As someone who once spent three days in Mashhad bargaining for a piece of mottled or veined turquoise for my mother, I was pleased to be asked to review Arash Khazeni's new book on turquoise, its commerce, and its cultural significance. My mother, who knew little about Iran, had somehow learned that it had once been the source of the world's best stones. She prized the piece I bought, even though it had an excessively qashang setting that contrasted with the silver simplicity of her single prized piece of Southwest American turquoise jewelry. It was not difficult to find turquoise merchants in the city or nearby Nishapur, although they were not so importunate as the dozen agents of gem merchants I had once encountered in Jaipur, an Indian center for precious stones. Both Iranian Khurasan and Indian Rajasthan—and the Indian Deccan—had long been centers for the trade in these luxury commodities that were prized by the ruling elite in the eastern Islamic world. Nonetheless, the economic importance and cultural significance of turquoise is far less well known than the Indian market in precious stones. Arash Khazeni, the author of an important earlier book on tribes in 19th-century Iran, has now retrieved from multiple Persian and European language sources information about the mining and sale of turquoise. He also analyzes the cultural significance of the stone in Safavid Iran, Timurid Mawarannahr, Afghanistan, the Ottoman Empire, and Mughal India. Khazeni writes forcefully and passionately in this well-illustrated book, which is published in the University of California Press's World History Library series.
The obvious and compelling strength of this book is Khazeni's ability to synthesize information from the remarkably numerous Arabic and Persian language sources and later European commentaries that contain information about the aesthetics, chemistry, mining, prices, cultural significance, and value of turquoise as a stone of aristocratic conspicuous consumption. He focuses on three major themes: the chemistry, mining, and sale of turquoise, the value and appreciation of the stone in Safavid Iran and the neighboring Ottoman and Mughal empires, and perhaps most important of all, the cultural significance of the stone and its color in Iranian culture. In the latter section of the book he considers the Iranian Qajar regime's largely ineffectual attempt to revive turquoise mining in the 19th century and also substantiates the world history framework of the book by explaining how New World discoveries in South America and the American Southwest affected the value of Iranian turquoise.
As Khazeni observes, knowledge of Khurasan's turquoise mines long antedated the Safavid period. (The Achaemenids knew about turquoise, but believed it came from Khwarezmia, near the Aral Sea.) The Arab geographer al-Muqaddasi, he notes, reported their existence in the 10th century. Khazeni describes in detail how later Persian language works on precious stones, known as javâhirnâma, supplemented al-Muqaddisi's account, giving details of the Nishapur mines, the prices of its stones, and dwelled on the brilliant blue color of turquoise, which emulated the sky. Some texts also expressed unrestrained enthusiasm for turquoise's supposed therapeutic properties and its power to reward those who possessed it with conquest and dynastic prestige. Not surprisingly therefore, turquoise became a prized commodity and its trade expanded during the Timurid era and the establishment of the Ottoman, Safavid, and Mughal Empires. Turquoise's heavenly hue led not only to the stone being used to decorate mosques, but apart from actual stones, the color itself predominated in Iranian and Central Asian religious architecture, and could also be found to a limited extent in Mughal India and also Ottoman Istanbul, where the Blue Mosque is decorated with the tiles of this color. Khazeni also associates the prevalence of turquoise in Iranian culture with the cobalt that provided the “Persian blue” of Chinese porcelain, and the lapis lazuli of northeastern Afghanistan, which along with cobalt first brought the prized ultramarine color to Renaissance Italy.
Khazeni writes meaningfully and eloquently about turquoise, its appeal as a gem and as a therapeutic stone—and a stone that to some Iranian writers seemed to imitate the quality of farr, the Sasanid legitimizing essence. He is also persuasive about the broader cultural importance Iranians have historically attached to the color blue, whether found in turquoise, lapis lazuli, or the cobalt of Persian blue. In this connection he might consider a separate future article elaborating these insights, expanding on Priscilla Soucek and Annemarie Schimmel's brief contributions on color in Iranian literature and art in the Encyclopaedia Iranica (www.iranicaonline.org). In reflecting on his study it is impossible to forget the contrast between Iran's stunningly beautiful blue domed mosques that illumine its khaki landscape and the equally impressive but stylistically distinct Ottoman and Mughal religious architecture. Khazeni also has illumined the intra-Asian and Eurasian trade in turquoise, while noting that little data exists to document its actual value in Safavid trade, whose historiography, as he accurately observes, has long been fixated on the silk trade. Both turquoise and carpets constituted luxury Iranian exports during the era of the three Muslim empires, but the trade was not sufficiently great or valuable to offset Iran's historic balance of payments deficit with wealthy and productive Mughal India.
Beyond the book's impressive scholarship a balanced critique of the work should nonetheless note that it could be improved in a few respects. First, Khazeni ought to modify his assertion that scholars have long ignored intra-Asian trade, as contrasted with the many works on European commercial expansion in the region (pp. 6–8). Studies on intra-Asian land and sea trade have appeared with increasing frequency since the publication of Edwin H. Schafer's fascinating work The Golden Peaches of Samarkand (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1963), a model of its kind, which, like Khazeni’s, deals with commodities, including a brief reference to turquoise. Studies of the trade of the Central Asian Iranians, the Soghdians, constitute an important example of this literature. Second, his borrowing of the questionable phrase “tributary empires,” without explanation, to label and somehow characterize the Ottomans, Safavids, and Mughals ought to be modified or at least explained. It is confusing, since the phrase implies that these states derived their principal income from tribute rather than taxation, generated by threat of force rather than through bureaucratic fiat, which was not the case. Certainly Iranian turquoise was not a tributary commodity, since the Safavids controlled the mines, as they did the silk trade, and it is difficult to understand what he means to imply when he refers to “tributary networks” (p. 42) as a way of characterizing commerce between the three Muslim empires. Third and finally, when he writes that the turquoise trade affected “the geography and spatial economy of Timurid, Safavid and Mughal cities,” (p. 56) his argument seems to represent only a rhetorical aside rather than an argument, for he neither cites examples of such fundamental changes nor does he explain what the phrase “spatial economy” means. These few questions are, nonetheless, peripheral to Khazeni's principal achievement in this admirable monograph, his articulate, scholarly analysis of the place and importance of turquoise in Iranian life and culture and the commodity's broader significance in the eastern Islamic world.
