Instructors of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era are fortunate that the first edition of Greenwich Village, 1913: Suffrage, Labor, and the New Woman, by Mary Jane Treacy, is finally available in print.Footnote 1 This thoughtfully executed gamebook sets the stage for students to enter the bohemian world of Progressive Era lower Manhattan. In the scaffolding set up by Treacy's creative Reacting game, students take on roles as artists, intellectuals, literati, playwrights, artists, feminists, suffragists, and labor activists who vie for influence at Polly's Café—a bohemian haunt historically owned by little-known anarchist and free-love advocate from Evanston, Illinois, Paula Holladay.
The premise of this game is that those belonging to the “suffrage faction” compete against those in the “labor faction.” Will bohemian villagers champion a parade in Washington, DC, in support of gender equality at the polls? Or will villagers lend their efforts to promote an avant-garde pageant designed to highlight the cause of striking silk factory workers in nearby Paterson, New Jersey? As labor and suffrage make their appeals, villagers in turn work to convince factions to integrate bohemian and feminist issues into the campaigns for gender equality and class solidarity. How will suffrage address racial segregation? How will labor address family limitation? These questions and others are taken up over nine class sessions. The first three sessions are devoted to historical background readings and discussions of foundational primary sources. For the remaining six sessions, students take on roles as historical or composite characters.
As to which roles the instructor assigns, class size (as few as twelve, as many as thirty) and desired course themes may be taken into account. The instructor's materials, available from Norton as PDF downloads, suggest which characters to cast depending on these variables. With regard to course themes, for instance, instructors can swap out characters depending on what debates they would like the class to focus upon. For example, whereas W.E.B. Du Bois and May White Ovington might be cast to ensure that students tackle racial inequality, Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Henrietta Rodman might be cast when it is imperative that students discuss how early twentieth-century feminism intersected with “domestic revolution” and feminist visions of the built environment. To aid in casting, the instructor's materials contain a useful questionnaire that asks students about their “talents, time, and personality.”
Happily, this 259-paged gamebook is compact, so students can bring the book to class without weighing down their messenger bags. Despite its slender profile, it packs many punches in terms of content. In its new role as the publisher for the Reacting Consortium, Norton will be implementing a “clear five-part structure” for each of its thirteen inaugural Reacting texts: (1) Introduction, (2) Historical Background, (3) The Game, (4) Roles and Factions, and (5) Core Texts. Norton claims that “this new organization brings a much-demanded consistency to the series and makes it easier for new instructors to learn the games, or for experienced ones to teach multiple titles in succession.” As someone who occasionally teaches Reacting games back-to-back, I applaud this move. In Greenwich, Norton has also thoughtfully color coded “The Game” section, making it easy for students to quickly find the rules, strategies, session overviews, and information on how they can earn “personal influence points”—or “PIPs”—the vehicle through which this game is won or lost.
Treacy's creative gaming element of PIPs bears special mention here. PIPs model how Progressive Era social and political groups used art and culture to win support: “Players with the most influence control the game. They gain influence through their actions.” Those actions, in the form of cultural and artistic expressions, earn students PIPS of varying degrees. The more intellectual and artistic investment, the higher the PIP value, so that wearing a yellow ribbon for suffrage earns 1 PIP, whereas writing a one-act play about suffrage earns 15. The gamebook includes suggested activities. In my four times teaching Greenwich, the specter of PIPs initially (and unfailingly) causes students some measure of anxiety, but ultimately PIPS are one of the most rewarding parts of this game; students relish these opportunities to be rewarded for creative expression. Socialite Mabel Dodge might come to class donning a turban; I.W.W. frontman Bill Haywood might wear Dutch clogs to signal sabotage; playwright Neith Boyce might ask classmates to perform a scene from her play on the new marriage; newsman Max Eastman might invite his pal Floyd Dell to play chess in public; trade unionist Leah Schwartz (a character based on Rose Schneiderman) might create a silent film about women's factory work. While Emma Goldman does not “stoop for PIPS,” she will still smuggle copies of her anarchist publication Mother Earth for Polly's patrons to read. I have seen it all.
The intellectual underpinnings for PIPs, and for wider course debates, are found in the “Core Texts” (text-based primary sources, with four exceptions), which include eleven to twelve chronologically arranged readings in each of three subsections: “Women's Rights and Suffrage,” “Labor and Labor Movements,” and “Bohemia: The Spirit of the New.” The earliest readings date from 1848 (an excerpt from Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, and Elizabeth Cady Stanton's “Declaration of Sentiments”), but most texts draw from the first two decades of the twentieth century. While sidebars in the “Historical Background” section define terms such as nativism, separate spheres, or Jim Crow laws, and provide additional background information, in the “Core Text” section, sidebars serve as a useful content index (i.e., “[Hutchins] Hapgood explains the importance of the foreign in a city like New York”), and provide questions that focus readers on the most pressing issues: “[Walter] Lippmann asks us to create a vision to guide the future. What does he mean by a vision that ‘is made out of latent promise in the actual world’?”
Like their counterparts in 1913, students will not likely come to consensus about what that vision should be. But thanks to Treacy's efforts in Greenwich Village, 1913, they would be hard-pressed not to connect creatively, meaningfully, and memorably to the divergent voices of the Progressive Era's complex past.
