Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:38:05.886Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Experimental survey of linear and nonlinear inertial waves and wave instabilities in a spherical shell

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 January 2016

Michael Hoff*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerodynamics and Fluid Mechanics, Brandenburg University of Technology (BTU) Cottbus – Senftenberg, 03046 Cottbus, Germany
U. Harlander
Affiliation:
Department of Aerodynamics and Fluid Mechanics, Brandenburg University of Technology (BTU) Cottbus – Senftenberg, 03046 Cottbus, Germany
C. Egbers
Affiliation:
Department of Aerodynamics and Fluid Mechanics, Brandenburg University of Technology (BTU) Cottbus – Senftenberg, 03046 Cottbus, Germany
*
†Email address for correspondence: michael.hoff@b-tu.de

Abstract

We experimentally study linear and nonlinear inertial waves in a spherical shell with a radius ratio of ${\it\eta}=1/3$ . The shell rotates with a mean angular velocity ${\it\Omega}_{0}$ around its vertical axis. This rotation is overlaid by a time-periodic libration of the inner sphere in the range $0<{\it\omega}_{lib}<2{\it\Omega}_{0}$ to excite inertial waves with a defined frequency. In the first part, we investigate linear inertial waves. The influence of the libration amplitude and the libration frequency on the waves and further the efficiency of the forcing to excite linear inertial waves will be discussed. For this, qualitative data from Kalliroscope visualisation in a meridional laser plane, as well as quantitative particle image velocimetry (PIV) data in a horizontal plane, have been analysed. A simple two-dimensional ray-tracing model is applied for the meridional plane to interpret the visualisations with respect to energy focusing and wave attractors. For sufficiently high/low libration amplitudes/frequencies, the Stewartson layer, a vertical shear layer tangential to the inner sphere’s equator, becomes unstable. This so-called ‘supercritical’ regime, where centrifugal and shear instabilities occur, allows for nonlinear wave coupling. PIV analyses in the horizontal laser plane in the corotating frame show low-frequency structures that correspond to Rossby-wave instabilities of the Stewartson layer. Some of these are travelling retrograde and are trapped near the Stewartson layer, others are travelling prograde filling the whole gap outside the Stewartson layer. Since libration can be viewed as a time-periodic variation of differential rotation, we assume that these two different structures are related to either the retrograde $(Ro_{d}<0)$ or the prograde $(Ro_{d}>0)$ phase of the libration cycle. The experimental results confirm theoretical, numerical as well as other experimental studies on Stewartson-layer instabilities.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2016 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Geometrical and experimental parameters of the spherical shell experiment.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Three flow regimes can be observed: the ‘no waves’ (○), the ‘linear’ ($\times$), where mainly inertial waves occur, and the ‘supercritical’ regime ($\star$), where e.g. Görtler vortices and instabilities of the Stewartson layer start to grow. The uncertainty of the transitions is in the order of $(\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib},\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib})\sim \pm 0.1$ (grey-shaded areas). A representative Kalliroscope visualisation for each regime can be found in the supplementary material.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Ray paths for three different frequencies. Plotted are the last 500 of an overall number of 5000 reflections. (a) $\hat{{\it\omega}}=0.330$, (b) $\hat{{\it\omega}}=0.604$, (c) $\hat{{\it\omega}}=1.022$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Poincaré plot for ray-tracing method. Starting point is the ‘critical’ latitude ${\it\vartheta}_{c}$ in the northern hemisphere and the ray points in the northward direction. The dots mark reflection points at the outer sphere at position ${\it\vartheta}$ in radians as a function of $\hat{{\it\omega}}$. 5000 reflections have been done and the last 500 are plotted against the libration frequency. The resolution is ${\rm\Delta}\hat{{\it\omega}}=0.002$. The red lines mark the three frequencies depicted in figure 2.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Wave phases in the interval $[-{\rm\pi},{\rm\pi}]$ of a harmonic analysis for different libration parameter settings. The Ekman number is $E\approx 4\times 10^{-5}$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Comparison between analysed data and ray tracing in the meridional plane. (a,c) Show rays after 50 reflections for $\hat{{\it\omega}}=1.382$ and $\hat{{\it\omega}}=1.570$, respectively. The continuous lines are excited at the northern ‘critical’ latitude and the dotted lines at the southern ‘critical’ latitude. (b,d) Show reconstructed flow fields for frequencies $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=1.4$ and $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=1.6$, respectively. The colours represent the light intensity.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Time-averaged flow field over a period of 5 min for parameters $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=0.4$, $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=0.3$ and $E\approx 4\times 10^{-5}$ in the meridional plane using Kalliroscope tracer (a) and in the horizontal plane 4 cm above the equator using PIV tracer (b). The black rectangle and the $x=0$ line mark the regions which will be considered in § 4. (c) Shows radial profiles of the averaged azimuthal velocity $\overline{u_{{\it\phi}}}^{{\it\phi},t}$ for different $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}$,$E\approx 2\times 10^{-5}$ and $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=1.0$. (d) Gives the $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}$-dependency of the jet maximum $|\overline{u_{{\it\phi}}}^{{\it\phi},t}|_{max}$, scaled with ${\it\Omega}_{0}$ and $r_{o}$, for different ${\it\Omega}_{0}$. The dashed line represents the $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}^{2}$-scaling.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Wave amplitude $(\overline{u_{{\it\phi}}^{2}}^{{\it\phi},t})^{1/2}$ for different libration frequencies filtered by a harmonic analysis. The height of measurement is 4 cm above the equator.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Horizontal velocity fields for $h=2$  cm (a,b) and $h=4$  cm (c,d) filtered for the libration frequency with the help of a harmonic analysis. The libration parameters are $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=0.4$, $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=0.3$ and $E\approx 4\times 10^{-5}$; (a,c) show the instantaneous fields for $t=t_{0}$ and (b,d) for $t=t_{0}+T/4$. Measurements have been performed in the corotating frame. The colours show the magnitude of the velocity in prograde (red) and retrograde (blue) directions.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Power spectra taken from a Fourier analysis, (a,b) averaged over the $x=0$ line for three different velocity field time series with libration frequencies $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=(0.2,0.4,0.6)$ by solid, dashed and dotted lines, respectively, and (c,d) averaged over the inner region ($y\leqslant 6$  cm) in dashed and the outer region ($y>6$  cm) in solid lines. The libration amplitude was $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=1.0$ for each frequency.

