Interest in science as a collaborative practice has been part of a larger historical turn towards understanding science as a socially embedded activity. Against the older notion of scientist as a solitary genius and along with studies of scientific teams, labs and schools, historians began to view science as a family and couple practice. These innovative approaches intersected with gender studies: the landmark Creative Couples in the Sciences, edited by Helena M. Pycior, Nancy G. Slack and Pnina G. Abir-Am (1996) explored the relationship between marriage and scientific collaboration.
This collection of essays, arising from a 2009 conference, takes up where Creative Couples left off to deepen the exploration of the interaction between science and coupledom. Its goal is ‘to analyse the dynamics of partnerships in relation to scientific work, focusing on how the partners’ social and political agendas, work–life (im)balances, and public-relations strategies produced distinct forms of collaboration’ (p. 1). While most cases studies are of married couples, there are also examples of male–female couples who were not in a romantic relationship, and of a homosexual couple. Contributions build on a range of sources (private notebooks, speeches, research publications), and cover the period from the late eighteenth century to the late twentieth (though most are focused on the turn of the twentieth century) and, geographically, the US and Europe. Most innovatively, essays consider achievements of both partners rather than just the ‘neglected’ one.
The book is divided into three thematic sections. The first, ‘Representing collaboration’, examines how the scientific collaboration within the couple was communicated outwardly. ‘The making of a bestseller’ by Jean-Jacques Dreifuss and Natalia Tikhonov Sigrist shows that unattributed contributions were not always by the wife. While Conversations on Chemistry have been attributed to Jane Marcet, a study of the private notebooks of her husband, chemist Alexander Marcet, has revealed his crucial input. ‘“Not merely wifely devotion”’, by Donald Opitz, on Lord Rayleigh and Evelyn Balfour, argues that, against the popular view of Lord Rayleigh as a ‘solitary genius’, his educated, scientifically trained wife contributed to his research with her mathematical calculations. Finally ‘The mystery of the Nobel laureate and his vanishing wife’, by Joy Harvey, takes a synoptic view of Nobel Prize laureates and their wives. Bar exceptions such as the Curies, Joliot-Curies and Coris, a typical case entailed close collaboration and important involvement of wives during their husbands' early careers, followed by gradual disappearance as the husbands' star began to climb. In most cases, wives' contributions did not even merit a mention in Nobel Prize speeches.
Possibly the most successful section, ‘Negotiating academization’, follows three couples as their private and personal lives, households and laboratories intersected in the attempt to forge a dual-career partnership. Both Kristina Espmark and Christer Nordlund's chapter about Astrid Euler, née Cleve, and Hans von Euler-Chelpin, and Brigitte van Tiggelen and Annette Lykknes's ‘Ida and Walter Noddack through better and worse’, use analysis of publications by authorship (single-authored, co-authored within the couple or with other authors) across parts or the whole of couples' careers to examine to what extent the wives were able to forge independent career paths. In the Eulers' case, motherhood led to the straining of the relationship and eventually divorce, which had disastrous effects on Astrid Euler's career. Opportunities for women were limited even in harmonious unions – such as the Noddacks' or the geneticists Anna Rachel and Phineas Westcott Whiting, considered in Marsha Richmond's chapter. For Ida Noddack, existing on the margin of academia meant not having much to lose and enabled her to try out more risky – and possibly more interesting – research paths.
In the final section, on ‘Radicalizing co-operation’, two chapters, by Per Wisselgren and Eileen Janes Yeo, examine couples involved in social science and social reform around the turn of the century in Sweden and Britain respectively. As social sciences established themselves as fully fledged academic disciplines, wives, who could not gain entry into academia, found an outlet for their work in social activism and reform. This is especially evident in the British cases such as the Branfords, Bosanquets and Webbs. Voluntary associations were transformed into sites of research. Wealth and freedom from household duties, but especially not having biological children, seem to have been the crucial factors fostering wives' successful careers. Possibly the most innovative chapter is Donald Opitz's exploration of a collaborating homosexual couple. In the case of Edward Carpenter social and sexual reform were tied together, but interestingly his relationship seems to have fallen into the pattern of a traditional male–female couple, with his long-term partner George Merrill performing the role of helpmeet.
Nancy Slack's epilogue helpfully draws out some major themes in the book – such as patterns of collaboration; the effect of anti-nepotism rules (prevalent until the 1970s in the US) and institutional barriers to female employment; and the effect of life events such as pregnancies, child-raising, divorce and widowhood upon careers. The most useful aspect of her piece is her (brief) look at the ‘present’ and ‘future’ that relies on a (rare) small longitudinal study. While this volume nominally extends to the end of the twentieth century, most chapters focus on the early 1900s. In the 1970s and 1980s, most official barriers to women's employment were dismantled and societal changes allowed for a more even distribution of workload – household duties and childcare – within (academic) families. However, recent scholarship on women in academia has indicated that unofficial obstacles built by persisting gender roles and social expectations remain. Several essays in this volume indicate that it was pregnancy and motherhood that affected women's careers more than official hurdles, and inclusion of a chapter (or more) focusing on late twentieth-century academic coupledom would make this point clearer. As it stands, it is nonetheless a useful collection for anyone interested in science as a collaborative practice or in gender and science.
