This volume is the first of a series of books that will publish almost two decades of archaeological research that the University of Helsinki undertook at Insula IX 3 at Pompeii. It provides a detailed analysis of the corpus of finds, works of art, and inscriptions recorded in the large domestic complex at IX 3, 5.24 (the so-called Casa di Marco Lucrezio), from the first excavations carried out in 1847 to the more recent ones undertaken between 2002 and 2012 by the “Expeditio Pompeiana Universitatis Helsingiensis” (EPUH). Edited by Ria Berg (B.) and Ilkka Kuivalainen (K.), the book is organized into three major sections (“Le iscrizioni parietali,” “Finds from the 1847 excavations,” and “New finds from the 2001–2010 excavation campaigns”) which include 12 essays written by an eclectic team of scholars who have analyzed, interpreted, and assembled an enormous amount of data to build an understanding of the last phases of activities carried out within the Casa di Marco Lucrezio.
Formerly named the Casa delle Suonatrici, the house was renamed after the discovery of a small painting inscribed with the name of a certain Marcus Lucretius, who might have been the last owner of the house. Through a painstaking effort which entailed the reading of several inventories and archival sources, the authors were able to produce a remarkable contextual analysis of the more than 500 finds from this well-known, elite domestic complex set near the Central Baths, with its main entrance opening onto the Via Stabiana. Furthermore, a detailed description, analysis, and complete bibliography, as well as good-quality photos, are provided for the objects that the authors were able to locate in the collections at the Museo Archeologico Nazionale di Napoli and at Pompeii (67 in total). I personally found refreshing and encouraging the choice of beginning the first volume of the EPUH publications by focusing on these two types of evidence (wall inscriptions and material finds), since the latter, in particular, has for too long been dismissed or taken second place in favor of a more vivid interest in the architectural and decorative evidence.Footnote 1 All in all, this is a laudable work which highlights the potential of the study of the contextual distribution of the Pompeian artifactual evidence.
As highlighted in the brief preface by Castrén, who directed the EPUH Project from 2002 to 2009, the volume is the result of a long-established and praiseworthy collaboration between Italian and Finnish institutions. In the introduction that follows, B., coeditor and author of the majority of the essays, presents the three major phases of research undertaken in Insula IX 3 during the years 2002–12. During phase 1 (2002–6), the team conducted the excavation and field documentation of structures and wall paintings. Phase 2 (2006–8) saw the preparation and inauguration of an exhibition dedicated to the Casa di Marco Lucrezio at the Amos Anderson Art Museum in Helsinki (March 1–May 25, 2008).Footnote 2 Phase 3 (2009–12) was dedicated to additional fieldwork and archival research, as well as analysis and interpretation of the evidence in preparation for final publications. As B. notes, while other independent volumes on the architectural, structural, and decorative evidence of the entire city block at IX 3 will be produced, the present volume concentrates only on the inscriptions, works of art, and finds from the Casa di Marco Lucrezio.
Formed by the union of two originally separated houses some time during the beginning of the 1st c. CE, the Casa di Marco Lucrezio contains two atria set on different levels and a small garden, occupying a total area of about 555 m2. The first excavations of the house were conducted in 1847, during a period in which there was not yet a systematic method of excavation and recording of artifacts.Footnote 3 In recent years, scholars have started to pay attention to the artifactual evidence and the spatial distribution of activities within the Pompeian household.Footnote 4 As B. explains, however, the present volume mostly differs from such earlier studies by trying to trace finds recorded during earlier excavations. Although most of the finds could not be located, photographed, and personally analyzed (this was possible for only 12% of the original finds), the book presents a systematic analysis of the entire recorded assemblage of finds, including those not located and lost.
