Exploring the political culture of the three civilizations that emerged in medieval Europe, North Africa, and Western Asia in the wake of the barbarian migrations and the rise of Islam is by no means an easy task. The editors and authors of the present volume accomplished it brilliantly. Its chapters take us on a sweeping diachronic, cross-cultural, and interdisciplinary tour de force, covering sources, historical developments, and intellectual discourses over a time span of nine centuries. Although interdisciplinarity has in recent decades become a widely acclaimed paradigm of innovative scholarship, this book forms the first attempt to systematically compare formations, concepts, and practices of political culture in the Latin West, Byzantium, and Islam, juxtaposing each sphere's particularities with commonalities, parallels, and shared experiences on the basis of a well-defined set of questions.
Two introductory chapters, one by the editors and one by R. Stephen Humphreys, provide a flexible definition of the term “political culture” against the background of a broader shift of scholarly interests to “broader trans-regional contexts” (1). A major stumbling block lies in the fact that each of the three spheres has developed its own concept of power, authority, and rulership, articulating them in different languages and variegated intellectual traditions. The core languages of Latin, Greek, and Arabic came to be supplemented by numerous European vernaculars and literary languages used by Muslims and eastern Christians. The editors get around this problem by pinning down a “shared conceptual framework” (4), with a special focus on monarchy and elite power relations and various common features, such as imperial rule, monotheistic traditions, and the legacy of ancient Rome. The latter is of course less visible in many parts and periods of the Muslim world but certainly loomed large in the Umayyad empire and becomes again tangible in the Ottoman state of Mehmed the Conqueror. Stephen Humphreys gives a broad definition of politics as “that body of institutions and practices by which a society controls its resources and distributes the power to allocate those resources among its members” (17), highlighting the material aspect of resource control as the underlying driving force of political action. He then singles out four key elements, namely religion, women, property, and war, as indispensable components of politics emerging in all periods and societies. The topic of female elite agency in family, marriage, and public life has been well studied regarding the Latin West but awaits further exploration in the other two spheres.
The comparative survey chapters of this volume are organized in four parts, each dedicated to a key theme of political culture. It is understandable that the authors had to make choices. Except for Rosemary Morris's contribution, which extensively discusses post-1204 developments and Byzantium's integration into the rising Ottoman empire, the Byzantine chapters focus primarily on the period 700–1204. The Muslim world chapters are more balanced in terms of chronological coverage, as they are coauthored by specialists of three different periods: Andrew Marsham, Eric Hanne, and Jo Van Steenbergen. The Umayyad/early Abbasid, Buyid/Seljuk, and Turco-Mongol eras thus receive equal treatment. The emphasis lies with the eastern heartlands of Islam and the Nile-Oxus region; North Africa and Spain come up only occasionally. The western chapters concentrate on the Carolingian world and its successor entities in France, Germany, Italy, and the British Isles. The fringe zones of Scandinavia, Iceland, Hungary, and Poland are often referred to, but the Iberian Peninsula, the Norman realms of Italy and Sicily, the Angevin and Aragonese dynasties in the Mediterranean, and the Latin East surface only in passing. As explained in the introduction, the editors deliberately omit the contact zones of the Mediterranean. Considering that Latin, Byzantine, and Islamic entities in this region closely interacted with each other, overlapped territorially, and merged their institutions and practices, this decision certainly makes sense. Rather than distinct spheres, the medieval Mediterranean often represents a hybrid continuum defying the artificial separations of modern academic disciplines. Late Byzantium was in many ways both Greek and Latin, just as the Seljuk sultanate of Anatolia or the early Ottoman state resulted from a blending of Christian and Muslim-Turkish elements. Such a topic could easily fill another volume and would perhaps require a different framing of politico-cultural spheres.
Part 1 on “Sources” treats a wide range of administrative, legal, normative, and historiographical texts, outlining broader characteristics based on select snapshots. A long chapter on the Latin West discusses genres and text categories with respect to ideas of kingship, concepts of order, inauguration rituals, and institutions of government. The inexhaustible wealth of archives, administrative records, and documentary sources grants insights into numerous aspects of political culture that are not available in the other spheres. Byzantium and the Islamic world exhibit a very different state of transmission, marked by disruptive events and discontinuities in the preservation of archival material. Hence, historians approach their political culture via a relatively limited range of key texts related to historiography, concepts of rulership, administrative practices, and legal traditions.
