As a turbulent 2026 unfolds, taking stock of where Latin America finds itself is as urgent as it is disquieting. In a year of his second term in office, President Donald Trump has entertained the possibility of annexing the Panama Canal and has imposed punitive tariffs on countries in the region deemed to undermine U.S. interests. For months, the United States built up a military deployment off the coast of Venezuela and conducted extrajudicial executions of individuals alleged to be trafficking drugs in small boats in the Caribbean Sea. The mounting tensions ultimately ended with aerial attacks in Caracas and other strategic locations in Venezuela and the abduction of Nicolás Maduro and his wife. Far-right leaders are returning to power, with Chile and Honduras among the most recent states to elect a leader with Trump-like politics and policies. Organized crime continues its dangerous ascent. Many Latin American countries carry sovereign debt obligations that exceed half of their GDP. This moment is thus a compelling one in which to incorporate a regional lens into the conversation. For international lawyers, reflecting on whether the international legal practices, institutional forms, and knowledge developed within the region—past and present—can help us to understand and respond to the current moment feels especially important.
The publication of Latin American International Law in the Twenty-First Century, edited by Alejandro Chehtman, Alexandra Huneeus, and Sergio Puig, comes at the right time. The book arrives in a discipline already marked by years of efforts to decenter the North Atlantic, including through scholarship that has re-oriented understandings of international law’s origins by tracing how Latin American diplomats and jurists engaged with the United States and European powers.Footnote 1 In this sense, the book is both a product of and a welcome addition to such scholarly efforts. Although described as consisting of pieces by “leading and emerging scholars in the region who are rewriting the canons of international law scholarship,” most chapters are in fact written by well-established voices in academia, government, and diplomacy (p. xxii).
The book’s chapters are nested between an introduction and an epilogue in which the editors advance two bold, interconnected claims: that a “traditional LAIL canon” (LAIL being the acronym they propose for “Latin American international law”) shaped the past two centuries, and that this has now given way to a “twenty-first-century LAIL canon.” The editors group thirty-one chapters into five parts. Although framed as a study of the twenty-first century, the volume also spans the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. This wide temporal scope, together with the monumental effort to incorporate topics not usually addressed in explorations of Latin America and international law, makes it difficult to sustain a flawless organizational logic. Parts I, III, and V, nonetheless, offer the clearest guiding threads.
Part I, “History,” revisits diplomatic figures, jurists, doctrines, and techniques of legal ordering in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Part II, titled “Theories and Methods,” reflects on knowledge production in the region. Chapters range from assessments of scholarly production to analyses of the theories underpinning state-sponsored development projects, as well as approaches to science and technology. Two contributions adopt a narrower lens, using specific controversial decisions of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights to explore, respectively, Latin American feminisms and theories of legitimacy in international adjudication. Part III, “Institutions and Practice,” explores truth commissions and Latin American states’ engagement with the International Court of Justice, alongside the operation of the Inter-American Human Rights System and domestic judiciaries, before turning to practice and international law education. Part IV, “New Doctrines,” turns to what the editors describe as “the contemporary vibrancy of international law construction in the region,” highlighting innovations and state practice in reparations, countermeasures, transitional justice, racial discrimination, and maritime delimitation (p. xxxiii). The distinction between innovation and continuity is, however, not always clear, and the chapter on the ius constitutionale commune in Latin America, an analysis of a rather insulated academic project, stands apart from the section’s broader focus. Finally, Part V, “Contemporary Challenges,” brings together reflections on transnational corruption, the Colombian peace process, environmental cooperation, international health law, and internet and digital trade governance. As is clear, no stone is left unturned.
