Shahzad Bashir's Sufi Bodies: Religion and Society in Medieval Islam is a groundbreaking work in the study of Sufism. It demonstrates that theories of the body can aid scholars in reading hagiographical sources—including stories of the miraculous—for historical data concerning the socioreligious imagination of their authors. His approach is a straightforward one; he pays close attention to the myriad ways bodies are represented in Persianate hagiographical texts and miniature paintings from the 14th and 15th centuries. For example, he examines how bodies are used in “social performances” of spiritual authority in hagiographical sources in order to explore the social imagination and social contexts of the authors or miniature artists. By social performances, Bashir means the way we are habituated to certain social norms such that they seem utterly natural to us. To illustrate this point, I will use an unrelated example that I think will be most effective: consider that in the United States not too long ago, interracial marriage was considered by many as against the nature of things, both bodily and culturally, to such a degree that violence was necessary to protect the proper order. Racial purity did not maintain itself “naturally” but rather had to be continually performed through social and legal exclusion so as to establish and maintain its sense of naturalness to the order of things. In this vein, Bashir cautions us not to be seduced by the “naturalness” of these social performances but instead to recognize that our inward and outward actions in accordance with these norms are socially constructed to establish, maintain, or resist a status quo.
Bashir examines how representations of the body in Sufi hagiographical accounts work as performances of socioreligious hierarchies within and among Sufi networks (orders). His opening analysis of a miraculous initiatory handshake that confers spiritual authority across time and space offers valuable historical insight into the way in which the authors understood prophetic authority, who had access to it, and, most important, who did not. He demonstrates that these sources create socioreligious hierarchies that their readers could readily habituate, whether that means to establish, maintain, or resist them. Bashir's work is so well documented that it might read like a catalogue of examples proving fairly straightforward observations on gender hierarchies to scholars in other areas of study, such as Christian mysticism, where work on the body is more mainstream. He relies on the most accessible theoretical approaches to the body, focusing on the insights of Merleau-Ponty, Pierre Bourdieu, and Gabrielle Spiegel. But this should not be taken as a criticism. The fact is that the study of the body in Sufi sources is still in its early stages and a good number of scholars of Sufism will need to be convinced of its historical merit. This book will perform that necessary task (not to mention advance our understanding of this particular Sufi literature and of Sufism overall). The examples he chooses to demonstrate the social and religious hierarchies at work in the employment of these narrative images and miniatures cannot be considered marginal: the corporeal body's relationship to the imaginal body and the spirit; the body in ritual acts and spiritual athletics; the bodily intimacy of the lover–beloved relationship between masters and disciples; and the physicality of Sufi lineages (although I wish he had explained why he included only a brief section on the heart). I have no doubt that this book will change the way Sufism is studied from here on out. His argument that the body matters to the historical study of Sufism is so clearly laid out that after reading this book one will have to expend a good deal of intellectual energy to ignore its implications for the field.
I can best explain the impact of this book by relating some of the insights it offers on hagiographical material from the 14th and 15th centuries that I found to be valuable for my own work on early pious and Sufi women of the 7th to 11th centuries. His observations on the body and gender, for example, are extremely helpful in understanding how social formations considered “natural” to sexed and gendered bodies—in particular the inappropriateness of unchaperoned contact, let alone public or private bodily contact, between unrelated men and women—marginalize women within the Sufi tradition. In his sections on the lover–beloved relationship between masters and disciples, Bashir shows how the literature casts disciples’ bodies as impossible to overcome except through intimate bodily relationships with their masters: masters draw in potential disciples by transforming themselves into irresistible objects of desire; masters enter the bodies of disciples, such as when Saʿd al-Din Kashgari (d. 1456), the master of ʿAlaʾ ad-Din Abizi (d. 1487), miraculously stretches a hand from his heart into the heart of Abizi and squeezes it until the heart squelches through the master's fingers; masters take possession of their disciples’ senses or whole bodies, such as when Bahaʾ al-Din Naqshband (d. 1389) controls his disciples’ bodies with a mere flick of his sleeve; masters multilocate their own bodies to observe and interact with their disciples even in their most private moments, such as when Amin al-Din Baylani (d. 1334) sees that a disciple has not brushed his teeth before bed and multilocates to hand him a toothstick. Bashir demonstrates that this intimate discourse of bodies is necessary to the disciples’ incorporation into Sufi lineages and the maintenance of the lineages themselves.
Although Bashir could have been more explicit about the erotic capacity of master–disciple relationships, he nevertheless demonstrates that the narratives would have effectively excluded women from these intense forms of guidance and thus from Sufi religious and spiritual authority at the time. In the hagiographies he cites, some women are depicted as crossing these social boundaries, but they act as exceptions that prove the rule. Moreover they are often disembodied as sexed beings (women who are wives of masters or those seen as “men” on the path). But most often women, even mothers, are depicted in the hagiographies as barriers on the path. For instance, Nasr al-Din ʿUmar Murshidi (d. 1423) hears a woman's voice reciting Qurʾan, which incites a vision of her naked from head to toe and exposing her vagina to him. One interesting tale serves to inform its audience that women cannot “have it all.” An exceptional woman is depicted circling the Kaʿba by skipping on one foot. When asked about it, she says that her other foot remains back home rocking the cradle. Bashir comments that such accounts naturalize gender dichotomies, difference, and hierarchy.
These hagiographical representations of extraordinary bodies do not just tell us about how these authors perceived the embodied and gendered nature of the master–disciple relationship. The representations also indicate that they were intended to be used by their transmitters as recommendations to draw in disciples through the depictions of a master's miracles and/or a network's adherence to Islamic ritual and social norms. As such, the hagiographies determine the expectations of new disciples, constructing and maintaining the desired social norms so as to create a self-fulfilling narrative, one that I believe further research will bear out has had a negative impact on women's historical participation on the Sufi path even into the present.
I only wish that Bashir had taken a greater leap by discussing the material bodies of men and women in their lived circumstances—which I believe can be got at through social-historical research—rather than only the hagiographic representations of them. But that would require another volume and many years of research, so all is forgiven. It is my sincere hope that this brief discussion of the importance of Bashir's Sufi Bodies suggests to readers the book's value not only for the study of Sufism but also for the broader study of Islam.
