Acknowledgments
This book was born from a shared passion and an endearing friendship. When we embarked on an intellectual voyage more than a decade ago we did not know that this book would become such an integral part of our lives for the years to come. The project was nurtured by countless trips between California and Mexico to bring the authors together, and endless nights of pondering, hundreds of hours running statistical models, and countless meals sharing good food and even better conversation. Sometimes a trip would yield marginal improvements to the project, at times major breakthroughs. But every trip reaffirmed our commitment to not declare the book finished until we were thoroughly satisfied with it.
At the risk of failing to mention the numerous people who have generously shared their ideas, criticisms, and detailed comments, we want to thank, in alphabetical order: Felipe Auyero, Robert Bates, Rikhil Bhanvani, Valeria Brusco, Pradeep Chhibber, Gary Cox, Alain de Janvry, Ana de la O, Thad Dunning, Barbara Geddes, Andrew Gelman, Miriam Golden, Kristof Gosztonyi, Karen Jusko, Robert Kaufman, Phil Keefer, Stuti Khemani, Herbert Kitschelt, Eliana LaFerrara, David Laitin, Santiago Levy, John Londregan, Isabela Mares, Rohini Pande, Simona Piattoni, Dan Posner, James Robinson, Natan Sachs, Elisabeth Sadoulet, Andreas Schedler, Ken Scheve, Susan Stokes, Guido Tabellini, Andrea Vindigni, Leonard Wantchekon, Rebecca Weitz-Shapiro, Paul Wise, Steven Wilkinson, and Cesar Zucco. Over the years most of them have moved from admired colleagues to close friends.
Preliminary research on Pronasol was supported with funding from the World Bank. Additional funding was provided by the Center on Democracy, Development, and the Rule of Law, the Department of Political Science Munro Fund, and the Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education grant from Stanford University. We learned a lot about clientelism and distributive politics in a conference we organized at the Bellagio Center, supported by the Rockefeller Foundation, in December 2005, and at a series of subsequent meetings of a loosely organized group for the study of distributive politics meeting over the years, thanks to the efforts of Gary Cox (UCSD), Frances Rosenbluth, and Ana de la O (Yale).
We also want to thank a number of people we encountered in our field work that allowed us to gain critical insight about how social programs affect the poor. In Los Altos de Chiapas, Enrique Bentzul and his team opened their doors to us and allowed us to observe at a close range the operation of Oportunidades during two field trips in 2011 and 2012. We also want to thank participants in two focus groups we held in Oaxaca in 2009, as well as in door-to-door interviews we held in 2010 in various towns in the Zapotec and Mixtec regions of that state. We want to thank numerous women from poor villages in the Lake Atitlán region of Guatemala who have generously opened their homes to us and our students to help us understand the burdens of poverty, hunger, malnutrition, and disease that plague their everyday lives and those of their children. The experiences of these women serve as a tragic illustration of the hardships of living in extreme poverty without a safety net and government action.
We want to express our profound admiration to Santiago Levi, a scholar and government official who transformed the lives of millions. We invited Santiago to Stanford to give a seminar and many of our students described him as “one of the most inspiring persons” they had met. We want to second these views in acknowledging him for the huge contribution he has made to remedy extreme poverty in Mexico and elsewhere. The adoption of Conditional Cash Transfers in almost every country in Latin America was certainly influenced by Mexico’s success story with Progresa, which Levi skillfully innovated.
Invaluable research assistance was provided by Sandra Pineda, Marcela Gómez, Arianna Sánchez, Lorena Becerra, Jorge Bravo, Katherine Kelman, Ana Gardea, Emmerich Davis, Hamilton Ulmer, Rachel Brule, and Stephanie Gimenez. Elena Cryst proofread the text and prepared the final maps. Belinda Byrne edited the final manuscript. Chapters and fragments of the project were presented in many venues. Papers were presented at professional conferences, including the Midwest Political Science Association Meetings, the American Political Science Association Meetings, and the Latin American Studies Association Meetings. We thank participants in seminars at UCLA, Berkeley, the World Bank, Duke, Columbia, Yale, Chicago, Michigan, Princeton, and Stanford. We specially want to thank Susan Stokes, Margaret Levi, and Lew Bateman from Cambridge University Press for a “Seattle Seminar at Yale,” where we discussed an early version of the manuscript. The book was hopefully improved by our honest effort to incorporate the thoughtful dissection and constructive criticisms we received there. Finally, three anonymous referees from Cambridge University Press challenged us with incisive criticisms we hope to have addressed in this final version. The shortcomings and errors in the book are obviously our own, while the merits are to be shared with all of them.
Final thanks go to our families, in particular to Margie, Nicolas, Mateo, and Emilia, who have lived with this project for so many years. For their love the book is dedicated to them.