My aim in this review is twofold: to engage with the volume’s central argument, as articulated by the editors in the introduction and epilogue, and to reflect on recurrent modes of framing that emerge across a number of the contributions. The first part of this review unpacks and assesses the editors’ proposition of two canons to describe the scholarship on the “practices, doctrines, and aims of international law” in Latin America—a traditional canon spanning two centuries and a contemporary one that has recently emerged (p. xxi). The second part foregrounds a tension in the volume, in which fresh and incisive interventions that complicate the historical and contemporary operation of international law in the region co-exist uneasily with contributionist narratives that do not yield equally nuanced insights. Finally, as scholarship on Latin America and international law gains a more prominent place within the discipline, this review concludes by reflecting on knowledge that seems ready to be consolidated, allowing this body of scholarship to move beyond its more familiar preoccupations.
Canonizing Latin American International Law
The editors contend that over the last two centuries “the leading legal and political project among Latin American international lawyers was Alejandro Álvarez’s pan-Americanism,” a project that “encapsulated a worldview that has been enormously influential among Latin American elites, reflecting how they understand their status, values, and place and role in world affairs” (pp. 639, 642). Chehtman, Huneeus, and Puig argue that the traditional LAIL canon (also described as “Álvarez’s pan-Americanism” or simply “pan-Americanism”) was driven by diplomats and politicians in both the United States and Latin America, shaped by reactions to U.S. foreign policy in the region, and underpinned by a “deep confidence in free markets and a commitment to peace, commerce, and ‘civilization,’ typically construed in racist terms.”Footnote 2 Offering a bird’s-eye view of two centuries of regional thought is an intriguing and ambitious move, which provides a useful point of departure for reflecting on Latin America and international law even where one might disagree with aspects of its framing.
The editors’ understanding of the so-called “traditional LAIL canon” raises questions about its characterization and its periodization. In characterizing the canon, the editors take as their point of departure the international legal thought of Chilean jurist Alejandro Álvarez, whose writings shaped decades of debate on the nature and scope of international law in the region. Yet situating “Álvarez’s pan-Americanism” as the core legal and political project among Latin American international lawyers for two centuries might have warranted a more profound engagement with the content of that project. Identifying Álvarez’s legacy is not a straightforward task, not least because of his prolific life that traversed Chile, Latin America, France, and the United States. The individual contributions offer only windows to his work; none engages systematically with the implications of elevating his legal thinking to canonical status.Footnote 3 It would therefore have been helpful to learn whether the editors understand Álvarez’s agenda as a project of strategic engagement with the United States and European powers, as some of the contributions of the volume appear to suggest;Footnote 4 as an attempt to recast regional identity beyond the civilized/barbarian dichotomy;Footnote 5 or, as others have argued, as a program of unequal intra-regional ordering insofar as his project did not “elevate all Latin States, just the better-governed ones.”Footnote 6 One also wonders whether referring to “Álvarez’s pan-Americanism” and “pan-Americanism” interchangeably risks conflating Álvarez’s intellectual project with the diplomatic and multilaterally constituted pan-Americanism,Footnote 7 the latter shaped by an ample range of conditions and actors beyond a single individual. The limited engagement with the substance of Álvarez’s project also enables the construction of rather weak bridges between past and present in some of the contributions.Footnote 8
The second question concerns whether pan-Americanism can, in fact, be cast as a two-century canon, given that many scholars locate its decline far earlier.Footnote 9 The editors justify their longer chronology by emphasizing pan-Americanism’s enduring influence and by positing that the current geopolitical moment has unsettled it. Specifically, they say that one of the trends that has “challenge[d] the centrality of traditional pan-Americanism debates” is the declining influence of the United States in the region and the growing presence of China (p. xxvii).Footnote 10 (Leaving aside the question of whether U.S. influence in the region is in sustained decline—a claim that seems harder to maintain considering the 2025 U.S. National Security Strategy, admittedly published after the book appeared), the editors are right to foreground the expansive and overlooked importance of China. Even so, the justification for extending pan-Americanism into a two-century canon remains underdeveloped. The twentieth century was anything but linear, visible in the changing U.S. foreign policy toward Latin America and in the responses it elicited from Latin American states, diplomats, and scholars. What the editors present as the long period of Pan-Americanism encompasses, to mention some turning points, the Good Neighbor Policy in the 1930s; the post-war re-organization of both the global and regional orders; early Cold War anti-communism; Kennedy’s Alliance for Progress; the rise of military dictatorships in Latin America in the 1970s; and Reagan’s interventions in Central America in the 1980s. In this context, choosing the present moment as the point of rupture can feel somewhat abrupt.