Dedicated to the wall inscriptions found in the house, the first section of the volume includes two essays by Castrén and Varone which complement each other and perfectly introduce the history of this property that will be later unraveled through the analysis of the artifactual evidence. Castrén provides an overview of this type of evidence, which is then analyzed and discussed in detail in Varone's catalog. Among the most famous inscriptions found in the house is the wall painting mentioning Marcus Lucretius, a member of the ordo of the city decurions and a priest of Mars. While the lack of a cognomen does not allow one to identify with certainty this M. Lucretius, Castrén provides a brief discussion of the gens Lucretia at Pompeii and offers some possible suggestions. Completing the list of inscriptions are a small number of modern ones left by both local people (who most probably participated in the excavations of the house) and international visitors who “tagged” their names on the walls, demonstrating that the house was a popular place of visits during the second half of the 19th c.
In the essay that follows, Varone meticulously documents and analyzes the full list of ancient wall inscriptions in the house, the vast majority of which are no longer extant. His catalog presents six painted inscriptions and various graffiti, eight of which are unpublished and were found by the author himself and Castrén. Of the painted inscriptions, five were electoral programs that are no longer extant and were once painted on the house's main facade along the Via Stabiana, one of the busiest streets of Pompeii.Footnote 5 As for the graffiti, all three types are attested in the house (textual, figural, numericalFootnote 6), spanning from simple names and short phrases to drawings and numbers. Of particular interest are the names of some slaves belonging to the court of Nero, which support the evidence for the householder's connection with Rome and the imperial family.Footnote 7
Various essays dedicated to the analysis of the finds from the 1847 excavations directed by Guglielmo Bechi comprise the second section. B. outlines the rich collection of archival sources employed and analyzed to rebuild the 79 CE artifactual assemblage, highlighting both the rich, complicated archival dataset of published and unpublished sources that had to be consulted, and the problematic issues faced by such a study. Among the challenges in reading earlier excavation accounts, she outlines the difficulties in understanding not only the objects described by early excavators (as nomenclature changed through time in the records) but also the original findspots, as well as the actual locations of the finds today. Since objects received multiple inventory numbers, creating a sort of “inventory chain,” today it is difficult and in most cases impossible to locate the finds in the Naples and Pompeii collections. Taken in sum, the entire recorded assemblage of finds from the Casa di Marco Lucrezio includes about 503 objects and groups of objects, of which only 67 could be located in the storerooms in Naples and Pompeii. As B. points out, despite the omission of many fragmentary objects (especially pottery and glass) from early excavations, the high quantity and good quality of finds demonstrate that the house must have belonged to a wealthy individual during its final years.Footnote 8
B. continues with an overview of the results obtained by the analysis of the spatial distribution of finds, which supports the practice of storing objects in mixed arrays or assortments in smaller rooms or cupboards set around the atrium and garden area.Footnote 9 The results demonstrate two large activity zones within the house: the fauces zone and front part of the atrium area used for storage (e.g., rooms R3 and R4, serving as principal storage area and main deposits of the house); and the tablinum and triclinium zone at the rear of the atrium, which served more representative needs with little or no storage use. Hence, while more spacious, decorated, and prestigious rooms like tablinum R15 and triclinium R16 were kept clear of objects,Footnote 10 artifact densities have been greatest in rooms around the house's main entrance, where a slave (an atriensis or promus) might have been responsible for safeguarding them. As B. rightly concludes, therefore, it might be more useful to study the distribution of objects according to activity zones rather than room types.
