Exile and Return engages an issue of extreme importance—in both its enormous human and political value. Yet, these issues are easily oversimplified and overlooked, if not undermined, by excessively schematic propositions and diagrammatically charted solutions that disregard the multifaceted and unique nature of the complex human experience engendered by refugee-hood, exile, and war. The organization of the material in this book leaves important issues to be desired. The five sections, together with the introduction, disregard substantial issues in the quest for a workable solution for the refugee return. There are copious footnotes, which substantiate statements in the main body of the text and contain a mass of additional sources, and an impressive set of expertise invested in the preparation of the fourteen chapters. However, wishful thinking and imperceptive, but nonetheless ingenuous, hopes dominate what should have been meticulous scholarship.
Some of the chapters avoid the quest for the “magic formula” to resolve the Palestinian refugee problem, the kernel of the Arab–Israeli conflict, but the preface and introductory chapter advance an intellectual quest for a practical, instead of fundamental, resolution to the Palestinian refugee problem. This approach jettisons social and political issues, in particular those with significant historical magnitude, in favor of equation making. It also overlooks the continuing colonial structure and its impact on the making and future of the refugee problem. The book thus begins the quest for a workable resolution by starting from the search for a solution without blatantly investigating its root causes.
Nevertheless, the problem facing the successful resolution of the Palestine question in general, and the refugee question in particular, is not the lack of tabled solutions. It was dealing with the Arab–Israeli conflict as a mathematical issue that led to the grave miscomprehension of the White House's seemingly highly trained equation makers about the essence and nature of the conflict in the Middle East, as the failure of the 2000 Camp David summit demonstrates (see Clayton E. Swisher, The Truth About Camp David, 2004). This text, however, maintains many of the same assumptions without the least questioning or curiosity.
The introductory section constructs a thesis based on the two-state solution, ignoring the increasing body of scholarship that perceives the collapse of Oslo, the dismembering of the West Bank, and the expansion of Israeli settlements as signs to the end, if not utter failure, of such a solution. The editors proceed from suggesting “the Oslo process failed to bring peace between Israelis and Palestinians” to remind readers that a “workable compromise” was not only at close reach but was evidently obvious in subsequent meetings in Taba and Geneva (p. 3). This is a misapprehension of the Oslo process, the failure of Camp David, and the Taba negotiations to say the least. The root cause of the failure was actually the structural faults of the Oslo process and to not realize this is an intellectual and political myopia.
The Oslo process, as well as the Taba meetings and the Geneva accord, could never have resolved anything. As a matter of fact, Oslo, a deal between the elites to advance and prepare the foundations of neoliberal regional arrangements that ignored the root causes of the conflict, survived only when the core issues of the conflict, including the right of return, were postponed, if not intended to be dismissed altogether. These issues were the jinni unleashed in Camp David, leading to the end of the process.
In addition, although many chapters allude to the unbroken connection between the refugee question and the Palestinian national scheme, the specter of the search for a magic formula leads to disjoining both. It is hardly possible to comprehend the Palestinian national question without the refugee issue and vice versa. In the course of the Arab–Israeli struggle, the Palestinian refugee question has become more than simply the issue of the right of return. Rather, it has come to represent all, and at the same time individual, aspects of the Arab–Israeli struggle and the Palestinian national question. Thus, any formula of return must be embedded in the culmination of the Palestinian national scheme, and anything short of that will not put a permanent end to the conflict.
Reconsidering the nature and structure of the Israeli regime and Zionist ideology is also overlooked. Questioning the foundations of the refugee problem and, more profoundly, the responsibility of Israel's colonial roots that enfolded the current regime in Israel (neoliberal Zionism) is essential. However, the moral responsibility that the book argues Israel must accept as a necessary step should not be divorced from the practice of return by refugees. Such acceptance is meaningless to refugees unless it is coupled with return.
An equally important and erroneous proposition regards the relationship between Palestinian and Jewish exile and return. The introduction proposes that both experiences are relevant to formulating the intellectual infrastructure necessary for a practical resolution to the Palestinian refugee problem. Indeed, the title Exile and Return: Predicaments of Palestinians and Jews and the book's cover design hint at such an association without stating anything definite. The reader discovers, however, the dissimilarity and even utter mismatch between the title and design, on the one hand, and the content of some worthwhile reading, as well other excruciatingly unreadable chapters on the other hand.
Even if the reader disregards these views that the introduction and certain chapters embrace and build upon, it is not possible to claim that the book introduces a breakthrough in the discussion of the return of the Palestinian refugees. It neither goes beyond previously proposed resolutions nor invites wider speculation on the refugee question. Repatriation mainly to the Palestinian state, restricted return with improved refugee camp conditions, compensation, land swap, or any combination of any number of them might be a recipe for a temporal solution but by no means a desirable solution of the perennial kind.
What remains seriously disturbing is that any quest or formula to resolve the Palestinian refugee issue seems to be interested mainly in reassuring unjustified, if not racist, Israeli fears. Not questioning these fears and Israel's colonial roots reflects the sheer bias of any view that perceives Israelis' fate as being significantly more important than that of the Palestinians.
The most praiseworthy chapter of Exile and Return, on the internally displaced Palestinians (IDPs), breaks with this deplorable tendency to present the refugee question as a security issue, thus colluding with the racist and unjustified fear of return that remains highly unquestioned. Jamal's chapter includes an interesting deconstruction of the myth of security and demographic threats, highlighting the centrality of the ideological character of the state of Israel. Although the return of the IDPs would not have been even the most trivial security or demographic threat to Israel, their return has been disallowed since the establishment of the state despite high court rulings in certain cases. The IDPs' case considerably undermines the unexamined and widely accepted Israeli discourse on the refugee question.
Exile and Return would have benefited from Simha Flapan's advice in his pioneering The Birth of Israel. Flapan noted that “it is not the task of intellectuals and friends of both peoples to offer ad hoc solutions but to hold the roots of the conflict up to the light of intelligent inquiry, in the hope of sweeping away the distortions and lies that have hardened into sacrosanct myth.”