Periodization matters because it shapes expectations about which developments should be treated as central to the volume. If, as the editors argue, pan-Americanism shaped the region’s legal and institutional architecture well into the twentieth century and “lies at the core of institutions such as the Organi[z]ation of American States (OAS),” then greater engagement with the OAS itself would seem warranted (p. 641). The chapters collected in Part I, “History,” focus almost exclusively on the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.Footnote 11 Yet, the 1940s were key years for regional relations and institutional development, most importantly because of the establishment of the OAS in 1948. Moreover, given that the OAS remains the principal regional organization in the hemisphere, its role might have been expected to feature more prominently elsewhere in the volume, including in Part III, “Institutions and Practice.” While several chapters address the Inter-American Court of Human Rights—which, though related, operates independently from the OAS—and references to the OAS appear intermittently throughout the book, there is no analysis of the organization itself, its trajectory, its successes and failures, and the competing regional projects that have emerged in response to its perceived limitations.
If the characterization and periodization of the traditional canon are open to question, a further issue concerns the coherence of what the editors describe as the “twenty-first-century LAIL canon” that demarcates a “new LAIL era.”Footnote 12 I would like to focus here on two features they attribute to it.Footnote 13 First, the editors argue that contemporary scholarship revisits older doctrines “but now with the critical twist that this was a particular class of Latin Americans, who were vested in suppressing other voices within their own states” (p. xxiii). But what distinguishes a substantial portion of contemporary historical work is not simply the addition of a critical layer to readings of old doctrines and debates. Many recent interventions pursue different intellectual ambitions altogether: some examine the worldmaking consequences of legal argument in the region, while others develop vocabularies and frameworks capable of capturing the complexity of international law’s operation in Latin America. Some chapters in the volume illustrate this broader orientation. Arnulf Becker Lorca and Amaya Álvez Marín, for example, analyze the use of uti possidetis juris as a state-building technique that facilitated the dispossession of Indigenous peoples’ lands, a successful endeavor whose effects endure. Beyond the volume, other scholars have sought to recover the legal-political imaginaries that once guided visions of the region’s place in the world in the twentieth century, imaginaries that cannot be reduced to projects serving the interests of a few.Footnote 14
Second, the editors claim that human rights law—developed through the inter-American system in dialogue with domestic courts—is the “area of greatest cohesion, development, and originality” in contemporary LAIL (p. xxiii). This premise can be questioned from both descriptive and normative standpoints. Descriptively, the notion of cohesion is difficult to square with the diversity of current scholarship. What, for instance, does the German-propelled ius constitutionale commune project share with granular analyses of the merging of the global and the local in the quest for transitional justice in the region, as conveyed in Alejandro Chehtman’s chapter, or the Third World Approaches to International Law and critical analyses of human rights in Latin America surveyed in George Galindo’s contribution? One wonders whether, rather than a coherent canon, we might instead be looking at “a very heterogeneous set of pursuits,” with little in common other than that they arise from the same region and are “expressed in a legal vocabulary.”Footnote 15 Normatively, whether the predominance of the human rights lens ought to be celebrated as intellectual vitality or regarded with caution is a question that should not be eluded.Footnote 16
Contributionism as an Enduring Driver
Whether or not one accepts the idea that there is, or ever was, a canon of Latin American international law, the editors are right to foreground the growing body of scholarship produced about and within the region, and the increasingly rich methodological and interdisciplinary approaches that animate it.Footnote 17 The collective volume showcases the breadth and vitality of current work. It brings forward novel histories and perspectives that productively harness the Latin American experience—from local innovations on welfare policies through conditional cash transfers,Footnote 18 to mappings of the Latin American technoscientific thought,Footnote 19 and prescriptive regional paths to address the climate emergency.Footnote 20 As with almost any collective endeavor, there is, however, a certain unevenness in the depth of the chapters. The editors note that they “did not set out to advance a particular project or vision” but rather “sought to explore the competing visions of regional law that coexist today … with an eye to scholarly trends and legal practice” (p. xxii). What interests me here is a mode of framing that emerges across some of the chapters—in particular, the tendency to cast histories and developments as Latin American contributions to international law.
