Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T04:53:32.994Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Large-scale multifractality and lack of self-similar decay for Burgers and three-dimensional Navier–Stokes turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 August 2025

Takeshi Matsumoto
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
Dipankar Roy
Affiliation:
Université Côte d’Azur, CNRS UMR 7351, Nice, France
Konstantin Khanin
Affiliation:
BIMSA Beijing China, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
Rahul Pandit
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India
Uriel Frisch*
Affiliation:
Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur, CNRS Laboratoire J.-L. Lagrange, Nice 06300, France
*
Corresponding author: Uriel Frisch, uriel@oca.eu

Abstract

We study decaying turbulence in the one-dimensional (1-D) Burgers equation (Burgulence) and 3-D Navier–Stokes (NS) turbulence. We first investigate the decay in time $t$ of the energy $E(t)$ in Burgulence, for a fractional Brownian initial potential, with Hurst exponent $H$, and demonstrate rigorously a self-similar time decay of $E(t)$, previously determined heuristically. This is a consequence of the non-trivial boundedness of the energy for any positive time. We define a spatially forgetful oblivious fractional Brownian motion (OFBM), with Hurst exponent $H$, and prove that Burgulence, with an OFBM as initial potential $\varphi _0(x)$, is not only intermittent, but it also displays a, hitherto unanticipated, large-scale bifractality or multifractality; the latter occurs if we combine OFBMs, with a distribution of $H\hbox{-}$values. This is the first rigorous proof of genuine multifractality for turbulence in a nonlinear hydrodynamical partial differential equation. We then present direct numerical simulations (DNSs) of freely decaying turbulence, capturing some aspects of this multifractality. For Burgulence, we investigate such decay for two cases: (a) $\varphi _0(x)$ a multifractal random walk that crosses over to a fractional Brownian motion beyond a cross-over scale $\mathcal{L}$, tuned to go from small- to large-scale multifractality; (b) initial energy spectra $E_0(k)$, with wavenumber $k$, having one or more power-law regions, which lead, respectively, to self-similar and non-self-similar energy decay. Our analogous DNSs of the 3-D NS equations also uncover self-similar and non-self-similar energy decay. Challenges confronting the detection of genuine large-scale multifractality, in numerical and experimental studies of NS and Magnetohydrodynamics turbulence, are highlighted.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.A schematic plot showing the construction of an OFBM$_H$ with Hurst exponent $H \in (0,1)$: We consider intervals of length $l_i$, with $i\in [1,2, \ldots]$; for this illustration we consider three contiguous segments, of lengths $l_1$, $l_2$ and $l_3$. To obtain an OFBM$_H$, we start with three independent realisations – light red, light green and light blue – of a fractional Brownian motion (FBM$_H$) with a given Hurst exponent $H$; in the first, second and third segments, we use the dark red, dark green and dark blue FBM$_H$, respectively, after a vertical translation of the starting point of the FBM$_H$, in segment labelled by $i$, so that it meets the endpoint of the FBM$_H$, in segment $(i-1)$. The OFBM$_H$ is shown in dark red, dark green and dark blue (for our three-segment illustration). The lengths of the segments are random variables that are distributed according to the PDF $p(l)$; here, we choose a power-law tail for this PDF: $p(l) \sim l^{-\gamma }, \;\; l \to \infty$, with $\gamma$ the tail exponent (see text).

Figure 1

Figure 2.The regions A, B and C, in the $H-\gamma$ parameter space, in which cases A, B and C (see text) are applicable, respectively.

Figure 2

Figure 3.In (2.20) we define the exponent $s(m)$; here, we plot this exponent versus the order $m$ using (2.26) for case B and the Hurst exponent $H$ uniformly distributed in the interval $[1/2,1]$; the three parts of $s(m)$ in (2.26) are shown by full-red, dashed-blue and full-green curves.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Log–log plots of (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$, at some representative values of $t$ (the inset shows the initial spectrum $E(k,0)$ in detail in the wavenumber range $5\times 10^2\leqslant k\leqslant 6 \times 10^2$) and (b) the scaled total energy $E(t)/E(t=0)$ versus the time $t$ for the multifractal initial condition (3.2)–(3.6), for the potential $\varphi _0$, with Hurst exponent $H=1/2$; the inset shows a plot of the local slope. We compute structure functions in figure 5 at the point in time that lies at the centre of the interval indicated by the blue vertical lines.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Plots for the multifractal initial condition, for the potential $\varphi _0$, with Hurst exponent $H=1/2$ at $t=10^{-5}$: (a) log–log plots versus $\ell$ of the structure functions of order $p=1, \ldots, 5$. (b) Plots of $\zeta _p^{loc}$, obtained from local slopes of the structure functions in (a), versus $\ell$. (c) Plots of $\zeta _p$ versus $p$ (in blue) at $t=10^{-5}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Log–log plots for (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative times $t$, (b) the decay of the total energy $E(t)$ with time $t$ and (c) the growth of the integral length scale $L(t)$ with time $t$ for case I(a), with a two-power-law initial energy spectrum (see § 3.3.2). The insets show local slopes that can be used to estimate the decay and growth exponents in (b) and (c), respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Log–log plots for (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative times $t$, (b) the decay of the total energy $E(t)$ with time $t$ and (c) the growth of integral length scale $L(t)$ with time $t$ for case II(a), with a four-power-law initial energy spectrum (see § 3.3.2). The insets show local slopes that can be used to estimate the decay and growth exponents in (b) and (c), respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Log–log plots of the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative values of the time in the range $0 \leqslant t \leqslant 820$; (b) and (c) display log–log plots versus $t$ of the total energy $E(t)$ and the integral length scale $L(t)$, respectively; (d), (e) and (f) are, respectively, the hyperviscous-DNS counterparts of (a), (b) and (c).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Results for the decay of energy from our DNS for the hyperviscous 3DNSE with a two-power-law initial energy $E(k, t=0) \propto k^{1.5}$ and $E(k, t=0) \propto k^3$, i.e. $(n_1, n_2) = (1.5,\,3)$ in (4.4). (a) Log–log plots of the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative values of the time in the range $0 \leqslant t \leqslant 820$; (b) and (c) display log–log plots versus $t$ of the total energy $E(t)$ and the integral length scale $L(t)$, respectively; in (b) and (c) logarithmic local slopes are given in the insets, where $F(n) = -2 (n + 1)/(n + 3)$ is the naïve prediction for the power-law exponent for the decay of $E(t)$, if $E(k, t=0) \sim k^n$ and $G(n) = 2/(n + 3)$ is the corresponding prediction for the growth exponent of the integral scale $L(t)$.

