Influenced by Daniel James' Resistance and Integration, a group of historians propose in The New Cultural History of Peronism ‘to demonstrate the potential of a theoretically informed cultural history to chart a course … and to produce a richer understanding of Peronism’ (p. 2). The book partly fulfils its promise. Its introduction to cultural history, with its references to Geertz, Hunt et al., treads over some rather familiar ground, though it provides a good review of a quarter-century of production that will undoubtedly be useful to students new to the cultural turn in historical scholarship. The chapters that follow offer a kaleidoscopic portrait of Peronism's presence in Argentine society, covering mass culture in radio and film (Matthew Karush), racial attitudes (Natalia Milanesio), indigenous peoples (Diana Lenton), folklore (Oscar Chamosa), architecture (Anahi Ballent), public ritual (Mirta Lobato, María Damilakou and Lizel Tornay), consumer culture (Eduardo Elena) and political militancy (César Seveso).
What stands out in the chapters collectively is Peronism's appearance in manifold sites and its protean capacity to articulate diverse societal aspirations and grievances, clearly demonstrating, if there were still any doubters, that it is the crucible to understanding the country's modern history. Mariano Plotkin's excellent final chapter highlights the contribution to the subject made by the volume but also injects some common sense into the pretensions of cultural history. How precisely does an historian assess the impact of ‘emotion’ on politics? Emotions, after all, are not a monopoly of Peronism. Can other examples of political violence besides the Peronist resistance – say, the state terrorism of the 1970s – be explained simply, or even mainly, as a question of emotion? As Plotkin aptly notes, ‘memory’ is not the same as ‘history’ – and nor is ‘melodrama’ a replacement for the more traditional subjects historians have studied to explain a phenomenon such as Peronism. One of the problems of writing the cultural history of Latin America is that, unlike the case of European and US historiography, the approach has lacked an engagement with economic and social history; indeed, it has treated ‘culture’ as if such things do not matter. Europeanist and North Americanist historians have produced some superb cultural studies precisely because these studies have been written in implicit dialogue with the findings of economic and social historians. Very little of the ‘new’ Latin American cultural history has been produced in this way, preferring to dismiss the approach, rather superficially, as ‘structuralism’. Culture surely can help to explain certain things, but culture standing alone may obscure as much as it reveals.
Though original, interesting and uniformly well executed, the essays, as history, thus do have a few limitations. The authors present some suggestive research, but most of the chapters rely heavily on published sources, newspapers and interviews. Untapped archival collections exist for this period, especially in the provinces, but only a few new discoveries are revealed in the chapters. So while the perspective in the collection is novel, the research is, for the most part, much less so. More importantly, the book, very insightful in probing Peronist identity, is less convincing (despite its subtitle) in explaining the dynamics of power (their concrete dynamics, not just their discursive or symbolic renderings), as well as in accounting for change over time – though it should be added that this is a weakness not so much of this particular volume but of cultural history in general. Cultural historians provide interesting but also rather static snapshots; they also tend to look for those unusual, even obscure subjects that normally fall outside mainstream scholarship's purview. This volume certainly succeeds in its search for and deft treatment of recondite themes. It ably demonstrates Peronism's penetration into all realms of Argentine national life, sometimes in the most unexpected places. All of this again makes for a novel perspective and a very engaging read. If asked to assign a book on Peronism for an undergraduate survey, I might well choose this one.
Yet the volume ultimately does not recast our understanding of Peronism beyond providing a much broader picture that demonstrates its presence in these very different sites. Part of the problem here is indeed a rather reductive understanding of what comprises ‘culture’, confined largely to identity questions. If the authors had considered culture to include certain very Peronist forms of political recruitment or had examined persistent Peronist practices in dealing with labour, business, the military and the Church, we would be closer to getting at the relationship between ‘power’ and culture. The great historical questions on the Perón governments of the 1940s and 1950s, the ones that made Argentina the country it would become, are not addressed by the collection and remain to be studied. Peronist labour legislation and the workings of the labour courts are one area that immediately comes to mind; a post-Potash study of the Argentine military is another. There is undoubtedly a cultural component to each of those vitally important subjects. So while The New Cultural History of Peronism does offer original insights and interesting vignettes on Peronism and on a very eclectic range of topics – everything from beauty queens to rural folklore to architectural kitsch – it does not really address the big questions on the subject. In that sense, Peronism remains in many ways, and despite the voluminous literature surrounding it, the hecho maldito of modern Argentina's historical scholarship.
