Andreas Wimmer’s two most recent books represent some of the best of recent scholarship on ethnicity and nationalism and should become parts of the canon of these fields. In Ethnic Boundary Making, Wimmer argues for the analytic value of Frederick Barth’s concept of marking and maintaining ethnic boundaries. In Waves of War, Wimmer expands on the theme that he had advanced previously of “like over like” as an essential standard for legitimacy in modern political orders. Each is an expansive work, full of diverse ideas and methodologies. As exemplars of the best in these fields, these books also, however, make clear what challenges lie ahead for scholarly inquiry. This review can only suggest the outlines of both books and highlight a few of the larger opportunities for further work.
In Ethnic Boundary Marking, Wimmer promises that Barth’s concept gives analytic purchase on the processes by which social interactions among individuals form and reform ethnic groups, establish the content and significance of groups, and define the contexts in which ethnic boundaries are relevant (and where they are not). Ethnicity—a distinction that he uses so as to include race—is a subjective bond among those who share common culture and ancestry. The chief constraints that define the location and relevance of boundaries include 1) state institutions; 2) the distribution of economic, political, and cultural resource endowments; and 3) networks for sharing information about jobs. The book promises to steer a middle course between Johann Gottfried Herder’s three Cs of culture, community, and categorization and the Constructivists’ four Cs of construction, context, contestation, and contingency (p. 204). It promises to sort out the distinct effects of race, ethnicity, and other similarities (and differences) on social relations. The book further promises methodologies that do not privilege ethnicity, but permit us to discern which groups form, with what intensity, and in what situations (p. 38).
Wimmer explores the influence of ethnicity in three case studies, which give special weight to relations involving immigrant populations. The first (ibid., Chapter 5) explains attitudes toward one another among the Swiss and immigrant groups in three cantons. Swiss evaluations of other groups are shaped by their perceived closeness to or distance from “petit bourgeois” virtues such as cleanliness, punctuality, and decorum. The second case study (Chapter 6) explores Facebook networks among students at an American college. Mainstream white and black students do form a disproportionate share of their contacts within their respective ethnoracial groups, but other students are much more inclined to form friendships that cut across ethnoracial lines. Among the latter, nonethnic similarities, such as preferences for certain types of music, are often a more powerful source of social contacts (p. 164). The third (Chapter 7) studies the social values of different European ethnic groups, once again principally immigrant groups, in order to analyze their closeness to or distance from the national consensus in their countries of current residence. Religious and linguistic differences do not explain distance in social values, but patterns of political exclusion emerge as a major determinant that explains why some ethnic groups show greater divergence from national norms in second- rather than first-generation immigrants.
Waves of War is a comparative macrohistorical exploration of the global transformation from empires to nation-states that is often accompanied by interstate and intrastate warfare. Nations triumph, Wimmer argues, when the terms of exchange favor one institutional form over another—particularly when they are seen as fair (legitimate). The offer of public goods and political participation opportunities are key elements of this exchange relationship.
The four empirical studies in this book begin with (Chapter 2) the identification of different domestic alliances that lead to nation building (linking national elites with both local elites and publics), populist nationalism (linking national elites directly to publics but circumventing local elites), or ethnically divided states (excluding local minority elites and minority publics). The second study (Chapter 3) explains the timing of the triumph of popular sovereignty—when the state can first be said to rule in the name of the people. Wimmer finds that in today’s states, this timing was affected by the configuration of power within the ancien regime and by processes of intraempire and neighborhood diffusion. The third study (Chapter 4) reports that wars tend to spike during the institutional transformations of imperial incorporation and nation-state formation. The rise of empires is characterized by wars of conquest; the rise of nation-states is first associated with civil wars, but then with interstate wars as nationalizing states fight one another. The fourth (Chapter 5) studies the relationship between ethnic power configurations within states and the likelihood of civil war, finding, for example, that states practicing greater political exclusion of ethnic groups experience more rebellion, but that greater numbers of parties to power sharing bring infighting.
