No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 August 2005
In Sick Economies, Jonathan Gil Harris undertakes a study of the mutually constitutive relationship between the early modern discourses of trade and disease. He argues that “economic developments helped writers imagine disease as a foreign body,” while “the new vocabularies of contagious or exogenous disease provided writers with the imaginative resources for an emergent discourse of national and global economy” (p. 18). He leaves the reader in no doubt that tracts on trade employ complex medical analogies. Perhaps his clearest and most extended example is drawn from Malynes, who argues in The Center and Circle of Trade that “the obstruction of the Liuer, (Money, and the conduict Pipes of Spanish Royals and Germaine Dollers) must be opened by the meanes of the Braine, (Exchange) to minister good Bloud and Spirits to the Heart of our natiue Commodities, to make a liuely Trade” (quoted p. 144). But he also provides ample evidence of dramatists punning on the vocabulary of medicine and trade. For instance, in Michaelmas Term, Thomas Middleton underlines the pathological associations of consumption: “Oh, worse than consumption of the liver! / Consumption of the patrimony!” (quoted p. 163). Indeed, Harris contends that early modern drama is a particularly rich point of contact between the discourses of trade and pathology because Elizabethan theaters were focal points both of market forces and disease, as Jean-Christophe Agnew (Worlds Apart: The Market and the Theater in Anglo-American Thought, 1550–1750. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986), Douglas Bruster (Drama and the Market in the Age of Shakespeare. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992), and Leeds Barroll (Politics, Plague, and Shakespeare's Theater: The Stuart Years. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1991) have argued separately.
Harris organizes his chapters by considering the way particular texts pair a disease with an economic problem. Thus he explores the themes of syphilis and trade in the works of Thomas Starkey, Thomas Smith, and The Comedy of Errors; taint and usury in the works of Gerard Malynes and The Merchant of Venice; and so forth. He devotes most of his attention to the tracts on trade produced by Malynes, Edward Misselden, and Thomas Mun, and to plays written by Shakespeare (The Comedy of Errors, The Merchant of Venice, and Troilus and Cressida), Ben Jonson (Volpone), Thomas Heywood (The Fair Maid of the West), Philip Massinger (The Renegado), and Thomas Middleton (The Roaring Girl). A controlling opposition that reappears in several of the chapters distinguishes between a model of organization (whether bodily or economic) that assumes that health can be recovered by restoring humoral homeostasis and one that believes that health may be imperiled by foreign pathogens—whether plague or imported luxuries.
I do have some reservations about the book. The first is its use of the words “mercantilism” and “mercantilist.” Harris acknowledges that “mercantilism” was the brainchild of Adam Smith and that many subsequent historians have denied its existence altogether or redescribed it as a loose collection of ideas rather than a systematic theory or system of legislation. He says that he wants to analyze mercantilism “as primarily a discursive rather than an ideological or economic system,” one that is characterized by certain “strategies of signification, by means of which it produces both power and knowledge” (p. 6). This is an approach that he borrows from Michel Foucault's The Order of Things: An Archeology of Human Sciences (London: Tavistock, 1970) and Mary Poovey's A History of the Modern Fact: Problems of Knowledge in the Sciences of Wealth and Society (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998), but he says that he is interested in mercantilism as a discourse not of “factual” or “precise” representation (as they are) but of “transnational typology.” If Harris means anything more by this phrase than that mercantilists wrote about goods crossing national borders, he does not really explain what he does mean. Moreover, he refers to “mercantilists” in what appears to be an inconsistent manner—sometimes using the term with all of Adam Smith's force, at other times using it as a synonym for “writers on trade.” Occasionally he makes claims—for instance, that “labor” is a “category notably absent from mercantilist writing” (p. 14)—that seem impossible to accept no matter what construction is place on the word mercantilist. I was also unpersuaded by some of Harris's associations. For instance, in chapter 5 he suggests that an episode about the transmigration of souls in Volpone “provides Jonson with a satirical template for the representation of overlapping economic and pathological phenomena: that is, the movement of people, commodities, and diseases across the borders of national body politics” (p. 117); and in chapter 6, a passing reference to hepatitis in a tract on trade is yoked to the themes of castration and treasure in plays about pirates.
Yet there are excellent passages in the book. I found myself coming away from it with a sharper understanding of the imagery of disease in many early modern plays. I also found intriguing Harris's observation that plays that are set in shops before about 1600 tend to be set in workshops, whereas those that are set in shops after 1600 often feature luxury goods that may have been provided by guilds such as the Goldmiths as a means of promoting their products (p. 177ff.). For suggestions such as this, and for its attempt to grapple with the methodological problems posed by the creative interpenetration of seemingly discrete discourses, the book deserves to find a readership among early modern intellectual historians and economic historians.