Ideas that at certain times seem quaint or utopian can suddenly become sensible, rather mild and eminently feasible. Indeed, if one looks back at how progressive ideas unfold, one can appreciate how they have a habit of moving from being dismissed as fantastical to being reasonable and then essential.
The late Albert Hirschmann even wrote a book about this. He pointed out how numerous progressive ideas are met with three types of scornful criticism. First, there is a claim of perversity, that the policy would have unintended consequences that would defeat its objective, a claim of futility, that it would be ineffectual, and a claim of jeopardy, that it would endanger other goals.
Over the centuries, a few quirky persons have proposed the idea that everybody in society should receive a modest basic income as a right, in order to be able to meet their subsistence needs and take their place as starting point equals. Some of those have advocated something like basic capital grants, that is, lump sums to give them a start in life or to compensate for disability or old age or infirmity.
In this tradition, an early figure was Thomas Paine, most notably in his Agrarian Justice of 1795. Others have been advocates of a basic income paid in the form of a monthly sum of money, without conditions and paid individually. Distinguished early advocates of that include Charles Fourier, William Morris, Bertrand Russell and G.D.H.Cole.
However, in the past fifty years there has been a dramatic growth in the breadth of scholarly and political claims in favour of moving towards a basic income. In 1986, the Basic Income European Network (BIEN) was established by a group of economists, philosophers, sociologists and activists, which evolved in 2004 into BIEN, with the E changed to Earth, in recognition of the growing number of members coming from Latin America, North America and elsewhere.
This anthology is just one attempt to assemble the essence of the debates that have ensued, particularly since BIEN was established, although a surprisingly (and yet predictably) large number of American contributions have been included.
With any anthology on a complex policy, the eventual selection will reflect the views of the editors to a large extent, and this is no exception. Everybody who has been involved in the international movement and with the global network, BIEN, will feel vital contributions have been omitted and that minor items have been included.
Indeed, the authors seem besotted with my friend, Philippe van Parijs, reflecting their own early student days. This bias results in a strong over-emphasis on libertarianism, and a lot of sophistry around ideal types, like Lazy and Crazy, and Malibu surfers. Those issues should be included, but not to the extent that they have been.
The book is divided into nine sections, nominally on Freedom, Justice, Reciprocity and Exploitation, Feminism, Economics, Post-productivism, Implementation, Institutions and Politics. This is preceded by a general introduction, which defines basic income. Two points omitted in the definition are, first, that the basic income should be paid in monetary form, not in goods or services, and second, that it necessarily requires some boundary on determining entitlement, be it citizenship (as the British Citizen's Income Trust proposes) or legal residence, or some other definition.
Anyhow, while alternative pragmatic answers can be devised for that latter point, the result of the following nine sections is 74 chapters, many of which are excerpts from an author's paper or book. The result for anybody familiar with the literature is bound to be a feeling of frustration. This is probably most acute with the section on Freedom.
Overall, some of the contributions could have been excluded without much loss. Too many seem to be there because of the name of the person writing rather than for substantive content. An opportunity was missed to rescue some of the numerous papers that have been contributed to the bi-annual BIEN Congresses, most of which have not been published. At most Congresses, there has been a prize for the best paper. Here would have been an opportunity to publish them, even if some have been published in the journal Basic Income Studies. And rather than have little snippets from famous American economists, it was a shame not to revive some of the papers from the Congresses, as was attempted in Standing (Reference Standing2004).
However, the biggest grouse this reviewer has with this collection is that as a result of its philosophical bias, what might be called the structural case for moving towards a basic income has been under-emphasised, almost to the point of neglect. This, of course, is my bias. But an anthology should have both the main perspectives included equally.
The debate within the BIEN fraternity has been between those who focus on basic income by itself, dominated by libertarians of one kind or another, and those who argue that basic income can only be seen as part of a package of reforms, if one wishes to move towards a more emancipated, more egalitarian and more ecological society. This author belongs to the latter camp, and has been arguing this in papers and books since the early 1980s.
In this structural perspective (mentioned obliquely in Chapters 73 and 74 of the Anthology), it is implicitly accepted that most people would remain economically and socially vulnerable, and unfree, if they just received a basic income without other institutional changes.
Full freedom requires strong collective and individual Voice, or what can be called representation security. We must return to the perspective of Aristotle and Hannah Arendt, in saying that freedom is only realised through collective action, and should not be seen solely in individualistic terms. Put bluntly, the two meta-securities are basic income security and basic Voice security.
From a social protection viewpoint, basic income should be understood as the only way to provide ex ante basic economic security in an economic system in which economic uncertainty is prevalent. By contrast, social insurance and social assistance schemes, the hallmark of European welfare states in the post-1945 era, focused on ex post compensation for risks and adverse outcomes. That led remorselessly to workfare, and to issues under-played in this volume.
Finally, there is an understandable shortage of more recent literature. Although this book came out in late 2013, most of the chapters were originally published some years earlier.
With these caveats, this anthology is a very valuable contribution to the burgeoning literature on basic income. Most encouragingly, there is considerable evidence that the policy is moving into the mainstream of politics in many countries, in a context in which chronic insecurity is evident, in which the precariat is growing and in which inequalities cannot be reversed by conventional social democratic instruments. The main challenge now is about political mobilisation.
