A City Consumed is an illuminating study of urban commerce and consumer politics in Cairo during the first half of the 20th century. Using analytical insights from studies of urban consumption, especially those that treat consumption as a spatial process, Reynolds takes readers into the realm of everyday spatial and sartorial practices in downtown Cairo's commercial districts, examining how these practices shaped popular understandings of Egyptian national identity and anticolonial politics. In so doing, Reynolds joins other historians of the last decade who have studied how Egyptian national identity was formed through the cultivation of new kinds of political and economic subjects. By excavating the links between shopping and mass consumption, urban space, and nationalist politics, she offers fresh insights into the period's shifting—and often narrowing—meanings of Egyptianness and locates the 1952 Cairo Fire in a nexus of spatial and material entanglements that complicate simplistic renderings of the fire as an unmistakable national revolt to uproot parasitic foreign interests.
The first two chapters map the geography of urban space and commerce in downtown Cairo, particularly the luxurious department stores clustered in the newly expanded business district. Far from being neatly partitioned between European (ifranjī) and local (baladī), the city center functioned as a hybrid cultural space characterized by a fluid mobility of people and goods that “defied the dual city usually envisioned by colonial officials” (p. 46). In the ifranjī business district, department stores and their surrounding small shops and boutiques embodied a wider intercommunal society, which “defined itself in terms of language that connected more with a notion of culture than with either ethnicity or nationality” (p. 64). The major stores—Cicurel, Sednaoui, Chemla—were established by 19th- and early 20th-century immigrants to Egypt from around the Mediterranean Basin, some of whom rose to become important members of Egypt's resident foreign bourgeoisie, and targeted a diverse range of clients. Many stores had roots in old commercial quarters, like Muski Street. Salesclerks came from a variety of regional ethno-religious backgrounds and “spoke in Arabic, English, French, Italian and Greek” (p. 67). This cultural diversity was accommodated by Egyptian liberal-territorial nationalism of the 1920s and early 1930s that was premised on belonging to a place more than an ethnicity (p. 64).
A pivotal set of events in Reynolds’ narrative is the boycott campaigns from 1922 to 1924 and 1931 to 1932. Spearheaded by the Wafdist Women's Central Committee and its elite nationalist spokeswomen like Esther Fahmy Weissa and Huda Shaʿrawi, and then taken up by university students, charitable organizations, and local boycott groups across the country, the campaign initially aimed to encourage Egyptian consumers to stop buying British goods. But by the 1930s, amidst the growing prevalence of economic nationalism and more ethnic and religious-based notions of identity, the boycott campaigns shifted toward advocating the buying of “Egyptian” products (pp. 92–93). Reynolds does not fully explore the reasons underlying this crucial shift. Her suggestion that the boycotters’ support for Egyptian industrialization efforts was a self-evident corollary to the decline in imports of British textiles caused by trade shortages during the Great Depression as well as new Egyptian tariffs after 1930 requires further elaboration. The reader is left desiring a fuller historical explanation of why many Egyptian nationalists embraced a form of anticolonial critique that envisioned the creation of an economically autonomous national space (rather than an older one that was premised on reversing the detrimental effects of overconsumption of British goods) and of the extent to which this vision was shared by nationalist activists and businessmen across the board.
