Over the past five years, there has been a boom in the scholarship studying the memory(ies) surrounding contested pasts of political violence and conflict. Back in 2011, with my colleague Vincent Druliolle, we were lamenting in the preface to the book The Memory of State Terrorism in the Southern Cone the relative lack of high-quality scholarship published in English on memory struggles. That diagnostic could not be further from where we stand today.
Numerous monographs and edited collections have been published since, starting to fill that gap. Furthermore, in 2014, the XXXII International Congress of the Latin American Studies Association tackled the topic of ‘Democracy and Memory’, assessing the long-term consequences of the collective memory of human rights repression in Latin American countries that had lived through dictatorship and authoritarianism. Meanwhile, in 2015, the journal Latin American Perspectives dedicated a special issue (42(3)) to ‘The Resurgence of Collective Memory, Truth, and Justice Mobilizations in Latin America’. There could hardly be any more fascination and burgeoning academic interest in the subject.
The Struggle for Memory in Latin America, the third book released as part of Palgrave Macmillan's new series on ‘Memory Politics and Transitional Justice’, is a very welcome addition to this growing literature. It is an ambitious and pioneering volume that incorporates a wide-ranging set of countries with diverse experiences of human rights violations, including famous cases like Argentina and Chile and lesser-known ones such as Mexico and Paraguay. As the book editors state, the goal is to offer ‘a panoramic view’ of various forms of political violence suffered in Latin America to enable ‘a continent-wide historicization of the struggles over the memory of these pasts’ (p. 7). The editors undoubtedly achieve that important goal with this impressive collection. Yet, they miss the opportunity to go one step further and bring together the lessons learnt from this panorama of diverse experiences on memory struggles across Latin America tackled in the individual chapters. They could have considered adding a concluding chapter that, building on the country studies, could have offered an analytical framework unpacking key actors and dynamics involved in the struggles for memory across Latin America that could be generalisable and applicable to other parts of the world too.
The book makes three key contributions to our understanding of memory struggles in the aftermath of atrocities.
First, the book clearly shows how memories of a recent past are never really pasts, but rather constitute ‘pasts/presents’ (p. 1). Social memory is dynamic; it continuously changes and develops. As the editors write in the Introduction, ‘in the context of memory struggles, interventions aimed at assigning meaning to the past, even those proposed by those in power, can be eroded and defeated by other constructions of meanings’ (p. 10). Memory never stands still. Nothing is permanent or fixed in memory. Rather, memory struggles are ever evolving and shifting together with the societies in which they take place, reflecting broader political and social changes within them. For instance, in chapter 3, Claudio Barrientos shows how Chile's struggle for memory has been changing over time: the author traces shifting discourses of memory, ranging from the idea of ‘national salvation’ by the armed forces in the early 1970s to that of ‘state violence’ by human rights organisations later on. Chile remains, however, far from reaching ‘a consensus’ on its recent dictatorial past, since these struggles continue to be ‘rearticulated’ in the public sphere (p. 68). In chapter 10, Julieta Rostica likewise highlights the existence of a number of memories in Guatemala regarding the period 1954 to 1996 put forward by the armed forces, civil society, indigenous communities and guerrilla groups. The author shows, however, how the memory of the internal armed conflict remains hegemonic, despite efforts by civil society groups and the recognition by truth commissions that acts of genocide had been committed against Mayan ethnic groups between 1981 and 1982. The memory struggle continues to play out into the present. Current President Otto Pérez Molina, for instance, affirmed in 2012 that there had been ‘no genocide’ in Guatemala (p. 198), while during the historic 2013 prosecution against Ríos Montt, several former officers of Arzú’s government (1996–2000) denounced that ‘the accusation of genocide was a juridical fabrication’ (p. 198).
Second, the volume transcends the often used focus on transitional justice mechanisms as a way to understand memory struggles. Although several authors do address the work of truth commissions, the chapters are nevertheless varied and incorporate other lenses to look into these countries’ recent history, such as parliamentary session diaries and archives. In chapter 5, the authors assess whether Paraguay is ‘a society with too much or too little historical memory’ (p. 91). Despite the establishment of a Truth and Justice Commission, this failed to generate ‘a collective process of discussion and confrontation over the interpretation of the past’ (p. 106). Sectors of Paraguayan society continue to express ‘nostalgia for the glorious past’ (p. 107). The authors draw attention to a persisting disjuncture: on the one hand, efforts to acknowledge abuses under Stroessner's dictatorship and the recovery of the memory of the country's authoritarian past and, on the other, the current criminalisation of protest and social movements together with the enduring remnants of authoritarianism and the culture of impunity in contemporary Paraguay.
Third, the chapters demonstrate, although with varying degrees of success across the region, that a culture of human rights emerged and consolidated in Latin America in such a forceful way that few would have predicted just decades ago. On the one end of an imaginary spectrum of human rights culture, we find countries such as Argentina, Chile and Uruguay where the dictatorial past and the forceful denunciation of atrocities triggered the development of a profound human rights consciousness. Chapter 2 on Uruguay, for instance, underscores significant events such as the prosecution and conviction of two former dictators and other high-ranking civilian and military officers for dictatorship-era crimes after 2005. At the other end of the spectrum, human rights problems endure in countries like Brazil, Guatemala and El Salvador. For instance, at least 3,009 people were killed by the police in Brazil in 2014, according to the latest Brazilian Public Security Forum report (see http://www.forumseguranca.org.br/storage/download//anuario_2015.retificado_.pdf), the actual number is likely to be higher since some killings go unreported. In chapter 6, Cynthia Milton identifies human rights challenges for Peru. She shows how, although the Truth and Reconciliation Commission considered that holding perpetrators to account ‘was a central act of reparation’ and ‘crucial for restoring the population's trust in democratic institutions’ (p. 122), there have recently been substantial setbacks in the search for justice for past crimes and that social inequalities and racism – key causes of Peru's conflict in the recent past – remain largely unchanged.
The volume editors have put together an excellent collection of essays that will become a go-to volume for undergraduate and postgraduate courses on Latin American Studies, Memory Studies, and Human Rights, as well as for researchers looking for an overview of the struggles for memory in Latin America.
