Palestinian women have been under the microscope since the first Palestinian intifada in 1987. The multiple heroic roles these women have played as mothers and fighters have been centers of research, as well as literary inspirations for many women, revolutionaries, and freedom seekers around the world. Yet Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian's work is a bitter reminder that cultural assumptions in Western scholarship on and analyses of Palestinian and Arab women's status have not changed much.
In sharp contrast to Western media depictions of Palestinian women in the Israeli-occupied Palestinian Territories as silenced, defeated, and powerless, or as terrorists, Shalhoub-Kevorkian gives voice to these women's defiance of both the occupation and patriarchal oppression. She portrays them as fighters, political prisoners, activists, mothers, educators, frontliners, and so on. Palestinian women's reactions to the complexity of occupation, war, and victimization are told in terms of the strategies they develop to survive what the author describes as “the ordeal.” Their lives are shaped and reshaped in military zones in brutal ways, and yet their travails have pushed them to create new methods for resisting and surviving. Shalhoub-Kevorkian's work gives voice to the voiceless: women whose lives are ruined by checkpoints, the Separation Wall, daily humiliations, displacement, unemployment, violence, and death.
Shalhoub-Kevorkian employs several feminist approaches to analyze stories gathered from women in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, and East Jerusalem during fieldwork completed between 1999 and 2007. She combines a feminist genealogist approach with research methods that include in-depth interviews, observations, clinical examinations, and focus groups. One striking aspect of this work is the author's decision to eschew a convention of researchers to distance themselves from their research subjects. As a Palestinian woman, Shalhoub-Kevorkian instead injects herself into the narrative. When she experiences humiliation at a checkpoint or faces other forms of violence related to the occupation, her voice echoes those of the women in her study. Her own experience of “the ordeal” becomes an integral expression of the challenges facing Palestinian women in the Occupied Territories.
Through four chapters, an introduction, and a conclusion the author demonstrates hard work and sensitivity to these women's conditions and to “moral” questions that are mostly ignored in academic research. She asks, for example, “how can I ensure that everyone will remember” the suffering of the “colonized, raced, classed and sexualized” (p. 208) women who are not only unheard but also silenced, ignored, and represented in distorted ways.
The author's discussion of Palestinian masculinity is particularly interesting. Echoing Julie Peteet's work, Shalhoub-Kevorkian argues that masculinity and violence were not historically linked in the Palestinian case. Masculinity was instead expressed through the man's ability to protect his family and to meet “familial and social demands.” Both men and women were more willing to “die than to kill” for the sake of living (p. 99). However, during the intifada, and especially after 2000, every space was violated—schools, homes, hospitals—and women's bodies became targets of control, subject to masculine and military power. The fear of rape and sexual abuse by occupying soldiers against Palestinian women led Palestinian men and Palestinian society to impose restrictions on women on the basis that the latter needed protection. Thus, women's freedom was curtailed, their movements were restricted, and early marriages were encouraged. Frustration at the occupation, external violence, and violation of the private and public spheres often led Palestinian men to commit domestic violence and abuse.
With a passionate voice, the author tells us a different story of women who “create both a space and a discourse of ‘betweenness’” (p 94). The quotes of the women interviewees that she includes demonstrate that they are warriors, resisters, and agents of social and political change. Yet, they are also subject to social, political, and physical abuse from occupation forces and men in their own communities.
