Between 1950 and 1967, Morton Feldman wrote seventeen works—more, if we count unpublished pieces—without the benefit of staves, clefs, notes, meters, or any of the usual trappings of conventional notation. Working on graph paper, he instead scored the music in a new notation of his own design, insisting that the format facilitated a more visceral engagement with sound than old-fashioned notation could allow. Yet he never abandoned staff paper altogether, composing works in conventional notation in tandem with his graphically scored music. The bulk of his graph pieces belong to two series, Projections and Intersections, composed between 1950 and 1953; seven more works in modified versions of the format followed in the late 1950s and 1960s. By then, experiments with notation were de rigueur within the avant-garde, and Feldman could justly claim to have launched the trend. As we pass the fifty-year anniversary of his final piece in graphic notation, David Cline has written a probing and exhaustive study of this subset of Feldman's corpus.
The first two of Cline's eleven chapters provide an overview of these works and their position in Feldman's larger catalog. Chapter 3 is devoted to the mechanics of the notation, no small matter: believing that the meaning of his notation should be immanent in the score itself, Feldman provided unhelpfully terse instructions to performers in the prefaces to these pieces. Chapters 4 and 5 examine aspects of the aesthetic framework and creative mission underpinning the music; they are followed by two more chapters explaining how Feldman's compositional processes helped achieve his goals. Chapters 8 and 9 ask what we can discern about the composer's attitudes toward performance practice based upon his sometimes-conflicting words and deeds, such as his apparent blessing of the unorthodox interpretive strategies of his friend and colleague David Tudor. The final two chapters concern the relationship between Feldman's works in graphic notation and his other music, including his ultimate decision to abandon the graph altogether. The book has two appendices: one concerns unpublished works and the other details Cline's objections to other authors’ analyses of Feldman's graph music.
Cline is tenacious in scrutinizing the inconsistencies and ambiguities that attend Feldman's music and the large body of essays, interviews, and lectures he produced in support of it. Never one to accept an easy explanation, he asks questions of Feldman's graph music that other researchers have overlooked. Is it possible, for example, that Feldman secretly borrowed John Cage's micro-macrocosmic technique in structuring these works? Could George Antheil's ideas of the 1920s have served as one of the inspirations for this new notation? Did the artist Robert Rauschenberg play a role in Feldman's return to the graph after a lull of five years? These hypotheses are not merely shots in the dark but theories supported by at least a modicum of evidence. Some are borne out by Cline's investigations, others are not. But he resists the tendency to oversell those arguments he cannot prove, lending an air of rhetorical honesty to a study whose rigor is never in doubt.
Feldman often sought a sense of global balance in his compositions, and he used several techniques to achieve that end. In chapter five, one of Cline's strongest, he pinpoints how this bid for “holism” affected Feldman's approach to the graphic medium, leading him, for example, to distribute musical material among the instruments in each score with remarkable evenhandedness. Another scholar, Alistair Noble, has recently suggested that the completion of chromatic aggregates played an important role in Feldman's conventionally notated works of the same period—holism in another guise, perhaps.Footnote 1 Although Cline takes issue with Noble in one of the book's appendices, the respective contributions of these two authors are complementary in more ways than not.
Exceptionally impressive is Cline's command of the wealth of sources underpinning Feldman's music and thought, including compositional sketches and drafts, correspondence, published and unpublished program notes, and obscure performance reviews. Although most of the composer's papers reside at the Paul Sacher Stiftung (Basel), important secondary collections exist at the Getty Research Institute (Los Angeles) and the State University of New York at Buffalo. Cline has sifted through all three of those repositories and has even found crucial documents elsewhere. His detailed study of the piece Ixion (1958), for example, hinges upon a special paperboard copy of the score located in the John Cage Collection at Northwestern University. He argues convincingly that the work was conceived by Feldman as “expandable and retractable” in form, or what Henry Cowell would have called “elastic,” and that Cage played a role in fashioning the piece into its published version (210–11). This portion of the book reveals how Feldman's creative vision intersected with the ideas of other creative partners, including Cage, Tudor, Rauschenberg, and Merce Cunningham.
Cline's writing on Ixion spills over nonconsecutive chapters, revealing one of the book's weaknesses: a somewhat cumbersome structure. Its other problems are minor, and some editorial: there's a mislabeled caption here (75), a sentence wanting revision there. Rare are Cline's actual lapses, such as when he overlooks the fact that Feldman's metronome indication for the Projection series (“72 or thereabouts”) represented a hidden homage to Edgard Varèse, who served as a key influence on his conception of graphic notation.Footnote 2 These are small matters, however. On balance, The Graph Music of Morton Feldman offers a rich trove of information on a fascinating collection of pieces, and it will undoubtedly benefit scholars and performers of Feldman's music for years to come.
