Do you tend to always bring at least two books on vacation that you need to read for your research? Do you bring them everywhere, open them often, but the amount of pages read remains desperately low?
Raising the Floor – How a Universal Basic Income Can Renew our Economy and Rebuild the American Dream by Andy Stern might be the solution to your conundrum. It will enrich your research, raise multiple risk regulation questions that you will want to answer as soon as you get back to your desk and be a pleasant vacation book. But let me say more.
First I need to say a few words on the author, as his background is key to understanding the case he makes in favour of adopting a universal basic income. As we learn in the first chapter, Andy Stern was the head of the most influential American union, the Service Employees International Union. He then became a member of the Simpson-Bowles Commission on fiscal responsibility and reform gathered by President Obama and is now the Ronald O Perlman Senior Fellow at Columbia University. In other words, throughout his career, he has collected a vast amount of knowledge on the evolution of the job market, labour issues and unions. He has also developed connections with key actors from whom even more insight can be gathered on the matter.
In this book, which is useful for both experts and lay persons, Stern analyses why the job market has been characterised by a steady decrease in the number of jobs available. The main suspects behind this trend which, according to Stern, will only get stronger, are “the fundamental restructuring of the economy and the emerging disruptive technology that threaten secure jobs and income” (book summary). In light of this evolution, Stern explains both why and how a universal basic income offers the best solution to avoid social upheaval.
So what is the connection between this book and risk regulation? The theme might seem disconnected, but not upon closer examination. Risk regulation is, in many ways, an attempt to build institutionalised foresight. But when the risk comes from technology, regulation primarily focuses on preventing physical threats – ie to the environment or to health – while in reality the shock wave can reach much further, for example to jobs and well-being.
Reading Stern’s book is an opportunity to adopt a more holistic assessment of the risks associated with novel technology (AI, robots, etc): an assessment which covers societal disruptions as well as physical risks. Stern’s granular analysis goes beyond the obvious and usefully debunks any parallel with the last industrial revolution. Contrary to the previous technological revolution, the one we are in will impact every sector of the economy and people with every level of education, including for example (sigh) lawyers. Fewer lawyers are needed when the applicable law can be identified reliably and instantly by research data engines, when smart softwares can not only automatically fill up an appeal but also analyse the applicable law and use big data to apply it to specific and individual circumstances … In other sectors, the impact will be drastic: just imagine what automatic cars will do to bus, taxi and truck drivers.
The book calls for a policy that is capable of anticipating and softening the wide and deep societal impact of technology. Stern reminds us that professional activities are not only how people get the means indispensable to live a decent life, but also, where many find a sense of purpose and community. The impact of a steep reduction in the need for human labour cannot be correctly anticipated and managed without a truly holistic policy, integrating innovation, industry, employment, environmental and economic policies. This is the book’s core argument, which is worth reflecting on. It reinforces the very well known imperative, for researchers in risk regulation, to think holistically and to actively seek cooperation with other disciplines as well as with stakeholders. Stern’s analysis is directed at the American society and job market, however, many of the trends that he observes are global and therefore informative even beyond the US.
The structure of the book is straightforward. The chapters constitute each step that Stern climbed to reach his conclusion, and form together a compelling demonstration. What follows details the main argument of the key chapters.
After a first chapter introducing the author, Chapter II explains why the author thinks that a reflection on the future of labour in human society is needed now. For him, the relation between people and jobs is at a “strategic inflection point” – “a turning point after which a dramatic change, with either positive of negative results, is expected to result” (p 28). Using, among other sources, Piketty’s work Capital in the Twenty-first Century, Stern brings detailed evidence of economic hot spots. For example, the decoupling between wages and jobs from growth, income inequality, unemployment rates are discussed at length.
Chapters III to VI identify the causes and forms of the current and future transformations of the job market. Chapter III dives into the impact of novel technology. It is based both on personal reflection and on interviews with key actors in the field which bring a lot to the analysis. Chapter IV gives an excellent summary of the movement towards a “gig economy” that consists of workers that add up and shift between different mission-based jobs. Recognising that working on gigs can bring flexibility to innovative people, Sterns uncovers in Chapter V that the gig economy is not without a dark side. The workers suffer from a lack of predictability and lose the protection provided by being part of a tangible community which could get organised to defend common interests. Chapter VI explains why the dynamics identified in the previous chapters suffocate the American dream. This reflection could be easily exported to shed light on the hopes of the European social market economy.
In Chapters VII and VIII, Stern explores the potential solutions. “What is the new culture-shifting idea, the new mechanism for driving large-scale economy?” (p 147). The author considers the merits and risks of distinct policy scenario trying to provide a solution to soften the impact of the job market revolution on people. He promotes the universal basic income as the most innovative solution, when tailored to national conditions and applied alongside other initiatives.
Stern, humbly and rightfully, does not pretend to offer a one size fits all model. He recognised that a successful implementation of the idea requires tailoring a model adapted to the specific context of each state: experimentation and constructive deliberation will be indispensable. The author, therefore, focuses on the first step: launching the discussion. To this effect, he sets in the last chapter a list of questions that any society – and any individual – will have to debate before deciding whether the path of the universal basic income is worth walking, and if yes, how.
The risk regulation community could make a significant contribution to the discussion; reading this book is an entertaining way to check whether you would like to join.
