Books and articles written by philosophers tend to be dense and esoteric, and focus on a minute problem within a larger debate. Of these, I am sure, we have all read many. However, few philosophers are able to artfully track the history of philosophy in such a way as to draw a narrative arc depicting the dynamics, progressions, and value of philosophy, thereby arriving at a new understanding of philosophy and philosophers. Brand’s book, LoveKnowledge, is a much welcome, and refreshing book that accomplishes just that. It tracks the predominant, yet overlooked, theme of LoveKnowledge within the works of several eminent philosophers: Socrates, Spinoza, Rousseau, Nietzsche, Foucault, and Derrida. LoveKnowledge is, Brand states, “a distortion of the accepted translation of philo-sophia as the ‘love of knowledge.’” (P. ix) Accordingly, through the work of these philosophers, Brand tries to answer the questions: what is the love that turns into knowledge and how is the knowledge we seek already a form of love? He informs the reader that the book does not have clear, rigid answers—and rightfully so. These are age-old questions that drive philosophy, and to offer rigid answers would be immodest and audacious—not at all befitting a philosopher. To offer such answers would contradict the thesis of his work. Nonetheless, by the end of the book, with the mind’s eye, the reader sees what LoveKnowledge means, what each philosopher takes it to mean, and what each philosopher adds to the notion.
Each chapter is dedicated to one philosopher and one piece of seminal work. The first two chapters are dedicated to Plato’s Apology and Symposium respectively. Brand then continues with Spinoza’s Ethics, Rousseau’s Reveries of the Solitary Walker, Nietzsche’s Genealogy of Morals, Foucault’s History of Sexuality, and Derrida’s “Here I am,” and comes full circle, ending with a statement about Socratic unknowingness. The organization and presentation of the philosophers offers context that is lacking when one reads the primary literature alone. Each chapter begins with a brief biography, the philosopher’s impact and main contributions, and then proceeds to guide the reader through a summary and commentary of the seminal piece of work through the aperture of LoveKnowledge. For example, in chapter 1, Brand describes Socrates and Plato, and as he highlights and interprets salient passages in the Apology, he also touches on significant debates, questions, and themes in scholarship on Socratic philosophy and the Platonic corpus, such as irony, elenchus, chronology of the dialogues, and disavowals of knowledge among others. Later in the book, Brand makes comparisons and contrasts between philosophers illustrating the dynamics and complexity of LoveKnowledge. What is most intriguing and differentiating is that Brand states why these philosophers are important—something most of us simply take for granted.
LoveKnowledge, according to Brand, is a complex and dynamic notion. Love and Knowledge are co-constitutive in the realm of philosophy insofar as, without Love, Knowledge is simply a scientific search; without Knowledge, Love is simply base desire. The pursuit of the amalgam of Love and Knowledge is, as Socrates says, “the life worth living for man.” (Apology 38a) It is an activity—a way of life, so to speak—that renders life meaningful. LoveKnowledge cannot be achieved, and so, the pursuit itself, as opposed to the achievement, is virtuous. The philosophers, which Brand presents, not only write about LoveKnowledge but also embody it. It is the impetus that propels their thinking, work, and life. This is evident in the life of Socrates, who exhorted his fellow Athenians to care for the soul, to discuss virtue and examine themselves. It’s no surprise that the book is punctuated with references to the father of western philosophy.
Given Brand’s terse style of writing, which I very much admire, the audience is broad. Neophytes and professionals alike will enjoy and benefit from the book—the former for its introductory and widespread approach, the latter for its new reading and insightful interpretations of old, familiar texts. As philosophers, we have a tendency to paint with small, detailed brush strokes, honing in on a precise technical detail that is problematic, or one phrase that is provocative and puzzling within a corpus. But we forget (or perhaps choose not) to take a step back and paint with broader brush strokes in order to create and appreciate a beauteous 360-degree landscape. May the neophyte who reads this book be drawn to the field of philosophy, and may the professional be reminded of the LoveKnowledge that sparked her interest in philosophy in the first place.
