis on the suffering imposed by one upon another, propelled by amour-propre. Yet from Montaigne, there is the possibility of contentment to be derived from the here and now. In order to transcend our dismal condition, Rousseau explores multiple routes to contentment—the heroic citizen, the contented couple, moral self-contentment found in philosophical contemplation and in the radically solitary life. Suffice it to say, and following the lead of scholars such as Jason Neidleman, Mark Cladis, and Steven Johnston, the Storeys conclude that each of these paths is destined to fail. Despite the inventive ways in which Rousseau has personally sought to achieve his own happiness, he has discovered that they are all fatally flawed, and that we cannot truly escape our inevitable discontent.
The final object of this study, Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America, describes the American quest for happiness in a nascent democratic age. The Storeys’ Tocqueville describes Montaigne's quest for “immanent contentment” as possible for everyone, rather than one reserved for a narrow elite with adequate resources for the pursuit of personal happiness. Yet as with Rousseau, they perceive in Tocqueville citizens burdened with “Pascalian malaise” (144). Even as Americans achieved greater equality and prosperity, they have not cured their own restlessness. The constant need to work and the materialism that accompanies it leaves Americans feeling lonely, disconnected, shallow, vulgar, and envious.
As suggested above, this book is not written so much to present pathbreaking interpretations of its main thinkers as to tell a compelling narrative about the quest for self-knowledge and contentment that continues to this day. And in its chosen ambition, the book is a great success. The Storeys write both with clarity and with an eye to telling a story that should resonate with any readers inclined to engage these questions themselves. How can we achieve happiness, if at all? What is to be gained in pursuing one path to self-knowledge and happiness over another? What pitfalls await us down the various paths? These are the time-honored questions that constitute the Francophone tradition the Storeys describe so compellingly. While this may be a kind of self-help book, it surely represents the best kind of work that can be achieved in this genre today—a story that compels its readers to take stock of their own life choices in the face of the many challenges that confront modern life.