In the years that followed, boycotters, manufacturers, and retailers promoted new ideas of product nationality, relying on rigid binaries like foreign silks versus local canvas and assigning national qualities to products largely on the basis of who sold them. Emerging industrialists, including some associated with Bank Misr and the Filature Nationale, seized on nationalist rhetoric against foreign goods to promote self-sufficiency in the textile sector and tried to reconfigure consumption patterns around “national” commodities. Although her interest lies more in the bifurcating language and symbols used by these actors, Reynolds’ narrative allows the reader to see how a national market for locally produced goods did not derive naturally from the struggle against colonialism; it had to be continuously engineered by an upper- and middle-class alliance of boycotters, industrialists, retailers, and marketers who strove to format consumer desires in accordance with their vision for a unified national market. Using the shoe and hosiery industries as examples, Reynolds contends that efforts to encourage the exclusive consumption of national products through mass advertising—by branding them as authentic, durable, and modern—found some success but also ran up against the mixed style preferences of customers. In the case of textiles, the silky quality of Egyptian long-staple cotton “tinged the consumption of durable local fabrics with expectations of social mobility” (p. 128) that tended to reinscribe social hierarchies rather than promote national unity. The dichotomies that arose in the 1930s continued to harden after World War II, amidst the spread of mass consumption, heightened social mobilizations that underscored the depth of class antagonisms, and new laws to Egyptianize joint-stock companies. Reynolds captures this moment with a careful reading of cultural texts from the 1940s—satirical cartoons, short stories, and illustrated advertisements—that highlight the contested status of certain mass-produced commodities, like nylon stockings and footwear, and the social anxieties that surrounded them.
A City Consumed ultimately aims to rethink the history of the 1952 Cairo Fire, an event that began with the killing of up to fifty Egyptian police auxiliaries by British troops in the port city of Ismailia. The deaths sparked a series of riots in downtown Cairo the following day that witnessed the burning and looting of hundreds of bars, dance halls, cinemas, luxury shops, and other ostensible symbols of European influence. While the book does not offer a novel explanation of who or what caused the fire, which Reynolds says is not her intention, it does reinterpret the events and people in the fire as part of “a complex imbrication of foreignness and localness” (p. 189) formed by decades of spatial fluidity and sartorial diversity. Extirpating unambiguously foreign elements proved challenging for demonstrators in a hybrid urban space: protesters, who often dressed in mixed clothing styles, mainly targeted European-owned establishments, but the damage extended to the surrounding residences and businesses of Egyptian Muslims and local resident minorities (especially Maltese and Cypriot small enterprises) and even resulted in the deaths of Egyptian employees. Rather than treating the fire as a clarifying instance where the social and cultural fault lines intrinsic to colonial society became more visible, Reynolds reads it as a moment of profound ambiguity that revealed, even to some nationalist literary figures and anticolonial critics, how the struggle against colonialism could paradoxically involve a measure of self-destruction (pp. 194–95).
From the vantage point of history, the fire functions as a lens (one might even argue an “event” in the Sewellian sense) that reveals how the structures of urban commerce and society were transformed during the process of decolonization. Addressing whether 1952 was a moment of rupture or continuity, Reynolds suggests that, in the case of the fire, it was both (p. 7). The fire marked a continuation of nationalist efforts to fashion a hybridized commercial space and its commodities into symbols of Egyptian sovereignty and unity, with all the complications that entailed. But it also set off a chain of occurrences that by the late 1950s would allow for the remaking of urban space in ways that were not previously possible. Reynolds describes how the swift rebuilding of downtown Cairo privileged large retail businesses over small enterprises, the former having better access to state loans. How the social tensions and anxieties embodied in the commercial district were addressed after the July 1952 military coup illustrated the character of the new political order. The growing emphasis on making merchandise more accessible to a wider cross-section of Egyptians, as well as films and magazines depicting the need for the state to protect private consumption, helped lay the basis for the nationalization of major department stores and for the creation of a state-run retail sector in the late 1950s and 1960s.
A winner of the 2013 Roger Owen Book Award, A City Consumed skillfully combines economic and business history with questions about national subject formation and anticolonial discourse. Reynolds’ analysis of the boycott campaigns (Chapter 3) and the 1952 Cairo Fire (Chapter 6)—two episodes that have received insufficient scholarly attention—offer instructive case-studies of forms of anticolonial mass politics in Egypt that drew upon the participation of social groups from outside the elite political class. Through the innovative use of diverse sources—memoirs, magazines, films, advertisements and cartoons, and archival records—she vividly reconstructs the history of urban commerce and consumer politics. A City Consumed is a valuable addition to the historical literature on 20th-century Egypt that no student or scholar of anticolonial nationalism, urban history, or consumption can afford to ignore.
