This work publishes the papers presented at a conference on Velleius at the University of Leicester in 2008. As our only extant contemporary historical account for the reigns of Augustus and Tiberius, Velleius' work certainly deserves this attention. The seventeen articles that make up this volume more than double the number of studies on Velleius that have been published since 1999, and the contributors are by and large luminaries of the study of Roman history and historiography. This work seems intended to break the spell cast by Syme's relentless antipathy toward Velleius, and one of its avowed purposes, as the editor Eleanor Cowan says in her introduction, is ‘to draw attention to the possibilities for further research’ on Velleius.
The contributors' papers are loosely grouped under four topical headings. Barbara Levick begins the first section of the book, titled simply ‘Velleius’, with a reworking of Velleius' biography. For this she has chosen the odd gimmick of having Velleius' sons Gaius and Lucius (suffect consuls in a.d. 60 and 61 respectively), a connection she (I think rightly) assumes, tell the story of their father's life. This is somewhat awkward throughout and becomes especially so when the sons must become reticent on their father's career after his praetorship in a.d. 15. Edward Bispham focuses on the attention Velleius gives Italy in Book 1, and concludes that the macro-structure of Velleius' work (the succession of world empires) creates a tension in Book 2 (regarding the threat of the possible transfer of Rome's imperium) that is clearly evident in Velleius' final prayer. Maria Elefante concludes this section with a close reading of several passages in which Velleius' connections to Campania are manifest; her note on the temple of Diana Tifatina is especially interesting.
The next section is devoted to historiography and intertextuality. John Rich provides an excellent overview of the questions regarding the genre and purpose of Velleius' work. In a very thoughtful article W. Martin Bloomer rightly points out that no small part of Velleius' achievement was to bridge Rome's republican past with its imperial present. Velleius did this, Bloomer argues, by presenting the Caesars as a cure to the culture of invidia that wracked the Republic. Bloomer's arguments regarding Velleius' brevity, and specifically his use of the term festinatio, bring a new dimension to a very old debate. John Marincola follows with a very clear treatment of causality in Velleius, an aspect of his historiography that has received insufficient attention previously. Victoria Emma Pagán argues, unconvincingly it seems to me, for an intertextual allusion between Tacitus, Histories 4.81.2 and Velleius 2.30.6. Christopher Pelling takes on the implied thesis in the titles of Woodman's commentaries on Velleius (e.g., The Caesarian and Augustan Narrative), which suggest ‘biostructuring’ on Velleius' part, and examines Velleius' treatment of Caesar to test that implied claim; Pelling argues (unsuccessfully I think) against those who have seen an intention on Velleius' part to telegraph a linear movement toward one-man rule through such structuring.
Ulrich Schmitzer begins Part Three of this volume, ‘Roman Themes, Roman Values’, with an overview of the German preoccupation with the study of value terms; he suggests further research in this area and uses Velleius' praise of Tiberius at 2.126.2–4 as a case study. John Alexander Lobur continues the focus on Roman values, drawing a parallel between Velleius and his contemporary Valerius Maximus to suggest that both employed unique approaches to time to highlight exemplars of Romanitas. Tom Hillard provides a rich examination of Velleius' portrayal of Tiberius' reluctance to assume the burden of the Principate, concluding that it reflected ‘the message of his age’ that ‘ennobled industry and labour’ but also hesitation. Luke Pitcher directs his attention to the transition between Velleius' first and second books, arguing that Velleius used Aemilius Paulus, Metellus Macedonicus, and Lucius Mummius to comment ‘upon themes of memorialisation, felicity, and luxury’. Catherine Steel concludes this portion of the volume with the thesis that Velleius' focus on exemplary individuals creates a tension with his narrative of decline that ultimately plays into his ‘programme … to construct a panegyric of Tiberius as the restorer and epitome of republican virtue’.
The final section of this work collects four thematically unrelated articles under the heading of ‘Velleius and …’. In the first of these T. P. Wiseman makes a series of interesting observations on the odd attention Velleius gives to public entertainments and ludi scaenici in particular, noting the importance of theatre in the presentation of Roman history and Velleius' use of theatrical metaphors in describing historical events. Robin Seager surveys Velleius' treatment of Pompey and concludes that, unlike Antony and Sextus Pompeius, ‘Pompey is never a villain’; indeed, an argument could be made that Velleius' treatment of Pompey is structurally crucial to his presentation of the late Republic. Kathryn Welch sees in Velleius' enthusiasm for Livia, whom he describes at 2.75.2 as Romanarum ementissima, a reflection of the way Livia was used as a symbol of reconciliation in the aftermath of the civil war. In the final chapter of this volume Eleanor Cowan explores Velleius' use of Romanum nomen (‘the Roman name’) in association with Marius, Pompey, Octavian, and Mars; her conclusions here nicely demonstrate the ‘possibilities for further research’ that she suggests in her introduction to this volume.
For those wishing to pursue research on Velleius the ‘Consolidated Bibliography’ provided in this volume will be of great use. The only major omission I noticed was my own dissertation, Imaging Empire: Aspects of Velleius Paterculus' Historiography (University of Cincinnati, 1999). This volume also contains a general index and an index of passages cited. The fit and finish of this volume are superb, in keeping with The Classical Press of Wales' standards; I noticed no errors in the text itself, and only one small typo in the footnotes (p. 49 n. 47).