As representatives of some of the best scholarship in the fields of ethnicity and nationalism, Ethnic Boundary Marking and Waves of War also make clear the major challenges that all of us in these fields must address in future research. Most important is coming to terms with ethnicity itself. Despite the title of the first book, the investigations are not about ethnic boundary making linked to the defining qualities of ethnicity—culture and ancestry. Instead, they are about relations among ethnic groups and the deployment of ethnicity in various public contexts (such as the formation of friendships). Yet we receive no explanation for the origin of ethnicity in the first place. The irony in this book is that for Wimmer’s projects, despite his disclaimer, ethnicity is a predetermined category that could even be primordial. For all of us, a challenge is explaining ethnic boundary making in the sense of why some lines of culture or ancestry become reified as ethnic groups in the first place.
A second challenge is to understand the relationship of ethnicity to nationhood. At the very least we need conceptual precision; it would also help to arrive at conventional definitions for such concepts as ethnicity and nationhood so that research is truly cumulative. I thought that I share Wimmer’s definitions that ethnicity concerns shared ancestry and culture and that nationhood concerns a right of populations to govern themselves within states. Yet as in so many studies in our field, ethnic groups and nations become conflated in actual applications. Wimmer introduces nationalism as the claim of popular sovereignty that “like should rule over like” (Ethnic, p. 90), which I had thought means that the nation (the body of citizens) should rule. This leads to confusion, however, when the author then seamlessly moves to the analysis of ethnic rule and transforms this “like-over-like” principle into the claim that ethnic groups should only be governed by coethnics. I had thought that whether the nation is one ethnic group, a few ethnic groups, or all citizens of the state is the subject of a debate that arises among political actors within the like-over-like principle. Social scientists need to explain why, rather than assume that, one of these views trumps the others in different contexts.
A third challenge in the fields of ethnicity and nationalism is rigorous theory. Both books represent important steps in this direction, and yet they seem to avoid the close attention to logical progression from definitions and assumptions to testable hypotheses to which we aspire. In Ethnic Boundary Marking, Wimmer promises us a theory (Chapter 4), but by the end of the book describes his contribution as a “model” or more loosely as an “analytic framework” that sets the conceptual building blocks for others to build many theories (p. 111). By trying to be applicable to a broad range of empirical circumstances, the analytic framework in this book falls prey to two different shortcomings. First, there are so many elements introduced that it is difficult to see what is excluded. It is unclear whether we have made a step toward greater theoretical parsimony. Second, the framework leaves it to others to provide the analytic rigor that brings the building blocks together in theories that explain (“predict”) causal relationships. Alternatively, Waves of War may not have enough theoretical development to make the case studies sum to a coherent point. The four previously published articles that constitute the empirical chapters in this work appear to have been written originally without a common theoretical framework.
Furthermore, a fourth challenge is more precise data. It may seem ironic to raise such a question when a hallmark of these books is artful analyses of data sets that are so well executed. Indeed, by the combination of their richly diverse methodologies, both books demonstrate the opportunities for innovative methodologies in the study of ethnicity and nationalism. Yet one is left with the reservation that either the researchers did not collect the data sets they needed to answer the questions posed, or that the questions have somehow been reframed for the purposes of statistical analyses but the inferences to be drawn from the empirical results are not at all what are being claimed. For example, in Waves of War, Wimmer’s dependent variable in his second study may not be the triumph of nations, and instead may be the triumph of the principle of popular sovereignty—particularly, democratization. In addition, because his cases select on outcomes—that is, Wimmer defines his units of analysis as states existing in 2001—he is unable to study which societies make this transition and which do not. He, instead, answers the question: Among states that completed the transition to popular sovereignty, when did this take place? And in the same book, he engages in a surprising amount of ecological inference in which the statistical unit of analysis is the state, but the conclusions drawn concern individual ethnic groups.
These are important works. Their ambition leaves them open to many small criticisms, but these are not works that deserve a “death by a thousand cuts.” Both books make contributions that move the fields of ethnicity and nationalism forward conceptually, theoretically, and empirically, in pursuit of scientific progress. On these all-so-important standards, both are outstanding successes.