Part 2 on “Historical Contexts” outlines the ties between geography and political constellations and surveys political formations, social groups, and religious institutions. Despite some shared components, such as Catholic Christendom, papal influence, and a clergy-based literary culture, Latin Europe exhibited plenty of geographic and cultural differentiation within ever-changing political formations, realms, communities, and social groups, from the early medieval kingdoms up to premodern territorial states. As an overarching pattern, Len Scales stresses the tensions between ruling elites based on blood nobility, warrior aristocracy, and knighthood, on the one hand, and other forms of political participation via urban and rural assemblies enabling the integration of broader sections of the population into the political process on the other. In all these procedures, the church played a crucial role, in endowing rulers with sacredness, divine sanction, and glorification and in providing a moral and theological framework for political conduct and popular action. In comparison, Byzantium prior to 1204 was a rather homogenous unitary state straddling the Balkan Peninsula and Asia Minor. Due to invasions and periods of expansion, however, borders and centrally controlled areas shifted considerably over time, and the empire's ethnic composition underwent considerable changes. Moreover, Byzantium maintained a broad network of diplomatic contacts with and politico-cultural influence on entities surrounding the empire. As regards the interior, Catherine Holmes points to the discrepancies between the empire's outward appearance as a centralized bureaucratic state centered around an imperial court and a hierarchy of officials and its internal mechanisms of politics and decision-making, in which aristocratic houses, family structures, and dynasties played a pivotal role, and various social groups, such as elite women, eunuchs, city dwellers, and peasant communities, found leeway to pursue their individual interests. Generally speaking, there was a close interplay between institutional and personal factors, and it is impossible to say if any of them outstripped the others. This observation argues against a certain propensity in Byzantine studies to focus on institutions and legislation and to tacitly assume that the empire operated within the parameters of a well-functioning state apparatus. A recent trend to reemphasize traditions and practices of ancient Rome in terms of political procedures, state structures, and self-definition further enhances this way of thinking. Nevertheless, when comparing behavioral patterns in East and West, one comes across numerous parallels. Just as in the West, the church with its models, teachings, legal concepts, and monastic communities exerted a strong influence on political procedures. In the Muslim world, the emergence of Islam signified a radical shift in the history of the affected regions, which brought about the establishment of a new ruling elite rooted in the Arabian Peninsula and new political structures grounded in Muslim doctrines. Political fragmentation, the revival of local traditions and ethnic groups, and the Turco-Mongol migrations elicited numerous cultural and political changes to the Islamic Empire, with local dynasties, rival caliphates, and new types of power holders.
Part 3, on “Norms, Values and Their Propagation,” examines concepts of legitimacy, the propagation of images, and the enforcement of norms. The plurality of the Latin West contrasts with Byzantium's gravitational pull toward the court of Constantinople with its offices, laws, ceremonies, and hierarchies. The Fourth Crusade resulted not only in the empire's partition and the establishment of Western feudal states in the Aegean but also in a massive dissemination of Western norms and practices in the Byzantine sphere. The Islamic equivalents were ideas of monarchical rulership centered around the office of the caliph, accession and succession procedures based on concepts of leadership in the Muslim community and oaths of allegiance, elaborate ceremonies staged in Muslim palaces and Friday mosques, the rise of the sultanate with its honorific titles and symbols of authority, and a wide range of new elements introduced by Turco-Mongol hegemons between the 13th and 15th centuries.
Part 4 on “Practice and Organization” evolves around the question of maintenance of political power. Daniel Power distinguishes between the papacy and Charlemagne's empire as the “two forms of universal rulership” (372) in Latin Christendom, on the one hand, and numerous regional forms of political organization, such as dynastic kingdoms, autonomous city states, ecclesiastical lordships, medieval leagues, and territorial principalities centered around castle-based lords with military retinues and princely courts, on the other. He goes on to discuss the sources of hegemony in military, economic, and judicial power, as well as the church as a separate institution with its own system of dominance and its conflicts with lay powers. Elites consolidated their social status and maintained their power against people of lower standing through concepts of noble birth and knighthood. Succession procedures within dynastic kin-groups were regulated through an elaborate system of inheritance practices. Important mechanisms of organizing political power were institutions of public authority, Roman law, administration of justice, coinage, households, and patronage. In Byzantium, elites were rather vaguely defined and less separated from other social groups, but there were certain criteria precluding access to the highest echelons of the state hierarchy. Rosemary Morris surveys the sources of power and economic resources of Byzantine elites, differentiating between the leading aristocratic clans, provincial nobility, and wealthy merchants. A complicated system of imperial stipends, land grants, and tax exemptions enabled elite members to accumulate wealth and gain influence in the inner circles of power, but many details of this system are still subjects of controversy. It is quite questionable, for instance, whether offices and salaries outstripped land as a source of wealth, as some scholars hold, so that Byzantine aristocrats were less land-based than their Western peers. Again, the Islamic world throughout the centuries underwent numerous profound shifts, each of which brought new elite groups to the foreground. Arab, Berber, and Iranian military elites, war bands of Turkic and Mongol background, and Mamluk royal households employed and developed Muslim administrative and fiscal practices of the classical age, relied on the legal principles and doctrines laid out by religious scholars (ʿulamaʾ), and introduced traditions and organizational patterns rooted in their original homelands and tribal cultures. Although Islam provided a shared set of structures, practices, and principles, there were more varieties and particularities in time and space than in the other two spheres.
Overall, this volume is a major achievement of interdisciplinary collaborative scholarship. Specialists who feel at home in one or two fields will be inspired by thought-provoking observations, unexpected parallels, and helpful cross-references and comparisons. Students and general readers will find a dense, but highly readable and comprehensive, introduction into the intricate subject area of medieval political culture with its manifold subareas and scholarly debates. The book will be an indispensable tool for all sorts of trans-regional comparative endeavors aspiring to cross the boundaries of traditional academic disciplines.
