In 1995 John Zorn established a new record label, Tzadik, with the release of David Krakauer's Klezmer Madness! on the label's Radical Jewish Culture (RJC) Series.Footnote 1 Secrets (2009), a collection of hasidic nigunim (sacred melodies, singular nigun) reimagined as jazz tunes, is a recent release on that series, which now numbers over 150.Footnote 2 Tzadik has become a major presence in contemporary music: its Composer Series alone currently comprises over 160 titles and includes work by Milton Babbitt, Derek Bailey, Earle Brown, Fred Frith, Gerry Hemingway, Susie Ibarra, George Lewis, and (as with many of the other series) Zorn himself. The label may be best known for its catalog of new Jewish music, especially compositions from Zorn's Masada songbooks, arranged in guises ranging from fully scored chamber music to hard-driving post-bop. (The Hebrew word zaddik—denoting a spiritual leader or righteous man, especially within a hasidic Jewish context—reinforces the label's Jewish identification.) In a statement on Tzadik's website, Zorn asserts that the RJC series “does not release ‘all things jewish,’ [sic] and often I have had to reject projects on this basis . . . much to the consternation of the artist, who is told, perhaps for the first time in their life that the music is not ‘out’ enough.”Footnote 3 Notwithstanding this claim, Zorn has been recently developing new work that aims to “charm and delight” rather than to challenge.Footnote 4 Along these lines, Secrets is a polished, cleanly recorded assemblage of harmonized hymn tunes set in a chamber-jazz idiom. A majority of its nigunim are articulated as slow ballads or jazz “waltzes” in triple or compound meter and arranged in thirty-two-bar or similar song form. Caine is a veteran jazz performer, and during some of his solos the ensemble takes a turn into jazz-combo territory, notably in the opening tune, “Lubavitcher Nigun,” and in “Satmar Rikud” (Satmar Dance). However, for the most part the trio adopts a restrained blend of jazz, pop, and European classical syntax.
The artists on Secrets all appear on other recordings in the RJC series and perform in many of Zorn's ensembles. Baron, Caine, and Cohen play in the new Masada Sextet, which has a strong jazz influence, and Feldman and Cohen are part of the classically-oriented Masada String Trio. Baron and Cohen also form the rhythm section of Zorn's acclaimed and long-lived post-bop quartet, acoustic Masada—so-called to distinguish it from Electric Masada, a jazz-rock fusion band (which also includes Baron). Indeed, Tzadik draws heavily on Zorn's circle of colleagues and collaborators from New York City's experimentalist downtown music scene. Over the past several decades, this community of composer/improvisers has developed new formal contexts, musical syntax, and performance practices that engage with a wide range of interests—in jazz, free improvisation, rock, noise, avant-garde concert music, and a variety of global idioms. Zorn coined the phrase “Radical Jewish Culture” in the early 1990s to describe (and encourage) the surge of interest among downtown-based artists in writing and performing new Jewish music. The recent klezmer renaissance was an influence, but most artists were interested in approaching the idea of “Jewish music” more idiosyncratically than klezmer allowed. Some created work whose Jewish aspect was conceptual or formally obscured, while others incorporated traditional Jewish melodies, texts, or synagogue modes into a downtownish musical landscape—thus mirroring the hasidic Jewish practice of making secular songs sacred by transforming them into the nigunim that lie at the heart of hasidic devotional practice.Footnote 5
Hasidism, a mystical branch of Judiasm that developed in Eastern Europe in the 1700s, has always placed song and dance at the center of its worship rituals. In performance, hasidic nigunim have a spiritual power, giving ordinary people a path to joyful communion with God (devekut).Footnote 6 Each hasidic sect has its own core melodies, and according to the liner notes the pieces on Secrets are based upon Lubavitch, Satmar, Bobov, and Modzhitz nigunim.Footnote 7 Unfortunately, the notes are minimalist to the extreme, and they provide no further contextual information.Footnote 8 Although the recording's individual nigunim are unattributed, it is likely they were originally borrowed from secular sources. As Ellen Koskoff asserts, in Hasidism it is considered a mitzvah (blessing, good deed) to adapt for a spiritual purpose melodies from outside the community. “But once adopted,” Koskoff continues, “a particular nigun usually became associated with, or was said to have been composed by, the person who first introduced it within the context of a Hasidic gathering.”Footnote 9
