The representation of flamenco in Carlos Saura’s Flamenco Trilogy—Bodas de Sangre (Blood Wedding, 1981), Carmen (1983), and El Amor Brujo (Love the Magician, 1986)—may strike some as unconventional. The three films are set in Madrid, not Andalucía; the main artists are Spaniards, not gypsiesFootnote 1; and the flamenco performances take place not in “tablaos” (“bars” or “clubs”) but in dance studios in the first two films, and a studio recreation of a gypsy slum from Vicálvaro (southern part of Madrid) in the third film.
Saura embarked on this trilogy after the end of Franco’s dictatorship in Spain (following the dictator’s death in 1975). During the dictatorship, Saura’s film work disclosed a side of Spain that was hidden by Franco’s propaganda by focusing on symbolic and inner worlds to bypass censorship. With the arrival of democracy, Saura shifted his attention away from social reality to art and in particular flamenco, during the 1980s. The choice of flamenco was not accidental. In the trilogy, Saura’s perspective on flamenco was a clear response to the españolada, a genre developed during the 1930s and 1940s and inspired by the Franco regime’s efforts to manipulate and construct a specific image of Spanish national identity.Footnote 2 Saura’s collaboration with Antonio Gades in his Flamenco Trilogy brought to light a minimalist, profound, and highly technical approach to flamenco dance and musical performances which stood in clear contrast to the folkloric, exuberant, and exotic representations of gypsies and flamenco fostered during Franco’s time. The films also reveal a much more hybrid and complex Spanish reality by featuring not only a wide diversity of musical genres—opera, ballet, flamenco, folk music, flamenco-pop—but also artists from different cultural backgrounds, both gypsies and Spaniards from different regions of Spain, as well as artforms such as dance, music, photography, film, and theatre. It is through Saura-Gades’s deep engagement with diverse artistic expressions and representations that this different pespective on flamenco—and through it, of Spanish culture itself—comes to the fore.
Saura framed the first film of his trilogy, Bodas de Sangre, with a photograph. The still image captures a moment in the celebration of the wedding which includes all the characters of the play but Leonardo, the lover of the bride (played by Antonio Gades). Some of the characters seem to have been captured unawares in the snapshot, whereas others are posing. This combination of frozen movement and staged pose encapsulates the important role photography played in Saura’s life and artistic career. From personal mementos to documents of post-war Spanish reality to meaningful entry points into other artforms—cinema, dance, music—what Saura seems to have discovered through the photographic lens was the medium’s potential not to capture, but to represent reality (Reason Reference Reason2004). Their mediated status as representations takes photographs beyond the traditional understanding of them as mere copies of reality. Representations are rather epistemological tools that contribute to our understanding of human reality. All three films under consideration bring the constructed and mediated nature of representations to the fore as a means to reveal the close bonds that exist between fiction and reality.
Bodas de Sangre by Carlos Saura.

Bodas de Sangre is the cinematic articulation of Saura’s deep aesthetic experience while attending a rehearsal of Gades’s dramatic dance version of Lorca’s play in a studio in Madrid. Gades translated Lorca’s drama into the corporeal, spatial, and musical codes of choreography. Saura would follow suit by creating a highly mediated representation of the rehearsal in cinematic terms. The film begins by capturing the ritual that precedes the performance. The camera moves from long shots capturing the dancers arriving at the dressing room to medium and close-up shots detailing their transformation from persons into personae through costumes and make-up. Then, after a short warm up of some choreographic movements in the studio, Gades announces that they will perform the dress rehearsal without any interruptions. At that point, the performance starts. From this moment on, the ethnographic approach of the first part of the film gives way to a deeper, more avowed dialogue between the camera and the staged ballet performance. The best instance of this media dialogue occurs at the beginning of the third scene of the ballet (mins. 40:00–44:55 in the film, see Fundación Antonio Gades n.d.). The scene opens with Leonardo alone, imagining the bride getting ready for the wedding and dancing lovingly with her. This purely lyrical moment is rendered through a “choreography” of camera angles and shots. The lovers’ separate embrace is echoed and mirrored by crosscutting shots of their gestures and facial expressions. The poignant embrace then moves to the ground. An overhead shot emphasises even more the distance and isolation of the lovers rolling individually on the floor. When their bodies finally touch, the camera moves along with them in a dance that comes to an end with a separate embrace that rhymes with the opening one.
