Introduction
I am writing this introduction on the day after the 2012 US Presidential election. We now know that Mitt Romney will not get a chance to carry out his pledge to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA), an Act that, on a national scale, bears much resemblance to the set of health care reforms that he himself desired for the people of Massachusetts. This does not mean that the implementation of ACA – or, in other words, the extension of health care insurance to tens of millions of American citizens – will be an easy ride; there are likely to be many implementation barriers in the years ahead. But it does mean that one potentially very high hurdle has been avoided. Another, possibly even more dangerous, hurdle was very narrowly cleared in June 2012 – so narrowly cleared in fact, that it took some of the skin off the ACA's knees, but ultimately left its bulk intact. That hurdle was the Supreme Court deliberation on whether the ACA violated the US Constitution.
In the following pages, a multidisciplinary group of scholars – namely, Tim Jost, Michael Gusmano, Uwe Reinhardt, Howard Berliner and Alex Waddan – will offer their perspectives on the Supreme Court Decision. Ultimately, the Court decided that the Federal Government could not withhold existing Medicaid funds from States that refused to expand Medicaid, but that the Federal Government was not exceeding its constitutional remit by imposing a mandate on individuals to purchase health care insurance. This was because, according to the Supreme Court, the imposition of a fine for those who failed to purchase insurance could be categorised as a tax, which Congress has the right to levy. Neither the Medicaid nor the individual mandate decisions were broadly expected. Nor was it expected that Chief Justice Roberts – a Republican appointee – would essentially be the person who saved ACA. There is much speculation (in the articles that follow and elsewhere), but no firm agreement or understanding, on why he did this. Was it to uphold the non-partisan integrity of the court, to curtail the reach of the Commerce Clause, to stave off a constitutional crisis, a combination of the above, or something else? Perhaps he should tell us.
To a non-American, like myself, and probably to most Americans, the story of ACA's journey until now is worthy of the pen of Voltaire. ACA nearly did not happen due to (of all people) Edward Kennedy's untimely death and the election of a Republican to replace him. ACA has been vociferously and viciously opposed by Republicans, and yet the Act offers an incremental approach that builds on their beloved existing private health insurance system; indeed, the individual mandate was a Republican innovation, and, if anything, it is the Democrats who ought to oppose it. And yet it took a Republican Supreme Court judge to rescue ACA in the early summer of 2012. If health care reform in the US was not such an important issue – if it did not impact at the deepest level on the lives, and deaths, of tens of millions of people – the story of ACA would be a comedy.
Hopefully, it will not now be a tragedy. The next four years, for which we might hope for calmer and more reasonable waters, might not offer us ‘the best in the best of all possible worlds’, but it might, at least, be better.
