The international cooperation initiative established by the Eisenhower administration (1956–1961), the People to People program, aimed to support American community leaders from different fields—such as the arts, education, sports, religion, health, and the military—in international exchanges to enhance understanding and good will on the part of citizens around the world.
My doctoral dissertation assesses the effect of President Eisenhower's leadership style on his administration's foreign policy decision making. More specifically, it addresses how the People to People program served as an ideological tool in the cold war.
The creation of the People to People program was an ambitious attempt to enhance the direct contact between Americans and people overseas. The new international context—characterized by the Soviet policy of “pacific coexistence” after Stalin's death—increased the importance of international public opinion. One of the biggest challenges facing Eisenhower was, therefore, the Soviet ideological threat. He personally endorsed a shift toward solidifying support in the “free world.”
Why did the administration create such a program of international private cooperation? Why did this program develop into something halfway between a peaceful cooperation initiative and a weapon in the ideological conflict of the cold war? And what role did Eisenhower personally play in its creation and development? The administration created the program to rally the West and present an ideological counteroffensive to the Soviets. However, I argue that the way Eisenhower managed the program increased the ambiguity of the initial project, insofar as it became neither a simple “peace” initiative, nor a full-blown propaganda operation. To make this case, I treat Eisenhower's leadership style as an important explanatory factor.
Using the social psychology approach developed in international relations by Alexander George (1969) and the recent work or Margaret Hermann and Thomas Preston on the importance of presidential leadership in foreign policymaking (Preston Reference Preston1996; Hermann Reference Hermann2001), my analysis of the Eisenhower presidency highlights how his leadership style is an important variable in the explanation of the creation and the management of the People to People program.
As seen through his involvement in the program, Eisenhower's leadership style is characterized by two dimensions. One is his need to control his administration's foreign policy; the other is his demand for an open flow of information within the administration. The first dimension of made him operate as a director (Preston Reference Preston1996). Eisenhower's personal interest in foreign policy matters was linked to his background (George Reference George1980). That deep interest in international issues had a strong effect on the way the he organized his presidency. It shaped the choice of advisors (George Reference George1980) and stressed the need for staff loyalty.
The other dimension of Ike's leadership is his attention to the external policy context. This aspect highlights his ability to be a “navigator” steering the ship of state away from the shores as they appeared. In this mode, Eisenhower's leadership was more flexible and adaptable to circumstances. Characterizing Eisenhower as director-navigator combines his need for control and routine with his ability to change course in response to changes in the broader global situation.
One of Eisenhower's strengths was his willingness to overrule powerful members of his administration, such as secretary of state John Foster Dulles, who was more skeptical about the idea that the ordinary participant in the program could be seen as foreign ambassadors. Eisenhower's actions also limited the rivalry between the United States Information Agency (USIA) and the State Department over its management.
However, Eisenhower did overemphasize the psychological dimensions of the cold war, which undermined elements of the People to People program. In addition, Eisenhower's demand of loyalty and desire to control his administration led some of his advisors to constantly seek his approval, which weakened their implementation of the program and increased the groupthink process (Janis Reference Janis1972). Consequently, the program suffered from an ambiguous conceptualization: it was neither a mundane international cooperation initiative among allies, nor was it simply a psychological operations program. The reluctance of the big private foundations to fund People to People is clearly linked to the way the program was conceived.
In sum, the study of Eisenhower's leadership is an important way to understand how his administration's foreign policy tried to adapt to the new international environment of the late 1950s. However, if the study of the president's leadership can be an important factor to explain outcomes in foreign policy, it must be a limited claim. The impact of presidential leadership on bureaucratic process can vary, but the way policy is shaped is clearly linked to the leadership style of the president. ■
