At the end of the nineteenth century, and well into the twentieth, the so-called science of eugenics enthralled intellectuals and elites in the Western world. They believed that certain peoples, mostly northern and western Europeans and their descendants, possessed greater inherent strengths of loyalty, intellectual ability, and honor than other ethnic groups. Although no proof existed for such conclusions it did not deter individuals from reasoning that it did. As a result of these erroneous beliefs people were categorized by race, gender, and geography and pigeonholed into various levels of “inferior” groups. The closest others came to being like Anglo-Saxons, the higher their ranking.
Through bigotry and ignorance, the whitest of men, and sometimes women, thought that they should rule the world and set moral standards. Few of their peers questioned these beliefs and generally held that God had endowed them with responsibility (the “white man's burden”) for teaching others how they should live. In this insightful book Cybelle Fox sheds light on how ideas like these affected American social welfare policies and priorities during the Progressive and New Deal eras. Focussing on immigrants from southern and eastern Europe in the Northeast and the upper Mid-western states, African Americans in the South, and Mexican Americans in the Southwest, her book attempts “to tease apart the relative influence of race, formal citizenship, and legal status for access to the social safety net” (2). As she easily shows, there were considerable differences in the distribution of relief, and the reasoning behind it, in the different regions that the book covers. At the beginning of the twentieth century, and well into the 1920s, relief for the poor generally came from local sources and included contributions from more affluent members of society. Federal assumption of assistance to those in need began during the New Deal era.
Although new laws prohibited discrimination based on race or ethnicity, local administrators allocated funds based on regional cultural values. Moreover, in times when planting or harvesting required many field hands, growers urged relief administrators in both the South and Southwest to cut blacks and Mexicans from the relief roles so that they would have to work to maintain themselves and their families.
Of the three groups, white European immigrants fared best in receiving relief. They lived among other immigrants; they were beholden to political “bosses” who in turn needed their votes; and it served everyone's interests to keep those in need supplied with food, clothing, and shelter. In the areas where they lived some Americans thought that the newcomers could be taught “American” ways and that eventually they or their children might assimilate into mainstream society. In the South, African Americans were always part of the regional culture, subject to the patronage of white community leaders. It served the needs of those who were more prosperous to keep the black people “in their place” and to call upon them when menial work was available. Most people in the region considered blacks genetically inferior. Nonetheless, some southern leaders assumed responsibility for keeping them from total deprivation. Thus African Americans in the South received some assistance but not at the same level provided to whites.
Mexicans and Mexican Americans in the Southwest fared the worst. They were often denied benefits because other white people believed them indolent and undeserving. Even though they were legally “white,” most southwesterners regarded them as non-white, “not like our people” (113), and of weak mental development. Many Americans attributed these alleged aspects of a Mexican's heritage to the fact that most of them were a mixture of Indian and Spanish “blood” (76). Some business leaders and agricultural barons knew that Mexicans were needed for menial labor during seasons of high agricultural demand, but their voices were often not heard. Social workers whose job descriptions included care and assistance for Mexicans looked down upon them. They were also among the leaders who wanted Mexicans expelled from the United States. No laws were passed, either by Congress or by southwestern state governments, requiring expulsion, but regional attitudes trumped legislation, or lack of same. During the Great Depression trainloads of Mexicans and Mexican Americans, including some born in the United States, were involuntarily returned to Mexico.
Fox has masterfully explored how relief was thought of and distributed in different parts of the United States during the first four decades of the twentieth century. She highlights the inhumanity of many charged with helping those in need who had, however, failed to do their jobs properly. Moreover, as she states near the end of her work, she has provided “a nuanced picture of how race, citizenship, and nativity served as dividing lines between those who were judged worthy of assistance and those who were not” (281). Scholars and others interested in the nitty-gritty of regional and national relief politics and policies will appreciate the depths of her research in both primary and secondary sources. She has provided them with a gold mine of information. More casual readers might find the excessive detail mind-boggling.