Scholars have long observed that contributionist articulations are not without their risks. Writing on scholarly accounts of Africa’s engagement with international law, James Thuo Gathii identified a recurring historiographical move: an attempt to assail Eurocentrism by accommodating “African cultural heritage as a part of the international civilization that contributes to international law.”Footnote 21 Gathii underscored the blind spots this framing produced, among them the misrepresentation of history by treating colonialism as a brief interlude, the sanitization of the power relations underpinning engagements between African states and European powers, and the marginalization of the effects resulting from the reliance on international legal rules forged in the colonial encounter. Similar concerns have been raised in the Latin American context, where scholarship often asserts that certain Latin American states, jurists, or legal traditions were the first to articulate, develop, or formalize certain doctrines or rules, thereby “contributing” to general international law.Footnote 22 As Mariana Diaz Chalela and Samuel Moyn have observed, such storytelling risks presenting legal regimes “as more emancipatory than they in fact are” while obscuring “the ideologies and interests that drove the very real Latin American contributions to international law.”Footnote 23
The contributionist framing manifests in some of the chapters’ treatment of the history of international law in the region and evaluation of contemporary institutional practice. One illustration arises in the chapter on the legal thinking of three so-called early internationalists—Andrés Bello, Carlos Calvo, and Alejandro Álvarez—which sets itself to challenge “the prevalent assumption that global norms and practices derive only from the ‘Global North’” by “making the work of these scholars more visible” (p. 24). The narrative describes the contributions of these thinkers as “similar,” suggesting that they sought “to promote and defend the existence and interests of the new American Republics” and that “Latin American jurists spoke with one voice” (pp. 26, 39).Footnote 24 Much can be lost in casting their work in such general terms. Moreover, the corrective impulse can lead to an overstatement of impact, with these jurists’ ideas described as having “profound consequences for the development of a more inclusive and indeed more ‘humane’ international society” (p. 41). In particular, according to the chapter, the Calvo doctrine “secured US approval at the Pan-American Conference in Montevideo in 1933, coming to final fruition in the Charter of the Organization of American States (OAS) in 1948” (p. 29). However, the United States famously introduced a wide-reaching reservation to the 1933 Montevideo Convention. Fifteen years later, in 1948, the Calvo Clause made its way into Article VII of the American Treaty on Pacific Settlement (not the OAS Charter), to which the United States not only appended a reservation upon signature, but ultimately never proceeded to ratify the treaty.Footnote 25
A similar dynamic is visible in the chapter presenting the “experience of the creation of the uti possidetis rule” as an instance of a Latin American contribution to international legal doctrine, characterizing it as “a case of successful positivism in Latin America”.Footnote 26 For the author, “positivism has been an ally in the efforts of Latin America to challenge the existing international legal paradigms in furtherance of the interests of its peoples” (p. 267). Yet its account of the principle’s “success” largely adopts the measure the International Court of Justice itself supplied in Burkina Faso/Mali, thus leaving aside the multi-faceted impact the embrace of this principle had in the region (pp. 250–53).
