We agree that the impact of subtle discrimination spawns from a dynamic process containing inherent cyclical elements, and we applaud the focal article's effort to provide clarity to a murky arena. More nefarious than the cycle, however, is the continued and typically unchecked presence of subtle discrimination in the workplace, which affords a clear path for prolonged and compounding negative effects. Although Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso, and Lindsey (Reference Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso and Lindsey2017) touch on the potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination, we believe they missed an opportunity. The potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination to severely limit the career success of women and minorities is substantial and not well diagnosed (Agars, Reference Agars2004). Building on their point, we wish to draw greater attention to this concern and articulate how the cumulative effects of subtle discrimination undermine the impact of performance management and limit the development and advancement of individuals from stigmatized groups.
Although the negative impact of subtle discrimination in organizations is starting to be discussed (Jones, Peddie, Gilrane, King, & Gray, Reference Jones, Peddie, Gilrane, King and Gray2016), this is a relatively new phenomenon in the organizational literature. Moreover, in the applied world such concerns are barely a footnote and often not taken seriously (Williams & Dempsey, Reference Williams and Dempsey2014). Because the nature of subtle discrimination is to be hidden or masked, the immediate impact may seem small and inconsequential. As Agars (Reference Agars2004) demonstrated about the impact of gender stereotypes, however, even effects that are quite small statistically can have a great impact when considered in the context within which they function. Subtle discrimination in the workplace is unlikely to be a single event. In contrast, because subtle discrimination is often based in our expectations around social roles and norms, subtle discrimination is likely to be common in contexts where social roles conflict (e.g., race, ethnicity, and gender conflicting with work roles). They are also likely to be repeated because they are endorsed implicitly by organizational culture. Consequently, in the workplace, subtle discrimination is typically a long-term and repeated experience for women and ethnic minorities. It is in that context that subtle discrimination must be framed and studied.
As noted by Agars (Reference Agars2004), the cumulative effects of subtle forms of discrimination matter particularly for the professional advancement of underrepresented populations (e.g., women and minorities). These effects are perhaps more clearly illustrated through the lens of performance management. Performance management systems are the central process through which employers develop, reward, and professionally advance employees, yet there are historic and recent concerns about ratings and evaluations in the performance management process (Adler et al., Reference Adler, Campion, Colquitt, Grubb, Murphy, Ollander-Krane and Pulakos2016). The cumulative effects of subtle discrimination illustrate the veracity of these concerns. Persistent subtle discrimination undermines the validity of performance ratings, creating direct concerns about the effectiveness of a performance management process for discriminated groups. Further, these concerns lead to questions about system integrity and fairness. Most insidious, subtle discrimination in the evaluation process means that qualified members of stigmatized groups are less likely to be advanced or promoted into leadership. When considered over time, these effects may be substantial.
Given the tolerance for subtle discrimination, supervisors, who are typically the primary (and often sole) evaluator in performance management, will likely have observed numerous examples of subtle discrimination involving a subordinate, as these behaviors occur frequently and without consequence. The impact of this compounded effect on rater perceptions is likely quite substantial. A female employee, for example, may end up evaluated negatively based on the consistent violation of gendered expectations (such as in-role incongruity; Eagly & Karau, Reference Eagly and Karau2002), the display of less-valued female traits in the workplace, or examples of performance impacted by condescending chivalry or friendly harassment (Benokraitis, Reference Benokraitis and Benokraitis1997), rather than on actual job-relevant behaviors. Again, it is not the single-incident experience but, rather, the systematic and frequent exposure of evaluators to tainted observations, which we propose has the most troubling consequences for performance management. It is also worth noting that these consequences for women and minority employees are no doubt exacerbated in upper level positions where social role incongruities are even greater.
The cumulative impact of subtle discrimination may also emerge in the context of reduced self-perceptions of performance and abilities, which in turn have negative consequences for employee performance as well as professional development and growth. Effective performance management is predicated, in part, on employee self-efficacy and self-determination. Information that undermines the professional legitimacy of women and minorities, however, can lead to negative self-beliefs about competence and worth (Heilman, Manzi, & Braun, Reference Heilman, Manzi, Braun, Broadbridge, Fielden, Broadbridge and Fielden2015). Over time, these negative consequences have a compounding effect in that employees who perceive themselves as less competent will be less motivated (Bandura, Reference Bandura1997) and consequently underperform relative to ability, seek out less challenging tasks, and suffer lower evaluations and fewer opportunities for advancement as a result. In short, single-event experiences of subtle discrimination will have an increasingly negative impact with repetition. The end result is that women and minorities will systematically underperform and be underrepresented in higher levels in part because of the undetectable but continuous impact of subtle discrimination.
It is commendable that Jones and colleagues (Reference Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso and Lindsey2017) discuss the potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination, as such consideration is long overdue. The consequences, however, reach far beyond individual differences in managing experiences of incivility, and as a field we must consider cumulative effects in additional ways. Within the context of performance management, and considering the critical role of self and other evaluations, the implication of the compounding effects of subtle discrimination is clear. Such effects may directly and severely attenuate the professional development and career trajectory of women and minority employees. We illustrate just two examples, but importantly, these are long-term deleterious effects that are not evidenced when considering single acts of subtle discrimination. We will benefit from a more nuanced understanding of subtle discrimination in the workplace, so long as we recognize that its most dangerous characteristic may be a clandestine yet persistent ubiquity.
