‘This book is a companion to learning how to teach music. It is intended to provide support, guidance, ideas and challenges for student educators and teacher educators of all types’ (p. 1). Although presented as a Second Edition, and with the same cover and binding as its predecessor (Philpott, Reference PHILPOTT2000), this is, more or less, an entirely new book. In this sense I feel that the publishers have a missed a trick, as owners of the first edition are likely to want to buy this for its new chapters, but may be put off thinking that only minor tweaking has taken place, whereas nothing could be further from the truth.
The title too could be considered as having misplaced emphasis, in that this book is not so much a primer for beginners, as a comprehensive survey of contemporary Music Education in the UK and beyond. This point is recognised to some extent by the editors when they observe ‘learning to teach music is a lifelong process’ (p. 3).
This book places itself as a key text in teacher education, with contributions from teacher trainers, music educators and classroom practitioners. As with many worthwhile edited collections, the whole is greater than the sum of its parts, yet it is in those parts that the content lies, and is likely to be of interest to BJME readers, so I shall begin atomistically by considering the various chapters.
Finney's opening chapter takes us through a potted history of how we got to where we have, in terms of music education, and simultaneously invites the reader to reflect on how we got to this position. For many potential trainee music teachers, and, indeed, for many in-service teachers, his questions will be very relevant, including the worthwhile-ness of music education, the place of jazz, pop, and rock music, the purpose of staff notation, and the ideology of the music classroom.
In the second chapter Spruce picks up many of the issues posited by Finney, and adds a cultural dimension. Here the reader is challenged to reflect on what it means to think about societal pressure on consumption of music. This includes asking questions as to the different valorisations of musical literacy in and between cultural groups. This forces teachers to think about what it is they value, and why it should be part of their curriculum, because, as Spruce puts it ‘. . . a too narrow conception of what music is can lead to an impoverished model of music teaching and learning’ (p. 27).
The issue of musical learning and musical development is obviously a key one for music education, and yet one whose deeper questions are difficult to answer! In Chapter 3 Philpott endeavours to do just this. This chapter, although aimed squarely at PGCE trainee teachers, is nonetheless one which all involved in music education would find it worthwhile to revisit, as there seems to be a danger that perpetual ‘doing’ can mean that learning is lost sight of, and that learning outcomes are not the same as task outcomes. The identification of three key types of knowledge in music (‘about’, ‘how’ and ‘of’), which is picked up elsewhere in the book, seems particularly helpful to those about to start planning lessons for the first time.
Dim and distant as those times seem now to some of us, there is a generation of teachers who have never known life outside of the National Curriculum. Cain takes us back to these times, and describes some of the furore surrounding its introduction, before going on to unpick key aspects of the National Curriculum for beginning teachers. Although the National Curriculum is changing again, many of Cain's comments on interpretation and levels remain apposite, and this is another useful chapter for trainee teachers.
Chapters 5 and 6 describe aspects of teaching music at KS4, and at post-16 level. These seem to be important chapters for trainee teachers, in that new pedagogies for exam group teaching are sorely needed in music, if we are not to simply replicate the ways in which teachers were taught themselves. Twenty-first century curricula require twenty-first century pedagogies, and these sections should help trainee teachers rethink and challenge ways in which they were taught. Hopefully the focus in the GCSE chapter on an integrated approach should help with this. I was less convinced by some of the post-16 chapter, and reading that ‘Pupils can learn any simple harmonisations by rote’ (p. 79) did not seem to be a useful methodology if we are teaching for understanding, but other writing here did examine the notion of placing knowledge of music at the heart of working.
Spruce's chapter on lesson planning should be essential reading for all trainee music teachers. It is all too easy for trainee music teachers to confuse ‘keeping them busy’ with learning, and this harks back to the messages of the third chapter. In this present chapter Spruce unpicks many aspects of planning, from initial thoughts, through to writing meaningful evaluations. This leads nicely into the next chapter (again by Philpott) on management and organisation of learning. This deals with issues from the basic, such as of organisation of tables, through to dealing with group work. Veering dangerously towards ‘tips for teachers’ at times, ‘some instruments are heavy . . .’ (p. 117), nonetheless experience of trainee teachers shows that the blindingly obvious does sometimes needs saying! The net effect is that Chapters 3, 5 and 6 act as useful preparatory work for trainee music teachers, dealing as they do with theoretical and practical issues.
The notion of creativity can be a problematic construct in music education, and in the next chapter Philpott acknowledges this, posing a series of questions to the reader. Here I feel that an opportunity was lost to engage trainee teachers in reflecting on cultural aspects of creativity in music, and add ‘whose creativity?’ to the list of questions. Thus creativity in the Western Classical tradition is different from, say, a Nigerian approach, or a Northern Indian approach. All of these, and more, will be met by trainees in schools, where a particular focus on domain specific creativity (Csikszentmihalyi, Reference CSIKSZENTMIHALYI1996, Reference CSIKSZENTMIHALYI and Sternberg1999) may not be helpful if that domain solely involves Western individualism.