The contributionist lens also extends to present-day assessments of regional institutions. The chapter on “Latin America’s contribution to developing the obligation of full reparations” traces a long arch from the Calvo doctrine to the development of the Inter-American Court’s doctrine of integral reparations.Footnote 27 The author pays little attention to longstanding concerns regarding the Court’s relationship with democracy and fidelity to its mandate, as well as the long-term sustainability of its remedial approach, particularly when remedies are not calibrated to the fiscal capacities of respondent states. Instead, the chapter centers on the purported threat posed by populist governments,Footnote 28 portraying them in relatively simplified terms and largely detaching their rise from broader discontent with international legal structures, including human rights regimes.
Importantly, however, the volume does not speak in a single register. Other chapters complicate, and indeed offset, this contributionist tendency, ensuring that the reader is not left with triumphalist narratives only. Steven Jensen and Kathryn Sikkink’s account of the role of Latin American and Caribbean states in the development of human rights in the 1940s and 1960s, while framed in terms of contributions, offers a granular analysis of the drivers, strategic choices, and limitations of these interventions. Becker Lorca and Álvez’s study of Chilean parliamentary debates in relation to the Mapuches and the lands they inhabited departs entirely from celebratory framing, instead examining how international law functioned as a technology of nation-building and dispossession, thereby revealing the uneven effects of the use of legal doctrine. Other chapters serve as much-needed counterpoints to celebratory analyses of the regional human rights system. Jorge Contesse challenges the “transformative” mission that some scholars and judges have attributed to the Inter-American Court, examining the perils that may follow from its expansive jurisprudence. Roberto Gargarella, drawing on constitutional theory, similarly critiques the Court’s democratic legitimacy, arguing that its decisions sometimes fail to engage the social agreements underpinning the local norms at issue in each case.
Historically, bringing experiences from outside the North Atlantic into view, and framing them in ways that would be taken seriously within dominant academic and institutional spaces, was no easy task.Footnote 29 But circumstances change, and the obstacles of the past are not those of the present. If contributionism once operated as a strategy of recognition (even if never free of limitations), it can, at present, reproduce the epistemic hierarchies it once sought to challenge. In other words, it was one thing to foreground and celebrate Latin American contributions at a time when they were systematically ignored. It is another thing to do so now when recognition is no longer the primary intellectual horizon.
Final Note: Consolidating Lessons
Latin American International Law in the Twenty-First Century offers reflections with the potential to broaden the worldview of any international lawyer. The volume also functions as a vehicle for sustaining and deepening ongoing conversations about Latin America and international law, taking stock of where this body of scholarship stands and where it might go next. It is at its strongest when it presents nuanced, non-romantic accounts of regional and national engagements with international law—interventions that illuminate the dynamics of governance and power in the region, past and present, and open space for thinking about paths forward.
The time may now be ripe to consolidate the lessons learned and consider what comes next. It is well established that many of the regional projects of the past “sought to insert Latin America into the Europe/U.S.-led community of nations on more equal terms” (pp. 644–45)—a strategy described elsewhere as a “cannibalistic consumption and digestion of the dominant international legal canon—for [Latin American jurists’] own sake and peril.”Footnote 30 Likewise, it is clear that semi-peripheral jurists used international law for their own ends: some in pursuit of emancipatory projects, others in ways that enabled or justified oppressive practices.Footnote 31
Moving forward, however, these observations ought to be points of departure rather than conclusions. The task now, I think, is to attend more carefully to the tensions and ambiguities of both past and present uses of international law; to the contextual conditions that enable, shape, or constrain them; to the different levels at which they operate—international, regional, local—and to assess their multifaceted consequences across those levels. It may also be time to reflect more carefully on the relationship, often taken for granted, between Latin America and the Third World. A clearer understanding of the structures and conditions that have shaped, and continue to shape, the lives of Latin American states and peoples, and of the multifaceted ways they draw on international law, may in turn help untangle and address the challenges they face today.