In Carmen, Saura employs a similar metadramatic approach. Yet this time he focuses on the porous boundaries between fiction and reality during the creative process of a flamenco danced rendition of Merimee’s novella and Bizet’s opera. The film plays with the crossings between fiction and reality at different levels. First, the actors and actresses, all of them members of Gades’s ballet company, play the roles of dancers preparing a flamenco version of Carmen. Second, except for Carmen, played by Laura del Sol, the other members of the cast keep their real names in the film. So, for example, Antonio Gades plays “Antonio,” Cristina Hoyos “Cristina,” and guitarist Paco de Lucía “Paco.” Third, the focus on the creative process during rehearsals blurs the boundaries between performance, illusion, and everyday life. Rehearsals are always in a liminal stage between the reality of the artists’ physical work and the illusion of the world created by their characters. An important section of Saura’s film is based on Gades’s search for the right dancer to play the role of Carmen and, having found her, his efforts to teach her how to dance the part he had in mind for the title role. During the rehearsals, there emerges a clear rivalry between Cristina and Carmen because both want to play the role of Carmen. The same rivalry existed between their real-life counterparts, Cristina Hoyos and Laura del Sol. Apparently, the intensity of their fight during the tobacco factory scene in the film was based on their actual rivalry. Finally, Antonio’s relationship with Carmen is also constantly shifting between the fictional world of the performance and the “real” world depicted in the film. During the rehearsals, Antonio and Carmen get too much involved in their roles and start a relationship that mirrors that of the fictional story. The film ends with Antonio killing Carmen, although it is uncertain whether the murder is part of the staged performance (following the fictional end of the opera) or part of the cinematic version (the reality within the film).
Flamenco Performance and/as Ritual: El Amor Brujo
Saura concluded his Flamenco Trilogy with a cinematic adaptation of Manuel de Falla’s homonymous ballet. Saura’s El Amor Brujo is a fictional ethnography focused on the ritual dimension of musical performances in gypsy life and culture. In line with the metadramatic approach of the former two films, Saura also starts this last one with another self-conscious gesture by drawing attention to its constructed nature during a pre-title sequence. The film begins with some ambient noise over a still image of a semi-opened garage door. After just a few seconds, the fanfare that opens Falla’s ballet takes the stage and prompts the closure of that garage door. The atmosphere suddenly becomes mysterious, with sustained string tremolos and appoggiaturas in the winds in pianissimo, as if locating us “in the cave at night”—quoting the title of this scene in the ballet. Along with the music, a two-minute tracking and tilting shot takes us to the interior of a film studio with a recreation of a gypsy slum in Vicálvaro, in the southern part of Madrid. The setting and lighting are clearly artificial, but once the camera brings the audience into the fictional story, the attention will be on the representation of daily life in this gypsy community. Since the very first moment, we see that life in gypsy culture is marked by rituals.
The story is triggered by an arranged marriage that will end tragically. The ethnographic value of the film lies in its realistic integration of the quotidian with the formality of traditional gypsy and religious rituals—usually performed through flamenco music and dance. The presence of music contributes to each ritual in different ways: fostering a sense of community during the wedding celebration, articulating intimacy between Candela and Carmelo when they dance together, commemorating religious events during Christmas, and also exorcising José’s spectre to free the haunted Candela. In this last case, the expulsion of the ghost requires the ritual fire dance. This dance is one of the most stylised representations of flamenco in the film, and yet it perfectly illustrates the integral part that musical performances play in gypsy rituals and life.
