The appearance of ZdSK is a major advance in later third-century studies. The book immediately takes its place as the new standard work, and should be in every serious library. In the period a.d. 235–284 the Greco-Roman world underwent fundamental change, from ‘High’ to ‘Later’ Roman Empire, in the course of what is now conventionally referred to as the third-century ‘Crisis’. However, the study of this turning-point is hampered by scarce and difficult evidence. When I began working in this field in 1969, there had been few significant publications since Andreas Alföldi's masterly chapters in the first (1939) edition of CAH XII. Research was dominated by numismatists establishing coin-sequences, and by Soviet and East German historians seeking the origins of the demise of the ‘slave-owning class’. On the other hand, it was possible to master most of the important material that had appeared on the topic. Since then there has been a huge amount of research on every aspect of the period, welcome in itself but impossible for a single researcher to digest. ZdSK considerably eases this problem by summarizing, or at least noticing, most relevant publications. Though Johne and his associates cannot be said to have laid the foundations of later third-century studies, they are to be heartily congratulated for having constructed a much-needed levelling-course on which all future work will be built.
The two volumes, consecutively paginated, contain ten sections (I. Quellen und Forschung; II. Die Ereignisse der Reichsgeschichte; III. Völker und Staaten an den Grenzen der römischen Welt; IV. Der römische Staat; V. Die römische Gesellschaft; VI. Wirtschaft und Münzwesen; VII. Bildung und Wissenschaft; VIII. Die Religionen; IX. Krise und Transformation des Reiches im 3. Jahrhundert; X. Fasti), comprising chapters by the editors and twenty-two colleagues (E. Baltrusch, D. Durkin-Meisternst, K. Ehling, K. Feld, T. Glas, A. Goltz, A. Gutsfeld, M. Heil, F. Herklotz, U. Huttner, P. Huyse, E. Kettenhofen, G. Kreucher, A. Lohwasser, A. Luther, I. Männlein-Robert, K. Pietzner, K. Ruffing, K. Schade, M. Schuol, M. Speidel, J. Wiesehöfer). This structure (‘sources’, ‘political narrative’, ‘society and culture’) appears orthodox, but the material it contains is unusually wide and deep. For example, the secondary literature cited ranges in date from the late seventeenth century to 2007; under ‘sources’ are texts in many languages other than Greek and Latin; and under ‘border-peoples’ close attention, with relevance to contemporary world-issues, is given to the Caucasus, Mesopotamia, Arabia, Egypt and the Sudan, and North Africa. The concluding detailed fasti and massive bibliography are of themselves a major contribution to scholarship. Though I would not dare to pass comment on the reliability of everything ZdSK contains, I can say that where contributors refer to my own publications they do so generously, accurately and fairly, and where they do not it is gratifying to find them coming to broadly similar conclusions as myself from the same evidence.
We are informed (11) that ZdSK was conceived in 2001, giving a ‘flash to bang’ time of around seven years, compared with the twenty years or so of the second (2005) edition of CAH XII. It is instructive to consider how so much was achieved so quickly. For one person to produce an overview of this kind would have been impossible, which explains why ZdSK was turned over to a large team. But to have asked a team to deal directly with the still contentious phenomenon of the third-century ‘Crisis’ in double-quick time would have been to risk producing a dog's breakfast. The editors’ solution was simple but elegant, and is reflected in the book's main title. ZdSK is precisely what it says on the tin: not a book about ‘the Crisis’, but one about ‘the age of the soldier-emperors’. When I first saw this it struck me as suspiciously old-fashioned, since it smacks of Rostovtzeff; and it is very much open to question, since there were, arguably, ‘soldier-emperors’ before a.d. 235 and after a.d. 284. As noted, most people (including, clearly, to judge from their various throwaway remarks, many of the contributors of ZdSK) now think automatically of a.d. 235–284 in terms of ‘the Crisis’. But the notion of the period as ‘the age of the soldier-emperors’ is defensible (601–2), and it is valuable because it relieves contributors from getting entangled in the ‘if’, ‘what’, ‘where’, and ‘why’ of ‘Crisis’, and frees them to reconstruct simply ‘what happened’. This produces the overwhelmingly encyclopaedic, even discursive, character of the book in which, for example, discussion of the development of the imperial office, the Senate and the equestrians ranges from the late Republic to the fourth century a.d. Everywhere there is much on the Severans. There is little revisionism: apart from certain points of detail (and, perhaps, from Ruffing's singular emphasizing of the awful economic consequences of Aurelian's currency-reform: VI.2), historical interpretation tends to the orthodox. Imperial politics and provincial administration are presented in terms of the ‘decline’ of the Senate and the ‘rise’ of the equestrians, and city-life judged according to the activities of local municipal élites in the better-known provinces. Foreign enemies are invariably ‘threatening’ (debate over Sassanid war-aims, for example, is confined to a footnote: p. 537 n. 21). The working of the Empire, functional and ideological, and its huge systemic weaknesses and strengths, are touched on by some in passing (e.g. by Hartmann on Palmyra: II.5), but not dealt with head-on until section IX, where Johne and Hartmann at last pick up the book's sub-title, Krise und Transformation des Römischen Reiches im 3. Jahrhundert n. Chr. (235–284) (in small print on the inside title-page). Here, they are ‘right’ in the sense that their interpretation of the ‘Crisis’ as a process of accelerated but intermittent and often localized change, not global collapse, is in line with current thinking. However, their section's brevity and careful cross-referencing of preceding material hinders a full and unbuttoned analysis. (How successful a ruler was Aurelian? What would have happened if he had been defeated by Zenobia?) Overall, therefore, ZdSK has an unusual and sometimes frustrating structure, but it gets the job done, coming the closest so far to fulfilling that great desideratum of third-century studies, ‘an agreed set of events’ (cf. p. 7). It is, indeed, unlike many other recent publications making the claim, an authentic ‘handbook’, which will encourage and enable more detailed and nuanced analysis.
This is not to say that, even on its own terms, it is flawless. Its bibliography should not be assumed to be comprehensive since, for example, it omits a number of important anglophone publications on the northern barbarians, including telling criticism of the finer points of germanophone reconstruction of their ‘ethnogenesis’. Despite conscientious cross-referencing, there is a great deal of repetition. ‘Construction by committee’ is evident in a number of places, apparently reflecting more the editors’ search for who could be got to do what in the shortest time, than any logical structure. Thus, for example, the main literary sources are presented in long, unlovely and intimidating lists, in which authors are catalogued alphabetically by name. (Hartmann's useful historiographical chapter, VII.2, should have been brought forward to here.) The narrative chapters are irregular in length and scope, with rulers from Maximinus Thrax to Aemilian being bundled together in one (there is explanation of this at p. 1027, but it is late and weak), but with Tacitus given his own. There is, indeed, generally far too much on Tacitus, an ephemeral emperor whose portrayal as the last ‘Senatskaiser’ was conclusively dismissed forty years ago by Syme. But Tacitus figures prominently in the later section of the Historia Augusta and, almost a fil rouge, ZdSK contributors show an unhealthy reluctance to put this sorry excuse for a source out of its misery. The HA is, indeed, uniquely, also accorded its own chapter (I.1.2), and ZdSK is shot through with references to it, the overwhelming majority of which ultimately dismiss it as ‘fiktiv’, full of ‘Erfindungen’. I suggest that, as their next major contribution to later third-century studies, the editors produce a definitive assessment of the HA's later ‘Lives’ to establish for good what these contain that is trustworthy, what may be trustworthy, and what — without doubt the greatest part — may be safely ignored.