What follows in the rest of the section is the analysis of the material finds according to five broad functional categories: I. works of art; II. vessels; III. instruments and utensils; IV. fixtures; and V. architectural elements. K. (I.1) presents a study of the large marble sculptural program that decorated the house at the time of the eruption and later contributed to the popularity of this house, at least until the beginning of the 20th c. In the peristyle garden (R18) were found 18 free-standing statues (i.e., herms, single statues, and sculptural groups), 6 reliefs (oscilla), and 1 mask.Footnote 11 This is an extensive sculptural decoration for a small garden, especially as compared to other larger or similarly sized ones at Pompeii, contributing to the idea that the house belonged to a well-to-do person. K. concludes with a brief evaluation of the ancient collection, noting how the garden's sculptural program appears predominantly Dionysiac, thus matching the pictorial decoration of the house. In I.2, Pietilä-Castrén analyzes the terracotta figurines – a class of finds selected according to their size (not exceeding 20 cm) – with respect to material (all fired clay) and the “item's nature as a work of visual art” (117). During the 1847 excavations, 14 figurines were discovered, but 4 of them could not be located and cataloged by the EPUH Project. They portray various subjects, including women, men, groups of people, and a grotesque depiction of Bes, the only statuette in the collection imported from Egypt. A heterogeneous group of seven figurines was found in the slaves’ quarter,Footnote 12 suggesting the possibility that they were either stored temporarily here or displayed in a domestic shrine no longer preserved.Footnote 13
In the remainder of the second section of the volume, B. analyzes the other portable finds recorded during the 1847 excavations. In II, she discusses the category of “vessels,” which are first analyzed in three different groups according to their material (bronze, glass, terracotta) rather than function. This is the right choice, in my opinion, not only because this type of find may have served different functions, but also because vessels were characterized by an extremely versatile nomenclature in both Pompeian inventories and the ca. 170 years of scholarship. Vessels represent the largest category of finds excavated at the house, a number that would have been even higher originally, considering that many terracotta and glass fragments were dismissed and left unrecorded by early excavators. In discussing the house's heterogeneous collection of vessels, B. reconstructs a prestigious banquet service, various utilitarian containers, and a group of hygienic equipment items. Because the kitchen and slaves’ areas were found well equipped with vessels and other cooking utensils, B.'s study also contributes evidence that the house was inhabited at the time of the eruption.
In III, “Instruments and utensils,” objects are discussed according to four functional groups: lighting, medical and cosmetic instruments, iron tools, and adornment and valuables. Overall, B.'s study confirms that household objects (both domestic and personal) were not usually kept in their place of use but locked up in storage spaces, although the cluster of artifacts that were not found in storage areas might be an indication of ongoing activities. This seems to be the case, for example, with cubiculum R5, where the large set of medical instruments suggests that the room was used by a professional doctor, potentially a member of the household. B. concludes this section with examinations of the furniture fittings and structural finds, dedicating special attention to a group of elements found in the upper tablinum R33 that once belonged to a prestigious chariot or cart decorated in bronze.
The third section of the volume is dedicated to two categories of new finds excavated by the EPUH team: wall and ceiling plaster fragments, studied by Hakanen; and two fragmentary terracotta masks, studied by Pietilä-Castrén. Three appendixes conclude the volume. In Appendix 1, B. catalogs by room the ensemble of finds from the 1847 excavations. Each object is accompanied by a short description, its inventory number, information about its actual location (when found by the authors), and its functional category. This appendix proves extremely helpful as it provides readers with a quick overview of the spatial distribution of artifacts within the house, as well as the type of material in each domestic space. B. has extensive experience in the analysis of the artifactual evidence at Pompeii, and her excellent reading of the various archival and published records to reconstruct such a heterogeneous collection of finds must be praised. K., Murros, and Tammisto provide in Appendix 2 a useful synthesis of the wall and floor decoration of each domestic space, thereby helping readers to better contextualize the distribution of inscriptions, works of art, and finds within the house. A plan of the Casa di Marco Lucrezio with room numbers is presented in Appendix 3 at the end of the book.
As a whole, the volume is an exemplary publication of this type of archaeological research, particularly because it presents a wealth of useful primary data to both specialists and other scholars. While there are many difficulties and challenges in undertaking analysis of the artifacts from such early excavations, the authors should be praised for succeeding in making the full collection of finds and inscriptions so accessible and easy to study. This is a laudable publication which has set the stage for a full understanding of the structural and decorative development of the whole Insula IX 3, a project that is promised to follow.
