Ranieri's opus examines the religious thought of two of the twentieth century's most important political philosophers, Eric Voegelin and Leo Strauss. Ranieri's scriptural analysis provides a vista for treating more familiar themes in Strauss and Voegelin: namely, the relationship between faith and reason and the critique of modernity. Ranieri concludes by offering an apology for biblical thought and Christianity through the lens of Girardian theory, which puts in perspective what Ranieri determines to be an overly optimistic account of philosophy inscribed in the work of both of his subjects.
Political exigencies profoundly shaped the intellectual orientations and pursuits of both Voegelin (1901–85) and Strauss (1899–1973). Strauss the Jew and Voegelin the lapsed Protestant were forced to flee the Third Reich, and although they had realized the centrality of the political question for philosophy before they had fled, it became an urgent concern that never abated for either of them. In turn, the topic of civilizational order and collapse animated their wide-ranging analyses of modern phenomena and classical thought. They corresponded briefly, but realized that, however much they shared biographies and philosophical and political orientations, their differences about matters of faith and politics were significant enough for them to limit their brief correspondence to mutual respect. Strauss went on to exert an extraordinary influence and create a loyal group of disciples who have kept his influence alive. This network has provided much of the intellectual foundation for the neoconservative movement. Although he spent as much time in the American academy as Strauss, Voegelin's thought never gathered the same momentum, as American political science has largely ignored his 1951 address (which became The New Science of Politics) that called for political scientists to remain philosophical questioners.
Both thinkers understood the twentieth century's genocidal politics within the framework of modernity and both, especially Voegelin, regarded modernity's failings as primarily spiritual. They intuited that modernity was an iteration of a fundamentally Christian animus and sought refuge in ancient Greek philosophy untainted by Western religion and modernity's gas ovens. Here one should add that Voegelin identified the essence of modernity as Gnostic, a worldview that finds some common ground with but ultimately departs from Christian orthodoxy. Ranieri underemphasizes this point in order to make a wider, valid point that in Voegelin's later writings Christianity receives much of the blame as well. Both chose Plato over the Gospel because they saw the latter as implicit in modernity's mass movements and followed Nietzsche in assessing Christianity as Platonism for the people. Their position explains their abiding appeal to those convinced of modernity's fundamental shortcomings yet unwilling to adopt a postmodern worldview.
Ranieri's facility with both thinkers allows him to cite from a wide array of their extensive and at times esoteric corpora. He explains that Strauss had a far more skeptical attitude toward scripture, and in some ways mirrored Spinoza in his suspicion about the compatibility between the Bible and philosophy. Voegelin, on the other hand, displayed a greater appreciation for biblical thought in his more regular and positive treatments of biblical texts. Unlike Strauss, who saw prophetic and mystical religion as fundamentally antirational, Voegelin recognized that the best religious thought belonged on the same continuum as ancient philosophy, especially Plato's more mystical brand. Both, then, contributed substantially to the conversation concerning the relationship between Jerusalem and Athens, yet Voegelin thought them more conjunctive where Strauss argued for a disjunctive relationship. Still, they agreed in attributing to Christianity and its Jewish apocalyptic roots the violent outbursts of modernity.
Ranieri informs the reader that a certain realist-pessimism animates their countermodernity. Yet of the two, Strauss is less sanguine about the capacity for most humans to undergo the mystical-philosophical liberation from the social and cultural forces that keep us in the matrix and lead us to mob violence. Voegelin, as the more Christian thinker, is at least as dire as Strauss concerning these forces, but preserves a greater hope about Christianity's capacity to produce authentic conversion.
Decades of scholarship on Voegelin and Strauss have resulted in an array of largely trustworthy commentaries. Ranieri knows this literature and refers to it frequently. Although his analysis of their views about the Bible presents a fresh angle, he uses this vantage point to return to familiar ground—Athens and Jerusalem, philosophy as political, antimodernity—that has already been covered. Ranieri occasionally modifies a position in the scholarship, but his overall silence on the state of scholarship raises the question of his book's relevance. Further, since Voegelin and Strauss cared so deeply about the political, Ranieri might have placed his and more recent scholarship within the context of the past decade of American conservatism. The so-called neoconservative movement, blended with a kind of biblical apocalypticism under the second Bush regime, produced a peculiarly violent tonic. What does this say about both thinkers' contribution to modern American conservatism, and does it vindicate Strauss's tepidity towards Jerusalem as a foundation for political order? Or does it vindicate the point that Voegelin made about Gnosticism being the greater political danger than orthodox Christianity?
The concluding chapter is the book's most interesting. Ranieri uses the theories of the French anthropologist René Girard to underscore the weaknesses of both philosophers while answering their critiques of Christianity. In this sense, Ranieri's work continues a recent conversation between these figures that resulted in a helpful collection that brought their thought into dialogue: Politics and Apocalypse, ed. Robert Hamerton-Kelly (Michigan State University Press, 2008).
Girard shares with Strauss and Voegelin a countermodern perspective. Yet unlike the latter, Girard argues persuasively that it is not authentic biblical thinking but rather philosophy that is more inclined to adopt a false mythology that leads to violence. Voegelin and Strauss provide test cases for Ranieri, who follows Girard. For Girard, violent episodes within Christendom represent departures from authentic Christianity; indeed the Gospel, though it has taken root unevenly and sporadically, represents humanity's best chance to liberate itself from the violent forces that present such a profound crisis. Even, nay, especially classical philosophy falls for and underwrites the mythic lie that violence provides a real solution. Ranieri remarks: “The horrors of the twentieth century are better explained as a consequence of the lasting hold exercised by sacrificial thinking, rather than as the offspring of a biblical orientation whose effect on Western civilization has been to call our attention to the lies by which we justify our scapegoating” (244).
As wholeheartedly as the reviewer agrees with Ranieri's usage of Girard, his choice seems arbitrary; certainly there are other Christian apologists—John Milbank and David Bentley Hart, to name just two—who brilliantly position Christianity as humanity's best political hope, and who place Greek antiquity along the same agonistic continuity as modernity and Nietzschean postmodernity. This point underlies the more general criticism that the author might have placed his central subjects and the scholarship on them within a wider context, so that the selection of these figures, as well as the subject under discussion, might have seemed more urgent. Still, the book offers a reliable treatment of two political figures of towering genius while bringing them further into conversation with a someone who offers a profound Christian apology for our time.