As the arrangements on Secrets suggest, in performance nigunim can be “slow, heartfelt, drawn out, and ornamentally embellished or wild and martially rhythmic.”Footnote 10 The calmer pieces on the recording include “Avinu Malkenu” (Our Father Our King), “Bobover Nigun,” “Z'chor Dovon” [sic] (Remember Thy Word), “Kel Adon” (God Is Lord), and “Moditzer Nigun.” “Lubavitcher Nigun,” “Z'chor HaShem” (Remember God), “Chabad Nigun,” and “Satmar Rikud” are faster, funkier, and more daring.Footnote 11 The more contemplative pieces feature a violin or piano playing an unadorned or lightly embellished melody to a tactful accompaniment: often, lightly tapped cymbals, brushed snare drum, and a rhythmically sparse (one-beat pizzicato) bass part. When Feldman plays the melody, Caine adds a harmonized countermelody or comps unobtrusively. “Kel Adon” opens with an unmetered, freely improvised interlude, as does “Moditzer Nigun,” a piano-bass duet that features a lovely melodic interplay between Caine and Cohen. However, when Feldman and Caine take solos in these tunes, they tend to reiterate straight rather than swung subdivisions of the beat. This rhythmic orientation, the lilting metric quality of the triple and compound meters, and the performance style of the violin and piano give these slower pieces a character that might best be described as “jazzy.”
Caine's fluency as an improviser animates the more rousing tunes, in which he seamlessly integrates nigun snippets into melodically inventive, rhythmically surprising, and harmonically refreshing solos. His jazz chops are especially evident in “Z'chor HaShem” and “Satmar Rikud.” The rhythm section opens the latter with a tense vamp à la acoustic Masada. Feldman, improvising freely over the vamp, executes a series of haunting, disparate phrases, to which Caine and Baron respond with subtly coloristic comping. When Feldman drops out, Caine launches into a solo over the tune's chord changes that creates a dramatic contrast to the opening mood: Caine's touch becomes more percussive, Cohen adopts a fast walking line, Baron begins dropping light, syncopated “bombs,” and the rhythm section starts to cook as a unit. Caine's dynamic solo lines are full of rhythmic surprises and new harmonic colors, including a few assertively bluesy gestures that invoke a semiotic field otherwise little in evidence on the recording. Next, Caine and Baron trade a series of lively eight-bar phrases, one of the few points in the recording where we can enjoy the joie de vivre of Baron's lyrical and rhythmic conception. (He also takes a playful solo on “Z'chor HaShem.”) “Satmar Rikud” is the farthest “out” of any of the pieces on the recording, not only in its jazz orientation, but also in that the ensemble never plays the main melody in full. By judiciously weaving melodic phrases and motives from the nigun into his solo, Caine may leave you humming it anyway.
In contrast, Feldman's occasional nonclassical touches, including a brief klezmerish trill in “Kel Adon” and a touch of Carnatic-style ornamentation in “Satmar Rikud,” highlight the otherwise European classical character of his playing. On Secrets, Feldman invokes the “High Church” style of early cantorial recordings more than he does either the jazz violin vocabulary or the “heritage music” approach of the klezmer revivalists, whose melodic phrasing is imbued with krechtsn (moans), scoops, catches, and slides.Footnote 12 In the early years of the recording industry, synagogue cantors began releasing recordings of liturgical and para-liturgical melodies arranged for solo voice with piano accompaniment—a niche that has expanded to include hasidic boy choirs, folk-rock ensembles, pop-oriented and family-friendly holiday song compilations, and the occasional mariachi combo or punk rock band. Neo-klezmer artists such as Andy Statman and Frank London have enriched this repertoire by creating a body of sophisticated instrumental arrangements of traditional Jewish melodies and nigunim. (Indeed, London, Caine, and Lorin Sklamburg released a collection of arranged nigunim on Tzadik over a decade ago.)Footnote 13 Secrets fits comfortably into this category. Listeners interested in exploring Baron, Caine, Cohen, and Feldman's more adventuresome work will find it amply represented on their other Tzadik releases.