Moving from creativity, Savage then takes our attention towards another key element of music education, that of performance, and asks, pace Reimer (Reference REIMER1994) ‘is musical performance worth saving?’. I wonder, along with Savage, why recording performance still seems to be an issue, despite the straightforward nature of the technology nowadays. But Savage goes further than this, and asks some telling questions, which trainee teachers would de well to reflect upon. There is still a case to be made that many prospective music teachers have arrived via a primarily performing route, without questioning many aspects of that. Reading this chapter should make them really think about what it is that performing entails in the music classroom.
Having considered composing and performing, Spruce takes us to the third domain of National Curriculum music, that of listening and appraising (although it is interesting to note that appraising has been downplayed in the new National Curriculum (QCA 2007) in favour of evaluating). This is, in many ways, quite a difficult issue for trainee teachers to get to grips with. Thus the thorny issue of meaning in music is approached from a variety of standpoints, and the fact that there is, and can be, no single meaning thoroughly explored. Demonstrating responses to music ‘. . . is likely to be most at its authentic and illuminating if such responses take place through musical activity’ (p. 158).
In many ways Philpott's next contribution, on ‘language and learning in music’, can be seen as an extension of his earlier work in chapter 3. This chapter concerns itself with how pupils evidence their knowledge through the use of language. It also explores how technical language can be appropriately used. A useful thinking point for trainee teachers occurs when the reader is asked to ‘choose a piece of music and describe it without the use of technical jargon or musical vocabulary’ (p. 164). This is something beginning teachers find very difficult, as they have become accustomed to thinking for themselves in technical terms. Some of them also seem to believe they think using staff notation, a point which Philpott again asks them to challenge, observing ‘. . . notation is not a musical language itself . . .’ (p. 172).
Chapter 13 deals with ICT, and for many teachers, trainee or in-post, one piece of advice from Crow on its use will ring true ‘Never assume that a piece of technology is going to work’. This in itself seems to act as a barrier for the use of technology, which is a shame, as this chapter contains much useful information and advice. One of the common problems is that no two schools are alike in their provision, and so a ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach cannot work. This Crow elegantly avoids by focusing on the musical potential of software and hardware.
One of the purposes of this book is to provide a subject-specific companion to the more general course book Learning to Teach in the Secondary School (Capel et al., Reference CAPEL and LEASK2005), and the chapter on Individual needs and Equality of Opportunity by Wright forces the trainee to think about issues like these, which are discussed the main text, with specific reference to music. We know that for many trainees this can be problematic, and this chapter does force trainees to address these issues, but, sadly, has to cover a wide range of content in a fairly limited space.
This leads us to the thorny issue of assessment, and its role in music education. Here Philpott steers the trainee gently through the potential minefield of National Curriculum levels, GCSE criteria, and the appropriateness (or otherwise) of formative and summative assessment purposes. It is good to note that Philpott makes no excuses for assessment being problematic, and for trainees this realisation is a key one. Assessment should be bound up in teaching, and the notion that ‘. . . assessment is not a ‘bolt-on’ to the process of learning and teaching . . .’ (p. 210) is welcome. Also welcome is Philpott's gentle admonishment to teachers not to level everything in lessons, and to use the level statements to form the basis of ‘best-fit’ judgements.
All too often we still hear the cry ‘they did nothing much at primary school, so we start again’. Coll's chapter on transition should be forcible reading for these teachers! Coll argues cogently that this impression can often be due to lack of information about work done, rather than a lack of work done. This again is a message trainee teachers need to take to heart. Just because pupils do not know technical terms does not mean they lack the concept, this is a point where the signifier has become the sign in the mind of the teacher. Do 11-year-old pupils really not have a concept of volume?
The new National Curriculum for music (QCA, 2007) widens the scope and remit of music education in the secondary school, and in two chapters looking beyond the classroom, Evans and Adams respectively discuss different aspects of the wider role of music. Evans deals with the nature of instrumental learning, a feature of schools which many trainee teachers can be reluctant to exploit. This chapter will also make useful reading for those involved in peripatetic music teaching, as integration is a two-sided construct in this case. Adams discusses collaborative partnerships, an activity which the new National Curriculum seems likely to privilege, and which is likely to make this chapter highly apposite for those in-post who are grappling with these issues.
Finally there are some useful appendices to help trainees get to grips with initial visits and primary school links, both of which need careful handling in order to point trainees in knowing what to look for.
So, that is a brief overview of the chapters, what of the book as a whole? This is likely to be a core text for PGCEs across the country, and will be useful for all such courses. whether at level 6 or the new Masters’ equivalent level 7 courses. It should be a useful addition to the library of all those involved in music education, whether or not they are involved in training teachers. For mentors in schools it will prove helpful in providing a common framework of understanding, and will also be of use to professional or general mentors in understanding some of the complexities of training to be a music teacher today. Inevitably with so many contributors there are differences in tone and emphasis, and some unlikely philosophical bedfellows can be found cohabiting, but as a broad and wide-ranging survey of current thinking in music education this has a great deal to offer. My only reservation, as I outlined above, is that the ‘second edition’ feeling about the book might put off potential buyers.