Figure 9

Table 1.Summary of our results. Top panel: rigorous results for 1-D Burgulence. Middle panel: numerical results for 1-D Burgulence. Bottom panel: numerical results for 3-D NS turbulence.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Log–log plots of (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$, at some representative values of $t$ (the inset shows the initial spectrum $E(k,0)$ in detail in the wavenumber range $5\times 10^2\leqslant k\leqslant 6 \times 10^2$) and (b) the scaled total energy $E(t)/E(t=0)$ versus the time $t$ for the multifractal initial condition (3.2)–(3.6), for the velocity, with Hurst exponent $H=1/2$; the inset shows a plot of the local slope. We compute structure functions in figure 11 at the point in time that lies at the centre of the interval indicated by the blue vertical lines.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Plots for the multifractal initial condition, for the velocity, with Hurst exponent $H=1/2$ at $t=10^{-3}$: (a) log–log plots versus $\ell$ of the structure functions of order $p=1, \ldots, 5$. (b) Plots of $\zeta _p^{loc}$, obtained from local slopes of the structure functions in (a), versus $\ell$. (c) Plots of $\zeta _p$ versus $p$ (in blue) at $t=10^{-3}$; the red curves show $\zeta _p$ (in red) for the multifractal random walk of 3).

Figure 12

Figure 12.Log–log plots of (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$, at some representative values of $t$ (the inset shows the initial spectrum $E(k,0)$ in detail in the wavenumber range $5\times 10^2\leqslant k\leqslant 6 \times 10^2$) and (b) the scaled total energy $E(t)/E(t=0)$ versus the time $t$ for the multifractal initial condition ((3.2)–(3.6)), for the potential $\varphi _0$, with Hurst exponent $H=0.75$; the inset shows a plot of the local slope. We compute structure functions in figure 13 at the point in time that lies at the centre of the interval indicated by the blue vertical lines.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Plots for the multifractal initial condition, for the potential $\varphi _0$, with Hurst exponent $H=0.75$ at $t=10^{-5}$: (a) log–log plots versus $\ell$ of the structure functions of order $p=1, \ldots, 5$. (b) Plots of $\zeta _p^{loc}$, obtained from local slopes of the structure functions in (a), versus $\ell$. (c) Plots of $\zeta _p$ versus $p$ (in blue) at $t=10^{-5}$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Log–log plots of (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$, at some representative values of $t$, and (b) the scaled total energy $E(t)/E(t=0)$ versus the time $t$ for the multifractal initial condition ((3.2)–(3.6)), for the velocity, with Hurst exponent $H=0.75$; the inset shows a plot of the local slope. We compute structure functions in figure 15 at the point in time that lies at the centre of the interval indicated by the blue vertical lines.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Plots for the multifractal initial condition, for the velocity, with Hurst exponent $H=0.75$ at $t=10^{-4}$: (a) log–log plots versus $\ell$ of the structure functions of order $p=1, \ldots, 5$. (b) Plots of $\zeta _p^{loc}$, obtained from local slopes of the structure functions in (a), versus $\ell$. (c) Plots of $\zeta _p$ versus $p$ (in blue) at $t=10^{-4}$; the red curves show $\zeta _p$ (in red) for the multifractal random walk of 3.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Log–log plots for (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative times $t$, (b) the decay of the total energy $E(t)$ with time $t$ and (c) the growth of integral length scale $L(t)$ with time $t$ for case Ib, with a two-power-law initial energy spectrum (see § 3.3.2 where figure 6 gives the analogous plots for case Ia); the insets show local slopes that can be used to estimate the decay and growth exponents in (b) and (c), respectively. (d)–(f) are the counterparts of (a)–(c) for case Ic; (g)–(i) are the counterparts of (a)–(c) for case Id.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Log–log plots for (a) the energy spectrum $E(k,t)$ versus the wavenumber $k$ at representative times $t$, (b) the decay of the total energy $E(t)$ with time $t$ and (c) the growth of integral length scale $L(t)$ with time $t$ for case IIb, with a four-power-law initial energy spectrum (see § 3.3.2 and figure 7 for case IIa). The insets show local slopes that can be used to estimate the decay and growth exponents in (b) and (c), respectively.

Figure 18

Figure 18.The same as the caption of figure 9 in § 4.1.2, but with $(n_1, n_2) = (3, 1.5)$ in (4.4).

Figure 19

Figure 19.The same as the caption of figure 9 in § 4.1.2, but with $(n_1, n_2) = (1.5, 2)$.