In Gatekeepers of the Arab Past: Historians and History in Twentieth-Century Egypt, Yoav Di-Capua follows in the footsteps of Jamal al-Din al-Shayyal, Jack Crabbs, Jr., Muhammad Choueiri, and others in examining the development of modern Egyptian historiography, offering his own interpretation of the interplay between intellectual history, scholarship, and politics in 20th-century Egypt. The title of the book is somewhat misleading—this is about an Egyptian not an Arab past—but Di-Capua makes his thesis clear: “the main argument of this study is that the modern idea of history is a form of thought and habit of mind that arrived in Egypt in the late nineteenth century, bringing with them specific institutions and modes of reasoning” (p. 11). With an eye for the dramatic, Di-Capua sets the scene at the conference on Commitment and Objectivity in Contemporary Egyptian Historiography held in Cairo in the summer of August 1987 (substantial credit for which belongs to Roel Meijer along with Ahmad ʿAbdallah), which brought together a large number of Egyptian historians to address the interaction between historical scholarship and politics. Casting back from this point, Di-Capua surveys Egyptian historiography from the end of the 19th century until the end of the 20th century, covering its various stages beginning with the de-Ottomanization of history before 1914 and continuing beyond World War I to the emergence of nascent academia, royal historiography, and the popular-nationalist tradition, each of which projected a “different vision of Egyptian modernity” (p. 13). The last chapters focus on the post-1952 period, which Di-Capua regards as dominated by the political partisanship of historians when histories became “national allegories” and a field of contestation between socialists and academics. His final chapter on the period between 1970 and 2000 addresses the “crisis of historical consciousness,” a product of the logic and priorities of an authoritarian political order. Di-Capua concludes that modern Egyptian historiography is still deeply attached to the 19th-century European tradition and needs to engage with the “emerging global discipline of history on its own terms” (p. 343) in order to regain its vitality.
This is a rich and ambitious, if at times uneven, work. Di-Capua is certainly right to stress the primacy of the nation–state in 20th-century Egyptian historiography. His discussion of the construction of historical knowledge and politicization of history, while not as comprehensive as he suggests (p. 16)—he could, for example, have given consideration to resistance to the dominant paradigm—represents a sustained narrative of a developing national consciousness. The author marshals an impressive range of source material, particularly in his examination of the critical period from the early 1920s until 1952. Especially fascinating is the detailed discussion of the reorganization of the Egyptian national archives, termed “the Abdin project,” a central element of the royalist school sponsored by Fuʾad that used the services of a number of foreign scholars to emphasize the benevolent administration of the ruling family. Abdin was, Di-Capua explains, “not simply an archive but also an actual workshop for history writing and a powerful memory maker” (p. 131). He sees a state archive as central to a vibrant scholarship, but his contention that its archivists played a critical role in what was “historically thinkable” (p. 132) is surely an overstatement. State records are clearly a principal source for determining what is verifiable in a country's history but not what is conceivable. The continued lack of access to official records during the time of Sadat and beyond prompts him to a bleak assessment: “deprived of basic archival infrastructure for the post-1952 era, history writers could say and write whatever they wanted, but the overall sum of their activity cancelled itself out in a futile, magiclike cycle of one underdocumented account competing against another” (p. 327).
In his discussion of Egyptian historians, Di-Capua gives greatest attention and praise to two figures, Muhammad Shafiq Ghurbal and ʿAbd al-Rahman al-Rafiʿi. Di-Capua rightly recognizes Ghurbal for his key role as an academic historian, the founder of the Egyptian Historical Society, and the mentor of much of the next generation of Egyptian historians. Al-Rafiʿi, Ghurbal's counterfoil in many ways, is praised for his life's work in pioneering the nationalist historical narrative. Di-Capua also provides an attractive and informative narrative on some of the other distinguished practitioners in the field, such as Muhammad Sabri, ʿAbd al-ʿAzim Ramadan, and Raʾuf ʿAbbas. The distinction drawn between the socialist approach of Muhammad Anis and the social history school of Ahmad ʿIzzat ʿAbd al-Karim is perhaps too sharp. Despite contrasts in personal style and published output, they both made significant contributions to the emerging academic consensus.
Di-Capua's discussion of the last thirty years of the century is compact, with greatest attention given to Islamist historiography, at its best in the writings of Tariq al-Bishri but generally of low quality and poorly documented. He is pessimistic regarding the state of Egyptian historiography at the close of the century, bewailing the loss of textual hierarchy and professional standards, along with the lack of engagement with contemporary ideas in historical theory and method. These points are well taken, but Di-Capua could have given more credit to recent endeavors, such as those of feminist historiography (rather cursorily dismissed in a footnote on p. 335) or the ongoing project to document the history of the communist movement before 1965, which in different ways have sought to fashion new perspectives and document and preserve historical voices.
This is a book heavy in assertion and full of declaration with a penchant for the rhetorical that will provoke the reader. Some sallies strike a pseudo-epigrammatic quality: “the construct of cosmopolitanism is difficult to challenge, because it romantically assumes a fixed condition of equality and happiness for all” (p. 114). Occasional characterizations seem glib: the concept of public opinion is labeled as “very French” (p. 170) and the work of Collingwood “typically British” (p. 212). In a work replete with detail, some errors are almost inevitable, among them: “Israel Marcel” should be “Marcel Israel” (pp. 238, 246); Sammarco was born in 1883 not 1848 (p. 115); ʿAbd al-Rahman al-Rafiʿi was a prominent member of the National Party, not its formal leader (p. 13); Muhammad Anis obtained his doctorate from the University of Birmingham, not London (p. 151); the historian of modern Egypt is Mahmud Mitwalli, not Mutawalli (p. 310); the Conseil d'Etat is the Majlis al-Dawla, not the Majlis al-Shura (p. 320); and there is a curious confusion regarding Jamal al-Din al-Shayyal's name (p. 305n). Di-Capua's style can be distracting. The lengthy text alternates between long-winded passages and a desire to conjure a heightened sense of drama from the narrative. The tone is confident, at times florid, and occasionally dismissive. The idiosyncratic English can jar: al-Rafiʿi's scholarship is “slightly relentless” (p. 164) and “indigestible to those in power” (p. 171); university historians are said to have “sweepingly abstained” from contemporary history (p. 206); competing historiographies “sparkled” a debate (p. 177). The pun on Douin's account of the battle of Navarino, Navarin, and the French dish (p. 121) might have been better left for an informal occasion.
These issues aside, Gatekeepers of the Arab Past is an impressive piece of scholarship that puts forward important new research and a provocative analysis, which will stimulate debate among researchers as well as graduate and senior undergraduate students of the historiography and intellectual history of modern Egypt. The bibliography is extensive, and includes relevant theoretical literature, but regrettably the Arabic-language periodical references, which bolster much of the text, are not consistently listed.
