On the back cover of this book it is described as ‘a collection of fifteen original essays analysing gender in the imagery of science’. As it happens, parts of two essays have been published previously, but my interest in quoting this description is to note the phrase ‘the imagery of science’. This covers a huge range of artefacts from portraits to laboratory notebooks and from textbooks to graphs. In this volume the scope is restricted to images that concern the body, predominantly the female figure, hence the title, which suggests the theme of problem-solving, although this is not especially prominent in the constituent essays. These are divided into three parts entitled ‘Frontispieces’, ‘The nineteenth century: technologies and gender politics’ and ‘The twentieth century and beyond: changes or continuities’. The main categories of images covered are prints, book illustrations and photographs.
Figuring It Out covers several centuries, from the eighteenth to our own times. Each essay covers a specific topic, and there is little that acts as a bridge between most of them, although the introduction attempts to do so. This is a collection of fifteen distinct chapters plus the introduction. Inevitably, they are of varying quality, and there are some truly delightful pieces of research and writing here. Jonathan Smith's account of Darwin's use of images of birds in the Descent of Man (1871) is particularly compelling. He neatly reveals the complexities of gender through a well-chosen case study, where the relationships between words and images, writers and illustrators can be probed. Eight images enable the reader to think afresh about describing and visualizing. And who can fail to be both enchanted and enlightened by James Secord's exploration of a little-known genre, ‘composite caricatures’, which shows ‘naturalists, scholars, tradespeople, and natural philosophers composed of the objects with which they deal’ (p. 164)? The images themselves are amusing, quirky, unfamilar and good to think with. But what really makes his chapter successful is the ways in which Secord reflects on how to explain them, and shares his thinking with the reader. It is an essay that uses images well – there are ten illustrations – and it manifests a confident familiarity with the history of prints and the relevant scholarship. It integrates the arguments and images. For the most part the images are big enough for the relevant details to be visible. Unfortunately this is not true of all the chapters. For example, on pages 41 and 42 eighteenth-century prints are reproduced in the margins of the page. These margins are generous, but the images are so small that their details are all but invisible. Similarly, on pages 70, 141 and 150 the reproductions are too small to be really useful, and on many other pages illustrations would benefit from being a bit larger. There are no colour reproductions, and in no case is the size of a work given. Secord's captions are exemplary in giving as much information as possible, including the type of print. These practicalities really matter in the interpretation of visual culture.
The absence of colour is a real loss. For instance, in Chapter 14 some illustrations in colour would not only have been helpful but might have enabled the argument to go further. There Annette Burfoot writes about ‘The fetal voyager’, a phrase that refers to backlit images of an embryo, detached from its mother and seemingly floating in space. She uses these and other advertisements to probe the ways in which the maternal body has been marginalized, even aborted from the visual discourses of the new reproductive technologies. By way of contrast, she ends, most inventively, with one of Ron Mueck's extraordinary hyper-realist sculptures of a newborn baby, umbilical cord attached, on the belly of its naked mother. The palettes that artists and advertisers choose are eloquent. To what extent, I wonder, are the images Burfoot analyses working with references to contemporary science fiction? When she shows an amazing image referring to a ‘cord blood bank’, which shows an umbilical cord dangling next to a computer cord and an electrical cord, the drama of the juxtaposition, which I assume was originally in colour, is lost in black and white. I am well aware of issues of cost surrounding the number, placement and types of illustrations in academic publications, but an integral part of taking imagery seriously is providing adequate reproductions with full and accurate captions.
It is disappointing that Naomi Adelson uses only three images in her intriguing essay about the Visible Human Project, and that Lorraine Code, in her gripping account of a female medical whistle-blower, does not provide any comparable photographs of men. This would have sharpened the gender analysis. She includes six photographs of Nancy Olivieri, the (attractive) Canadian haematologist who broke ranks in the 1990s to express her concerns about a drug she was involved in testing. More close readings of the images would be useful. For example, Plate 12.2 shows Olivieri with a young girl: ‘she bends forward in a strikingly subordinate position, leaning towards her patient and the camera’ (p. 299). The two females are looking at each other. Code describes this as ‘the typically feminine representation of Olivieri's professional demeanor’ (p. 298). It is a very striking picture, part of a larger montage showing men, which could usefully have been included in its entirety. Such images invite sustained analysis. The look on her face, for example, suggests, to me at least, the need for her patient's approval, while the angle of her body has a whiff of penitence to it. The long legacy of female religious healers might be worth considering from the point of view of visual culture.
I have just alluded to one of the trickiest problems raised by any work and writing on visual culture. Historical arguments need to provide and then deploy accounts of images (and texts) that readers can (mostly) buy into. For me, many of Alan Bewell's readings of images in his essay on early natural-history collectors failed to tally with the works themselves. Some of the literary examples were just as puzzling. Is Ovid's story about Apollo and Daphne really about natural-history collecting? Are the lines from Wordsworth's Prelude applicable to botany (p. 45)? What has Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, published in 1818, to do with a ‘vision of the naturalist as a threatening figure detached from social values and mores’ (p. 46)? Frankenstein was certainly detached, but he was not a natural-history collector in the sense that Linnaeus and Banks were. In Joan Steigerwald's interesting chapter on Alexander von Humbolt – the only essay to venture outside the English-speaking world – she discusses the frontispiece to his Ideas towards a Geography of Plants (1807). ‘It depicts Apollo, god of art and reason, unveiling a statue of Diana, the multi-breasted goddess of nature. Figurative inscriptions in the form of Egyptian hieroglyphs cover the statue's lower body’ (p. 54). What I see are five tiers of animals, carved in relief into stone in circular bands; three are visible on the three top tiers and two on the two lowermost. Steigerwald treats these as ‘inscriptions’ and ‘script’, whereas I would see them as a three-dimensional frieze.
I mention these examples to show how very challenging the tasks are that the editors and contributors have set themselves. Shteir's wide-ranging opening essay on the figure of Flora effectively shows how historians of botany might work in much broader ways, while the figure of Flora keeps the focus tight. It is a generative approach which characterizes the most successful of the essays. By contrast, the introduction sets out four vast themes: gendered cultures of science and medicine, gender and technologies of display, gender politics of visual images, and sexualities and sexual differences in the figural vocabularies of science and medicine. Such themes are undoubtedly important, but they are also abstract. The thrill of working with images and objects is discovering just how specific they are, how precisely they mediate social relationships and work with abstract ideas. This remains true even when they draw on familiar motifs. Such specificity is vital if we are to handle elusive notions like masculinity and femininity effectively.
I suspect Shteir and Lightman are well aware of these big issues. They tend to deal with them in the introduction by posing suites of questions to the reader. For example, in discussing the formats of scientific images, verbal and visual, they inquire, ‘Which image more transparently conveys an author's intentions? Does the visual image hold the key to interpret the verbal image? Is it the other way round? Or can the meaning of both only be determined by using each image as a guide to interpreting the other?’ (p. xxi, cf. questions on p. xix). These are false polarities, with only the last question making any sense. So why raise them? Furthermore, we know that authors' intentions are never ‘transparently’ conveyed, not least because it is extraordinarily hard to know what their intentions are. Visual culture, like verbal culture, is all about mediation, as some of the essays show. Let us hope that this book prompts further sustained and thoughtful engagement with the ways in which items of visual culture can be integrated into historical practice.