We agree that the impact of subtle discrimination spawns from a dynamic process containing inherent cyclical elements, and we applaud the focal article's effort to provide clarity to a murky arena. More nefarious than the cycle, however, is the continued and typically unchecked presence of subtle discrimination in the workplace, which affords a clear path for prolonged and compounding negative effects. Although Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso, and Lindsey (Reference Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso and Lindsey2017) touch on the potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination, we believe they missed an opportunity. The potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination to severely limit the career success of women and minorities is substantial and not well diagnosed (Agars, Reference Agars2004). Building on their point, we wish to draw greater attention to this concern and articulate how the cumulative effects of subtle discrimination undermine the impact of performance management and limit the development and advancement of individuals from stigmatized groups.
Although the negative impact of subtle discrimination in organizations is starting to be discussed (Jones, Peddie, Gilrane, King, & Gray, Reference Jones, Peddie, Gilrane, King and Gray2016), this is a relatively new phenomenon in the organizational literature. Moreover, in the applied world such concerns are barely a footnote and often not taken seriously (Williams & Dempsey, Reference Williams and Dempsey2014). Because the nature of subtle discrimination is to be hidden or masked, the immediate impact may seem small and inconsequential. As Agars (Reference Agars2004) demonstrated about the impact of gender stereotypes, however, even effects that are quite small statistically can have a great impact when considered in the context within which they function. Subtle discrimination in the workplace is unlikely to be a single event. In contrast, because subtle discrimination is often based in our expectations around social roles and norms, subtle discrimination is likely to be common in contexts where social roles conflict (e.g., race, ethnicity, and gender conflicting with work roles). They are also likely to be repeated because they are endorsed implicitly by organizational culture. Consequently, in the workplace, subtle discrimination is typically a long-term and repeated experience for women and ethnic minorities. It is in that context that subtle discrimination must be framed and studied.
As noted by Agars (Reference Agars2004), the cumulative effects of subtle forms of discrimination matter particularly for the professional advancement of underrepresented populations (e.g., women and minorities). These effects are perhaps more clearly illustrated through the lens of performance management. Performance management systems are the central process through which employers develop, reward, and professionally advance employees, yet there are historic and recent concerns about ratings and evaluations in the performance management process (Adler et al., Reference Adler, Campion, Colquitt, Grubb, Murphy, Ollander-Krane and Pulakos2016). The cumulative effects of subtle discrimination illustrate the veracity of these concerns. Persistent subtle discrimination undermines the validity of performance ratings, creating direct concerns about the effectiveness of a performance management process for discriminated groups. Further, these concerns lead to questions about system integrity and fairness. Most insidious, subtle discrimination in the evaluation process means that qualified members of stigmatized groups are less likely to be advanced or promoted into leadership. When considered over time, these effects may be substantial.
Given the tolerance for subtle discrimination, supervisors, who are typically the primary (and often sole) evaluator in performance management, will likely have observed numerous examples of subtle discrimination involving a subordinate, as these behaviors occur frequently and without consequence. The impact of this compounded effect on rater perceptions is likely quite substantial. A female employee, for example, may end up evaluated negatively based on the consistent violation of gendered expectations (such as in-role incongruity; Eagly & Karau, Reference Eagly and Karau2002), the display of less-valued female traits in the workplace, or examples of performance impacted by condescending chivalry or friendly harassment (Benokraitis, Reference Benokraitis and Benokraitis1997), rather than on actual job-relevant behaviors. Again, it is not the single-incident experience but, rather, the systematic and frequent exposure of evaluators to tainted observations, which we propose has the most troubling consequences for performance management. It is also worth noting that these consequences for women and minority employees are no doubt exacerbated in upper level positions where social role incongruities are even greater.
The cumulative impact of subtle discrimination may also emerge in the context of reduced self-perceptions of performance and abilities, which in turn have negative consequences for employee performance as well as professional development and growth. Effective performance management is predicated, in part, on employee self-efficacy and self-determination. Information that undermines the professional legitimacy of women and minorities, however, can lead to negative self-beliefs about competence and worth (Heilman, Manzi, & Braun, Reference Heilman, Manzi, Braun, Broadbridge, Fielden, Broadbridge and Fielden2015). Over time, these negative consequences have a compounding effect in that employees who perceive themselves as less competent will be less motivated (Bandura, Reference Bandura1997) and consequently underperform relative to ability, seek out less challenging tasks, and suffer lower evaluations and fewer opportunities for advancement as a result. In short, single-event experiences of subtle discrimination will have an increasingly negative impact with repetition. The end result is that women and minorities will systematically underperform and be underrepresented in higher levels in part because of the undetectable but continuous impact of subtle discrimination.
It is commendable that Jones and colleagues (Reference Jones, Arena, Nittrouer, Alonso and Lindsey2017) discuss the potential for cumulative effects of subtle discrimination, as such consideration is long overdue. The consequences, however, reach far beyond individual differences in managing experiences of incivility, and as a field we must consider cumulative effects in additional ways. Within the context of performance management, and considering the critical role of self and other evaluations, the implication of the compounding effects of subtle discrimination is clear. Such effects may directly and severely attenuate the professional development and career trajectory of women and minority employees. We illustrate just two examples, but importantly, these are long-term deleterious effects that are not evidenced when considering single acts of subtle discrimination. We will benefit from a more nuanced understanding of subtle discrimination in the workplace, so long as we recognize that its most dangerous characteristic may be a clandestine yet persistent ubiquity.