Based on the growing new evidence and location of key sites such as Myos Hormos in Egypt and Muziris in south-western India, Roberta Tomber aims to reassess the traditional view of Indo-Roman trade greatly influenced by the research of Mortimer Wheeler. According to T., the new evidence challenges and enhances previous interpretations by introducing new sites, enlarging the range and quality of goods involved, and providing a better understanding of the chronology.
Ch. 1 is a brief introduction to the topic. Ch. 2 is a critical appraisal of the source material including descriptions and drawn illustrations of the different types of pottery significant to the establishment of Indo-Roman trade. Chs 3–5 take us on a journey from the Roman Empire to the East focusing on three geo-economic areas: ch. 3 on the Red Sea as part of the Roman Empire; ch. 4 on the areas beyond the south-eastern borders of the Roman Empire — East Africa, South Arabia and the Arabian Gulf; and ch. 5 on India and Sri Lanka. In each chapter T. discusses the different meanings of the various imported goods at the different sites and how this relates to the character of the trade and the people involved. Ch. 6 sums up the distribution patterns and discusses the wider implications such the role of the church and the consumers.
T.'s method consists of mapping imported goods from the Roman world, East Africa, South Arabia, Mesopotamia and India, such as coins, pottery, botanical remains etc., at mainly coastal sites along the two main routes on the Red Sea and in the Arabian Gulf and in Indian and in correlating these data with information from written sources and ancient maps. The book provides a critical site-by-site evaluation of imported finds, often based not only on publications but on autopsy. As revealed by her list of publications, T. has worked extensively in the Red Sea area, and a list of the main ceramic publications from sixty-six sites in India shows that she has examined ceramics from fifty-eight of these. One of T.'s important contributions to the study of Indo-Roman trade is her re-evaluation of the ceramic evidence based on her extensive experience with the characterization of pottery.
In order to achieve large datasets the Roman period is subdivided into two periods: Early (first century b.c. to third century a.d.) and Late (fourth to mid-seventh century a.d.). To briefly summarize some of T.'s conclusions, it is difficult to assess the scale and relative importance of the two periods. During the Early Roman period imported artefacts reveal much activity at the Red Sea ports but no matching infrastructure suggests no imperial control. The evidence points to the Roman component being undertaken by private individuals and consortia. There is no all-embracing explanation to account for all the finds. The evidence reveals the active input of many different groups at different sites and upholds the separate regional itineraries introduced by the Periplus Maris Erythraei. The mid-third century revealed a dearth of artefacts, but activities increased from the fourth century onwards and the Indo-Roman trade continued until the Arab conquest. During this period the Aksumite kingdom developed into an international power reflecting a decline in activities on the Arabian side of the Red Sea. However, the continued Roman impetus of the trade is suggested by the small number of Aksumite finds recorded in India compared to the number of Roman finds, even if this is to some extent due to the state of research. All the active sites around the Red Sea revealed a strong Christian component, and the source of the visible unity in this area may be the shared Christian faith working to solidify trade groups. Previously believed to be Roman, Sasanian torpedo jars reveal the existence of a trade route through the Arabian Gulf, but although torpedo jars appear at the same sites in India as Roman artefacts, there is no evidence for a common source. The evidence from India is still the most difficult to interpret. Entrepots such as Muziris brought together goods from all India, but during both periods trade patterns appeared to vary considerably, e.g. between North and South Indian and Sri Lanka.
The format of the book (22 cm, very few illustrations) dictated by the series Duckworth Debates in Archaeology is closer akin to more leisurely reading and at times a little frustrating in a study devoted to distribution patterns of artefacts most of which would be unfamiliar to anyone but specialists. There are drawings of the pottery types discussed, but when specific artefacts are mentioned, illustrations are generally replaced with references. T. provides the reader with a broad overview as well as a detailed insight into a growing field of research beyond the traditional centre of classical archaeology. The book provides a way in to literature which would be unknown to most students and even specialists of Roman archaeology and more than two-thirds of which has been published since the 1990s. The book also offers an excellent case for teaching long-distance trade studies methodology and theory.
