The principal thesis of this book is that Gerald Fitzmaurice was an influential figure before World War I at the British embassy in Constantinople and, to a lesser extent, during the war in London with British Intelligence. The author, G. R. Berridge, of the University of Leicester, has written and/or edited twelve books on the theory and practice of diplomacy, the United Nations, and South Africa. He identifies Fitzmaurice as a “Minister of the Second Order” who, like Machiavelli, became more important than the ambassador, as noted in the late 17th century by Abraham de Wicquefort in his L'Ambassadeur et Ses Fonctions. In the 1990s, Berridge started a history of the British embassy in the Ottoman Empire since 1583 but stopped to become an associate editor of the (New) Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (ODNB) and to take responsibility for 20th-century diplomatists. Unable to find someone to do the Fitzmaurice article for the ODNB, Berridge did it himself.
Because Fitzmaurice left no papers, Berridge made extensive use of Foreign Office records in the National Archives (Kew), relevant memoirs, and many articles and books that have been published on British relations with the Ottoman Empire during the first two decades of the 20th century. Berridge also drew upon several collections of private papers, especially those of George Lloyd at the Churchill Archival Centre, University of Cambridge, with fifty letters from Fitzmaurice. Thanks to Caroline Mullan, the Irish archivist to whom he dedicates this book, Berridge discovered material about Fitzmaurice's background, early life, and education in Ireland. Berridge relies more on the sources than the opinions of Fitzmaurice or how he was viewed by his contemporaries in Constantinople and London, as well as by historians today. By avoiding sweeping judgments, Berridge can present the ups and downs as well as the personal pettiness and careerism surrounding this controversial figure.
In “Young Turks, Freemasons, and Jews,” an article that appeared in 1971 in his journal, Middle East Studies, Elie Kedourie writes that Fitzmaurice's “fustian fantasies” exaggerated Jewish influence over the Young Turks, a view endorsed by Bernard Lewis. Although Fitzmaurice and others exaggerated Masonic and Jewish collusion with the Young Turks, Berridge does not regard Fitzmaurice as mad or stupid, much less ill informed about the Young Turks. This reviewer published Mark Sykes: Portrait of an Amateur (London: Jonathan Cape, 1975) about another secondary British figure about whom opinion still remains divided. Like Fitzmaurice, Sykes was a Roman Catholic who distrusted Masons and Jews before 1914 and backed Zionism during World War I. Before the war, Sykes was a much less influential figure than Fitzmaurice at the British embassy, where he served briefly as an honorary attaché in Constantinople. However, as a Conservative member of parliament from 1911 who was tied first to Lord Kitchener, then to Lloyd George, and finally to Balfour's Foreign Office, Sykes was much more influential in London during the war than Fitzmaurice. The influence and views of Fitzmaurice and Sykes shifted with circumstances, as Berridge makes clear in his account of Fitzmaurice.
Before World War I, Fitzmaurice finally achieved his ambition to become the chief dragoman at the British embassy in Constantinople. Son of a middle-class Catholic family with business connections on the continent, Fitzmaurice was an outstanding pupil in Dublin, where he distinguished himself in ancient and modern languages. Upon graduation, he gave up his plans to enter the priesthood and applied to become an interpreter in the Levant Consular Service, passing exams along with some twenty other unmarried young men to be trained to replace native dragomans, subjects of the sultan who had served as interpreters and intermediaries between British diplomats and Ottoman officials. For two years the British government paid Fitzmaurice to learn Turkish, Russian, Arabic, and other “Oriental” languages from native teachers at a modest school in a village near Constantinople, with weekly trips to Constantinople to read law.
On passing the exams, most student interpreters were attached to vice consulates before joining more important consular posts in the Ottoman Empire, Persia, Morocco, and Greece. However, Fitzmaurice's colloquial Turkish led to his becoming in 1880 a consular assistant at the embassy in Constantinople, where his career was largely based until World War I. He was posted to eastern Anatolia in the mid-1890s, when forced conversions and massacres of Armenians peaked, then to the southeastern part of the Arabian peninsula, when Yemen's frontier had to be sorted out with Aden, and finally to Tripoli in 1912, when Italy's defeat of the Turks was recognized by Britain.
During all those decades in Constantinople, moving from the British embassy in Pera to sultan Abdülhamit's palace and to the grand vizier's office at the Porte, Fitzmaurice made himself indispensable not only to the consulate but also to British ambassadors. Fitzmaurice was a great storyteller, but most people soon tired of his stories. Berridge documents that Fitzmaurice knew as much as any British person did about the situation on the spot, but his Irish Catholic background, scruffy appearance, and rough manner and voice kept him out of the highest diplomatic circles in Constantinople and later in London, even after he had become the chief dragoman at the British embassy in 1907. Fitzmaurice worked very hard to fill various roles and had views of his own from the Young Turk Revolution in the summer of 1908 to the outbreak of war with the Turks in the fall of 1914. This book makes it clear that it is a gross simplification to label Fitzmaurice pro-Old Turk and anti-Young Turk.
Berridge contributes less to our understanding of Fitzmaurice and the role he played for the British during World War I. This may come from wartime London being such a vastly different context than the British embassy in Constantinople before 1914. This may arise from the secrecy surrounding Fitzmaurice's work for naval intelligence and the political department of the Foreign Office, not to mention special assignments, where he was usually passed over by most of the individuals and agencies involved with British war policy. After the war, the impecunious, chain-smoking, and hook-nosed Fitzmaurice was dismissed as too eccentric by most people. He died in relative obscurity.
