It has become something of a truism to characterize contemporary racial and ethnic relations in Britain as starkly divided on the issue of religion—or, more accurately, on the domestic version of the “clash of civilizations” between Muslims and non-Muslims. In the wake of the “riots” of 2001, and the global and local ramifications of the “War on Terror,” Islamophobia has been near the surface of political, popular, and press discourse—from the anti-Muslim rhetoric of the British National Party to the revivified demands for “integration” of ethnic (read, Muslim) minority communities and the conflation of Islam, asylum seekers, terrorists, and the threat to national security codified in tightened immigration and antiterrorist legislation. Within this overly presentist account, Muslims are placed consistently as outsiders, aliens, foreigners—as always “immigrants.” It is in this highly charged atmosphere that Humayun Ansari's historical account of the Muslim presence in Britain proves a crucial and significant intervention, exploring the long and multiple histories of Britain's Muslims and their complex engagements with state and society.
As the subtitle declares, Ansari's richly detailed historical account traces the history of Muslims in Britain from the 19th century. Drawing on a range of mainly secondary texts, and some primary material, Ansari paints an evocative portrait of a diverse religious community, from the early settlement of Muslim sailors and settlers to the present day. The book is divided into two main parts: the first charts the arrival of the first Muslim settlers from 1800 to 1945; the second recounts the beginning of substantial postwar migration of Muslims from Asia and the Middle East and explores the formation of a Muslim “community” through the struggles over education and political and religious organization. Ansari is always alive to the diversity of histories and positions, and the book includes material on both the more numerous and better-studied South Asian Muslim communities and the smaller, often longer established Middle Eastern and Turkish groups. The differences between Muslim sects and traditions are explored and linked to processes of political organization in the struggle for a “Muslim” voice. Issues around gendered difference and Muslim women are threaded throughout the book as well as in a chapter dedicated to “Women and Families,” and the role of women in this history is fully acknowledged and represented. Ansari also makes compelling connections between the personal lives of individuals and the broader social and political context, and between the local and national struggles and global shifts (such as decolonization).
“The Infidel Within” creates a rich and complex picture of a community in process, charting a journey between arrival and settlement, hostility and the struggles for recognition, the demand for integration and the desire for distinction, and the continuance and transformation of anti-Muslim sentiments. It offers no easy path through these complexities and contradictions, and this is a major strength of the work. In addition, the sheer breadth of its material will make this an invaluable resource for students and researchers alike across a range of disciplines. My only (minor) criticism of the book is that in its search for a “Muslim” history it occasionally downplays and obscures the links with other black and minority ethnic histories with which it is closely interwoven. It is not always clear, for example, what (if anything) is distinctly Muslim about the patterns of arrival and settlement, the reactions to immigrants, issues of racial discrimination, and so on. Thus, the early disquiet about mixed relationships can be found across racial, ethnic, and religious groups and cannot be separated from broader understandings of racial difference. However, and particularly in the present climate, Ansari's illustration of the historical and contemporary meshing and fusion of British and Muslim lives and identities is a crucial one, resisting any assertions of separateness from cultural and religious purists from either side of the imagined Muslim/non-Muslim divide.
