No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2004
Media commentators and political scientists alike referred to the 1992 elections as ‘The Year of the Woman’ because of the unprecedented numbers of women running in and winning congressional elections. Women's remarkable successes in that year have been attributed to a variety of factors: the large number of open seats due to redistricting and congressional retirements, strong anti-incumbency sentiments among voters combined with public perceptions of female candidates as honest outsiders, and women's perceived strengths in dealing with issues on the national agenda such as sexual harassment and health care (Palley 1993).
In 2002, redistricting once again created a healthy number of open seats, but voters seemed less bothered by ‘politics as usual’ than in 1992 and stereotypically masculine issues such as terrorism and the impending war with Iraq topped the national agenda. Not surprisingly, female candidates did less well in 2002 than in 1992. Why is this the case?
This paper provides an overview of the 2002 congressional elections, examining three questions in particular. First, did women run disproportionately as sacrificial lambs, or in districts where they had no realistic chance of winning? Second, how successful were female candidates in raising campaign funds in 2002? Finally, did women's campaign slogans convey an image of tough, aggressive women ready to tackle the nation's problems or did they stick to touting more stereotypically feminine traits and areas of policy expertise in their campaign communications?
In almost all respects, female congressional candidates fared as well as similarly situated male candidates in 2002. They faced similar competition in their primary election bids, won their primary races at rates comparable to their male colleagues, raised more money than male candidates, on average, and had similar success rates in November. The only area where female candidates did less well than male candidates was in competing for open seats, and here their success rates were significantly lower than men's and noticeably lower than women's success rates in the 1992 congressional elections. While women won 56.4% of their open seat contests in 1992, they were successful in only 31.3% of these elections in 2002 (CAWP 2002).
Without public opinion data, it is premature to conclude that the political climate and influence of voter stereotypes sunk women's candidacies in 2002. The bulk of existing research on voter stereotypes hints that such a factor may have mattered, though (Alexander and Andersen 1993; Mueller 1986; Rosenwasser and Seale 1988; Sanbonmatsu 2002; Sapiro 1981–1982). And it does not appear that female candidates in 2002 congressional races went to any special lengths to assuage voter stereotypes by touting their own masculine traits and capabilities. A cursory look at the campaign slogans used by women and men in the 2002 congressional elections demonstrate that both sexes used sexrole appropriate slogans most of the time.1 Neither sex emphasized their leadership over military issues or defense policy, but women more often included the words families or values in their campaign slogan while men more often stressed their leadership and strength. Thus, female candidates did not fashion campaign slogans to counter voter stereotypes, but instead stuck to emphasizing stereotypically feminine policy issues and personality traits on the campaign trail.