No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
Linda Walbridge, an anthropologist whose main research interests have revolved around Shi

ism and minorities in Islamic societies, now offers a work focused on the indigenous Catholic Christian community in Pakistan. Inspired by the 1998 suicide of the first Punjabi bishop, John Joseph, in protest against the blasphemy laws, The Christians of Pakistan seeks to tell the contemporary story of the impoverished and minority-status Christians of Pakistan.
The book is divided into two parts. The first part deals with the general historical situation of British India, the founding of Pakistan, and the conversion of the lower Hindu castes to Catholic Christianity. More detailed attention is then given to the contemporary political and religious atmosphere of Pakistan in the 1970s and 1980s, ending with a discussion of the blasphemy laws. Amended in the early 1980s, the blasphemy laws, particularly Section 295c of the Pakistani penal code, have been the centerpiece of Muslim–Christian tension. Under this section, a person found guilty of “defiling” the name of the Prophet of Islam automatically receives a death sentence, regardless of intention or context. While the law applies to everyone, and Muslims have faced charges, the marginalized and lower-status Christians have become associated with this law and thus feel most vulnerable. Against this introductory background, Walbridge, in the second section of the book, launches into the heart of her research, which revolves around the life and death of Bishop John Joseph. Through him, she investigates the wider Catholic communities that he represented.
By marshaling a wide range of interview evidence collected from both supporters and opponents of the bishop, Walbridge attempts to exegete not only John Joseph, but also his community and the wider Muslim-dominated Pakistani population, particularly in its relationship with the Christian minorities. This entails a broad examination of the nature and enculturation of the priesthood along with their works of service and reputation among both Muslim and Christian communities. Since Bishop Joseph was committed to human rights and justice as chairman of the Bishop's Conference for Justice and Peace, Walbridge also includes chapters on the position of women in the church and society, the relationship between Catholic and Protestant communities, and the national status of John Joseph as the Awami (people's) bishop. Further chapters focus on the mutual influence of Islam and Christianity; the ethical and practical dilemmas faced by Christians beyond the Punjab (Karachi in the south and Balochistan in North-West Frontier Province), which were outside the diocese of John Joseph; and the rise of fundamentalist Islamist groups such as the Sipah-e-Sahaba. The book concludes with a discussion of the ethical and political issues involved in the bishop's protest suicide.
In evaluating Walbridge's contribution, one immediately notices the challenge of adequately handling the historical background of Pakistan and Christianity along with the complex contemporary role played by Bishop John Joseph. Not only must the emergence of the lower socioeconomic Catholic communities within Pakistani society be discussed along with the religious and political factors of defining Islamic identity in Pakistan, but the author also has chosen to study the contemporary situation through the life of John Joseph. This challenge did not go unnoticed by the author, who at the outset carefully comments that the book is a balance between ethnography and biography. The need to address so many issues is perhaps one reason that the various chapters at times do not flow together but, rather, read as isolated segments of information. However, as the book unfolds, the reader is rewarded with greater insight into the complexity and suffering of the Christian communities along with the passion of Bishop John Joseph for justice, and perhaps discrete chapters are the best way to communicate these complexities.
The wide use of interviews and the desire to broaden the study to include Christians outside the Punjab enhance the value of the book considerably. Of particular note is the attention given to various relationships, such as that between Christian and Muslim, and between Rome and the local Catholic churches, and the varied views within the local Christian communities regarding Bishop Joseph. These insights further the scholarly contribution of the work precisely because the Christian community continues the struggle to coexist with Muslims despite mutual distrust, as seen in the blasphemy laws, and despite the poverty and minority status that leave communities on both sides vulnerable. These issues did not die with John Joseph, and they are not confined to Pakistan.
Walbridge is generally successful in providing a voice to an often unheard minority without vilifying Islam—noting the interplay of poor education, political corruption, and the concentration of wealth among the few, which is often addressed through religious discourse, as primary causes of Pakistan's problems with its minorities. This book will be of interest to students and academics in anthropology, religious studies, and South Asian studies, as well as Christian–Muslim relations.