Promiscuous Power is a history of the first century of colonisation and evangelisation in the province of Michoacán in New Spain. This developed out of the Tarascan state, a federated kingdom independent from the Aztec Empire and ruled by a monarch called the caltzontzin, whose execution on the orders of Nuño de Guzmán in 1530 opens the first chapter. Drawing on Inquisition files and ecclesiastical documents from municipal and church archives in the modern states of Michoacán and Colima, as well as the usual colonial archives in Spain, the author populates the region's highly variegated landscape of verdant highlands and sun-scorched lowlands with a cast of characters frequently more interested in drinking, womanising, murder, blasphemy and intoxicating flora than the greater glory of God or the Habsburgs. In other words, this is an account of the early colonial history of the region focused on the individual self-interested actors who contributed to the larger process of European colonisation with little reference to the grand designs of kings or viceroys. The focus is thus not so much on Indigenous responses to empire, which has dominated the recent scholarship, but on the little-known agents of empire on the ground: encomenderos, judges, missionaries (mostly Augustinians and Franciscans), inquisitors and the different people with whom they interacted (Spanish, Mestizo, Indigenous, African, etc.). None of these men (and they were ‘men’ for the most part (pp. 37–9)) possessed a grand plan, never mind a theory of empire. But each contributed in their own way to the ‘(un)making of empire’ in a globalising Hispanic monarchy that was nonetheless little more than a ‘loose archipelago of power’ (pp. 9, 3).
Reflecting its title, the book is written in a light-hearted and sometimes racy and colloquial style, which begins already in the acknowledgements. The argument itself is distributed across six narrative-driven chapters arranged around a particular protagonist or set of protagonists. Each case study, in turn, though limited in time and space, has a larger historical theme running through it, from regalism to caudillismo. These themes rooted in human foibles play out in layer upon layer of conflicts: between individuals, between families, between religious orders and between the patronato real (royal patronage) and the friars, which was itself a vicarious struggle between the imperial administration and the papacy. In an early modern world that prized corporate authority, each person or group could not only call on an ad hoc armed posse to defend their claims, but also make appeals to larger sources of authority that were likely to back them up. As Martin Austin Nesvig summarises it, ‘in this frontier, a few men wielded what amounted to promiscuous power, drawing strength and authority from overlapping institutions (such as royal court, municipal government, parish church, mendicant order, cathedral chapter, and Inquisition)’ (p. 3).
Although the reality was frequently sobering, the book brings sixteenth-century Michoacán to life in a way that few others have done. Highlights include an account of the struggles of Vasco de Quiroga to bring order to his chaotic diocese (Chapter 2), the theatrically ineffective efforts of the post-1571 Inquisition to bring to heel even the local clergy (Chapter 4) and the role of a powerful mafia of ‘sketchy and murderous dudes’ in Colima (p. 130) (Chapter 5). Building on the author's earlier work, the book history of the region also receives attention from time to time. While letrados (i.e. learned lawyers) were sent to Michoacán, copies of standard legal collections like Las siete partidas and Gratian's Decretum were hard to come by. This said, Indigenous-language grammars and catechisms were produced and circulated, probably in multiple copies, as necessary reading for missionaries. Royal and ecclesiastical documents were also produced and cited in large numbers, but these were more often than not used to undermine their authors’ original intentions, when they were not forgeries in the first place!
Although the work bills itself as an ‘unorthodox history of New Spain’ and is certainly highly evocative of the period generally, it is not a survey and would probably not be the first port of call when looking for a textbook for an introductory class on colonial history. This is because it is fundamentally focused on a single (though important and interesting) province of a single viceroyalty. Especially towards the end, it also becomes more akin to a colourful ecclesiastical history of the province. However, colonialists looking for an account of the region's history, and others looking for a general study of the period that focuses on a region that is neither the Valley of Mexico nor the Yucatán will find it useful as well as entertaining. Historians of the larger Hispanic or Iberian worlds will also be interested in the volume for what it tells us about the trials and tribulations of empire-building, and all readers will find pleasure in the volume's attractive maps, its very apt cover image and the additional information in the endnotes, which are full and generally enlightening.
Overall, Promiscuous Power succeeds in cramming a lot of lust, murder and ambition into its 200-odd pages. Part serious colonial history, part bodice-ripper, part paean to its geographical setting, it lays out a rich spread of colonial life that delights the reader on every page.
