This exchange has been so pleasing to be a part of, as it raises a number of key questions about how to conduct APD research and where the field is headed. I am especially thankful to Julie Novkov, who has been a leader in rethinking the intersection of race and development in the field of APD/law. I would like to use the remaining few paragraphs to touch on the issue of ideational change, which was raised by Novkov’s insightful review.
Novkov argues that my analysis would have been strengthened through a greater focus on how changing ideas influenced not just activism but the political landscape. Of course, she is right. However, this was a calculated decision on my part for two reasons that I would like to briefly explain: a desire to engage the traditional APD understanding of “a durable shift in governing authority,” and the near silence of black political agency in APD research.
First, the push to grant greater consideration to the world of ideas in APD analyses is one that I am sympathetic to. I especially think a focus on ideational change is important in research on race in APD. The sole study of political actors and institutions in the early stages of American political development has resulted in an almost race-less description of development, because racial minorities were shut out from formal politics. I believe works such as Johnson (Reforming Jim Crow: Southern Politics and State in the Age Before Brown, 2010) and Brandwein (Rethinking the Judicial Settlement of Reconstruction, 2011) are incredibly valuable in this respect and it’s the reason I discussed the anti-lynching work of Ida B. Wells at such length in the book.
At the same time, the rest of the field does not seem to be so convinced about the importance of ideas and I believe that it can be useful to engage these traditionalists by highlighting ideational change through a focus on institutional change. This is not to say that important work highlighting ideas should conform to traditional dictates of subfield practice and forsake a more nuanced analysis of ideas. That would be in one word: boring. But I do want to reconsider how, together, both orientations can revise the mainstream understanding of American statebuilding and challenge other approaches in American politics.
Second, the explicit focus on black activism was done to reclaim what I feel has been too often lost in APD (and American politics) research by well-meaning scholars who study ideas as well as institutions. I am admittedly less concerned about the way ideas influenced the political landscape than I am about how black activism directly influenced rhetorical shifts in political elites and shifts in institutions. I’ve found that many of the ideas that become elevated and embedded in institutions or that change how policymakers approach the problem of racial violence came out of black activist circles at the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th centuries, and I think its important to trace back and locate the origins of these ideas. In other words, while race is sometimes part of the story in APD analyses—it is rarely the center of the story in ways that a close reading of history suggests it should be. My desire was to shift the analytical focus to the role of black activists.
Finally, in reading through this exchange, I am incredibly encouraged and hopeful that a broader understanding of statebuilding and development will emerge—one that takes ideas, non-state actors, and institutions seriously!
