The republication of Austin Farrer: The Essential Sermons, forty years after Farrer's passing, will help introduce a new generation to the man whom Rowan Williams has called ‘possibly the greatest Anglican mind of the twentieth century’. In this collection, first published in 1991, Leslie Houlden has compiled fifty-two ‘timeless’ sermons, almost all of which Farrer preached to university students in Oxford. By editorial design, there is little in the sermons to reveal their social or liturgical context, beyond the themes and objections addressed. In this sense, these readings straddle a line between sermons, which are so necessarily shaped to time and place, and devotional literature, which may have more lasting currency.
Though Farrer's sermons have been in print for many years, they can look quite unusual on the homiletical landscape today; indeed, they set the contemporary field of homiletics – or at least one part of it – in striking relief. For nearly thirty years, narrative preaching has been an important theme in American homiletics and, since the early 1990s, some narrative homileticians have appropriated narrative theologies. A leading example is Charles Campbell whose book, Preaching Jesus: New Direction for Homiletics in Hans Frei's Postliberal Theology (1997), puts postliberal theological and hermeneutical proposals to homiletical use. Drawing principally on Frei, Campbell argues that in a postliberal homiletic the ‘crucial role of preaching is the use of Christian speech so that the community may learn to use its language rightly’ (p. 237). Or, as he says in borrowing a phrase from Wittgenstein, preaching prepares the community to ‘go on’ with the language of faith in new ways for new contexts (p. 234).
In God is Not a Story: Realism Revisited (2007), Francesca Murphy challenges Frei's proposals, and thus the foundations of Campbell's homiletic. Simply put, Murphy makes an extended plea for realism, arguing that contemporary narrative theologies yield a fictional God; the effort to ‘tell the story of God’ absorbs God into the story. So, in the case of Frei and ‘story Barthians’, the content of revelation is no longer the ‘the unmediated “thou” of the Lord’ (as for Barth), but the biblical story itself. The object of faith is no longer God revealing God-self through Christ, but the ‘Christ-for-us’ known in the biblical story alone. The result of these substitutions is that Christ is no longer an existent person, but a character identity; and the biblical text is no longer the free creation of inspired authors, but simply a given text. By absorbing these historical particulars into narrative – replacing content with method – Murphy argues that ‘story Barthians’ have enclosed ‘both Christ and believer’ in an ‘epistemological nexus’ (pp. 119–20). For homiletics, the implications of this enclosure become clear in Campbell's appropriation of Frei. If the crucial role of preaching and the response of the community are both defined linguistically, then preaching dead-ends in Christian hermeneutics – or more precisely, in a linguistically constituted Christian existence. Why does the preacher tell the gospel story? So the congregation can learn the Christian language and ‘go on’ with it in their lives.
But do we go on simply with Christian language? In his sermon ‘The Potter's Clay’, Austin Farrer tells doubting university students that the scientifically limited author of the early chapters of Genesis describes ‘the power which shapes things, and above all, men, here and now, and not once long ago in a fabulous morning of the world’ (p. 16). Moments later, Farrer charges the students, ‘We have always to ask, what is God doing with me now? What is his love doing with me now’ (p. 18)? Clearly, for Farrer, God is not enclosed in the biblical story, any more than God is enclosed in a ‘fabulous morning of the world’. Rather, God is active, and we go on, not simply with the story, but with the God whose story it is. Moreover, even as God is active, so we are free to act. Our going on with God is the loving response of created persons to their ever-creating creator; it is the freedom to act in the larger mystery of God's sovereign will. This paradoxical double-agency is a recurring and fundamental theme in Farrer's sermons, which he summarises with characteristic elegance in ‘Predestination’: ‘The believer unites his will with the creator's will, and so he learns the mystery of love . . . [W]e are never so ourselves as in the act of love which God inspires, never so alive as when we are clay under his fingers, and never so free, as in being predestinated’ (p. 41).
Austin Farrer's personal and dynamic understanding of God and humanity reveals something deeply impersonal and formulaic in contemporary narrative theologies and homiletics. Far from enclosing us in an epistemological nexus, Farrer uses profound Christian speech to lead us towards life in God and love for neighbour.
