Despite its wealth of natural resources and political promise at the time of independence, the majority of sub-Saharan African countries subsequently fell into decades of economic decline, despotism, and war. And yet, Africa now sits on the precipice of a remarkable renaissance; of citizens gaining political voice through widespread democratization and of long-desired economic development through the acceptance of free market economics. In Africa Emerges, Robert I. Rotberg recounts both the opportunities and challenges manifest in this time of transformation, arguing that the choices leaders make today will determine whether their countries can indeed break with the past.
According to Rotberg, Africa's greatest opportunity, as well as its greatest challenge, is demographic. An expected population boom—by the end of the century the populations of Nigeria, Kenya, and Malawi, among others, are predicted to more than triple (22–23)—will create a youth bulge that could fuel economic growth, as happened in Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea, and Taiwan. That youth bulge, however, will simultaneously place increasing stresses on still weak economies, shrinking agricultural lands, already inadequate public health and transportation infrastructures, and shaky new democratic governments. In the absence of expanded educational and job opportunities, the frustrated and unemployed young might also turn to black markets and armed gangs, increasing existing problems with drug trafficking and civil conflict.
Much of Africa Emerges is devoted to outlining these challenges that must be tackled and overcome in order for Africa to turn its demographic bulge into a dividend. Many countries are burdened by a tropical climate with its attendant diseases, pests, and poor soil quality that dampen productivity. Educational opportunities across the continent are few. Severe teacher shortages, limited places for qualified applicants in secondary schools and universities, and high educational gender gaps afflict nearly every African country (58). Historically venal leadership combined with ethnic discrimination and economic deprivation has left a legacy of devastating wars. Corruption is rampant, hampering growth, reducing government legitimacy, and undermining the rule of law. And basic infrastructure is lacking, from underdeveloped road and rail networks to inadequate power-generating capacity.
Such challenges are coupled with two recent developments that have opened up vistas of opportunity. First, Africa's embrace of mobile-telephone technology has raised economic productivity by greatly reducing the costs of communication, bypassing the need for landline infrastructure, and substituting for more traditional banking and other service-delivery platforms. Mobile phones also have the potential to decrease corruption and detect electoral and other types of fraud through anonymous reporting applications. Second, Chinese investment and demand for natural resources have boosted commodity prices and contributed directly to high annual growth rates. Moreover, 75 percent of Chinese direct investment supports infrastructure projects, leading to the rapid development of roads, railways, ports, and power plants (155).
How can African countries take advantage of these opportunities, and overcome their myriad challenges, to create a brighter future? Strengthening good governance is vital: most importantly, improving security, reducing corruption, expanding service delivery, bolstering freedom of the press, entrenching the rule of law, developing infrastructure, and expanding educational opportunities. But all such improvement, Rotberg argues, hinges on not just good but visionary leadership, the type of leadership provided by Nelson Mandela and Seretse Khama in the rare African success stories of South Africa and Botswana: “Leaders matter as much, if not more, than external influences, internal structures, and institutional constraints. . . . Human agency has been shown to strengthen or destroy nation-states, to uplift or oppress citizens, and to unleash or to stifle the talents and aspirations of followers and constituents” (191).
Rotberg's conviction is seductive. It suggests that a brilliant leader can navigate through the burdens of any history; through the baggage of long-established extractive institutions; through the lingering fear, resentment, and horror of war. It holds that human agency can prevail against long odds. He tends to downplay, however, the strong sway of entrenched institutions and the difficulty of changing patterns of human behavior that have coordinated around suboptimal equilibria—where at the societal level the outcome is negative but the reward structure is such that no individual has an incentive to change. And even if it was possible, and even if every country could find its own Mandela, the South African case itself demonstrates how good governance can slowly but inexorably slide backwards—how, after the departure of a visionary leader, ordinary or even venal men will once again govern.
Western liberal democracy was not founded on the promise of visionary and self-sacrificing leadership. Central to republicanism is the principle that human beings are selfish and factional; that strong institutions are necessary to protect freedom and channel the worst of our nature into a stable, benign political system. For good governance, institutions matter as much if not more than human agency.
And yet, the puzzle remains: how can societies emerging from a history of authoritarianism and war establish lasting democracy? How can states move from predatory institutions to good governance? Theories of path dependency suggest that, occasionally, critical junctures unfold, where in a moment of social and institutional fluidity opportunities for dramatic change emerge. During these junctures, new choices are possible and new institutions may develop, even if constrained by the past. In these moments, then, human agency can indeed alter the course of history. Whether sub-Saharan African countries are, in fact, at such a juncture and which choices are realistically available to their leaders remains, however, an unsubstantiated empirical question.
Such considerations do not diminish the importance or timeliness of Rotberg's work. Africa Emerges clearly details both the challenges and opportunities faced by African states in an uncertain time of change. Africa Emerges is also a deeply hopeful book, embracing the belief that out of tragedy and decay the dreams of ordinary people can be realized through visionary leadership. May he be right.