Figure 10

Figure 10.${\it\beta}$ parameter as a function of radius in a spherical shell. A discontinuity for ${\it\beta}$ at $r_{i}$ occurs due to abrupt change in fluid depth.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Velocity fields in the horizontal plane at 4 cm above the equator for $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=0.2$, $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=1.0$, ${\it\Omega}_{0}\approx 24.4~\text{r.p.m.}$ and $E\approx 4\times 10^{-5}$. All fields are magnified as indicated by the black box in figure 6(b). (a) Shows the mean flow; (b–e) show filtered velocities for the frequencies marked in figure 9(c). Colours in (a) show the magnitude of velocity (red – prograde, blue – retrograde) and in (b–e) the relative vorticity.

Figure 12

Table 2.Appearance, amplitude and frequency of the trapped Rossby waves depending on the libration frequency. The libration amplitude is $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=1.0$. The abbreviations mean: $\text{cs}/\text{ws}$ – $\text{clear}/\text{weak}$ signal in power spectrum, $\text{cv}/\text{wv}$ – $\text{clear}/\text{weak}$ vortices (waves), $\text{sv}$ – structural vacillations and * means wave detection in all measured heights $h=(2,4,6)$  cm, which indicates columnar patterns. $|Y({\it\omega})|_{rel}$ is the signal power of the respective frequency normalised by the maximum signal power of the trapped Rossby-wave modes.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Velocity fields in the horizontal plane at 4 cm above the equator for $\hat{{\it\omega}}_{lib}=0.2$, $\hat{{\it\epsilon}}_{lib}=1.0$, ${\it\Omega}_{0}\approx 47.8~\text{r.p.m.}$ and $E\approx 2\times 10^{-5}$. Shown are the filtered velocities for the frequencies (from (a) to (f): $\hat{{\it\omega}}=(0.038,0.064,0.110,0.131,0.155,0.169)$) marked in figure 9(d). The colours show the magnitude of velocity (red – prograde, blue – retrograde).

Supplementary material: File

Hoff supplementary material

Hoff supplementary material 1

Download Hoff supplementary material(File)
File 15.1 MB