Who was Anna Perenna? Or, rather, who did the Romans imagine her to be? Dido's sister, transformed into an Italian river nymph? An old woman from Bovillae, deified in reward for feeding the plebeians during their secession? A goddess of licentious celebrations and transitions from old to new? A figure whose pictorial representation communicates trustworthiness and success? These questions (each of which is explored in Gwynaeth McIntyre and Sarah McCallum's coherent and thoughtful volume) show the range of possible qualities associated with this figure from Roman mythology. Through its introduction and nine chapters, McI. and McC.'s book fulfils its aim of analysing Anna Perenna's place in Roman culture from a variety of perspectives. After a brief preface from the editors, T. P. Wiseman's introduction offers a chronological overview of the primary evidence and a discussion of the potential conclusions it might inspire. The chapters following these pages are divided into four sections: ‘From Carthage to Rome’ analyses the construction of Anna Perenna as an erstwhile Carthaginian princess now enmeshed in Roman culture (three chapters); ‘Anna and Her Nymphs’ focuses on Anna's divine status (three chapters); ‘Champion of the Plebs’ pays attention to the goddess’ associations with that group (two chapters); and ‘The Afterlife of Anna Perenna’ contemplates her links with James Joyce's Finnegans Wake (one chapter).
The book's chapters survey a range of evidence (e.g. literary, epigraphical, numismatic) and they share a willingness to offer nuanced readings that balance their insight into Roman culture with an appreciation for the questions that remain open. The entire volume will be of interest to those studying Roman history, culture, or mythology, while individual chapters will be worthwhile reading for those focusing on more specific topics, such as the literary relationship between the Fasti and the Aeneid or the iconography of the Altar of Peace. Since space is limited in this review, I concentrate here on representative chapters from the book's four parts.
McI. and McC.'s chapters in ‘From Carthage to Rome’ showcase the potential for considering how the Carthaginian and Roman aspects of Anna Perenna's identity play out in different media. In ‘Rivalry and Revelation: Ovid's Elegiac Revision of Virgilian Allusion’, McC. studies the figure of Anna in both the Aeneid and Fasti. In the epic, she convincingly argues, Virgil fashions ‘a metaliterary love triangle’ by alluding to a Varronian tradition wherein Anna, not Dido, becomes Aeneas’ lover (22), while Ovid uncovers his predecessor's handling of these different traditions in order to spotlight how his ‘own multi-layered and multi-generic narrative is a model of inclusivity’ (35). While McC. writes about how Roman authors imagine a Carthaginian princess, McI.'s contribution looks to a Carthaginian frieze to glean insight for a monument central to Augustan culture. As part of her argument that the central figure of the south-eastern panel of the Altar of Peace should be interpreted as Anna Perenna, McI. marshals an impressive array of literary, iconographic and epigraphic evidence that links details such as the figure's seated position with Anna Perenna. Most strikingly, McI. discusses an altar relief from the Augustan colony of Carthage that is almost identical to this Ara Pacis panel, and she argues that the figure of Anna, central to each of these panels, could serve ‘to unite … these two communities’ (66).
The section ‘Anna and Her Nymphs’ analyses Anna Perenna's role as a divinity in Roman thought, and David J. Wright and Anna Blennow's chapters focus on literary and epigraphic evidence respectively. In ‘Anna, Water, and Her Imminent Deification in Aeneid 4’, Wright deftly shows how instances of wordplay in Aeneid 4 forecast Anna's role as a Roman nymph and thereby associate her with a similarly tragic nymph from the epic's second half. After discussing its association with nympha, Wright discusses the use of lympha in two passages connected to Anna, one of which (4.634–7) contains an acrostic (ADES) redolent of prayers for divine assistance. Wright explores how these associations between Anna and her future status as a water nymph link her with Juturna and thus ‘highlight their similar, tragic plight’ (82). Epigraphic remains, meanwhile, are the focus of Blennow's ‘Instability and Permanence in Ceremonial Epigraphy: The Example of Anna Perenna’. Focusing on three votive inscriptions found at the fountain of Anna Perenna, Blennow argues that these inscriptions represent the change contained in the final step of ‘the votive process’, when the humans who asked for and received Anna Perenna's help fulfilled their vow to the goddess through inscription and donation (106). This temporal perspective, Blennow shows, raises a fascinating tension, as these inscriptions coexist spatially with the curse tablets found in Anna Perenna's fountain; whereas the inscriptions ‘can be seen as the end point of change’, the tablets, which ask for harm to come to one's enemies, are ‘active makers of change over a period of time’ (109).
The book's penultimate part, ‘Champion of the Plebs’, considers how the Romans imagined Anna Perenna's relationships with the plebeians, a topic Teresa Ramsby explores from a numismatic perspective in ‘Ovid's Anna Perenna and the Coin of Gaius Annius’. Convincingly drawing together evidence relating to coins, historical context, and Gaius Annius’ family, Ramsby argues that the figure on the obverse of Annius’ coins is Anna Perenna. Demonstrating how this goddess is strongly favoured by the plebs, Ramsby shows how Annius’ choice to associate himself with Anna Perenna functions to both ‘endear him to the Roman army and sanction a victory on behalf of’ the anti-plebeian Sulla (124).
The volume's final and briefest section consists of Justin Hudak's chapter ‘Riverrun: Channelling Anna Perenna in Finnegans Wake’. Adroitly bringing together two complex literary works, Hudak argues that Joyce draws on Ovid's Anna Perenna in constructing his character of Anna Livia Plurabelle. Beyond demonstrating the links between these two figures, Hudak suggestively claims that Joyce's engagement with Ovid extends beyond this association between characters to make Finnegans Wake ‘a highly concentrated Ovidian solution’ (161).
McI. and McC. have brought together a thought-provoking group of papers that productively study an enigmatic mythological figure from a multiplicity of perspectives. One testament to their success is that the volume as a whole offers a series of arguments that provoke further questions about topics like literary reception, pictorial representation and the apotheosis of non-elite and non-Roman figures, so that readers may both gain insight into particular aspects of this enigmatic goddess while also appreciating the many topics concerning Anna Perenna that still remain to be explored.
