No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
The subtitle of this book succinctly describes its contents. Long before the 19th-century military and cultural pre-emption of the Middle East by Europe, Egypt exerted a powerful commercial and religious pull on Europeans. Another descriptive subtitle might have been “In the Name of God and of Profit,” since these early travelers were for the most part merchants and pilgrims. Italians from Venice, Genoa, and Milan came to buy the Indian and Far Eastern spices traded at depots in Cairo and Alexandria, while pilgrims from the continent visited Alexandria, Cairo, Matariya, and Sinai for their apostolic, biblical, and saintly associations to receive indulgences from the Catholic church (p. 8).
Wolff aims to present a panoramic view of Egypt by medieval and Renaissance travelers. The choice of 1300 as the book's beginning seems logical, since by then the Mamluk sultans who ruled Egypt had successfully protected it from the Mongol menace and removed the Crusader presence along the eastern Mediterranean shore. The long reign of al-Nasir Muhammad (1310–41) ushered in a period of stability that encouraged dramatic increases in trade and exploration. The 14th century also saw the beginning of a new literature of travel in sprightly and informing travelogues. Why Wolff selects 1640 as an ending is less obvious. To do so, she includes observations of a venture into the pyramid of Cheops by John Greaves, a professor of astronomy at Oxford, and a much more riveting account by an earlier German traveler (Sam Kiechel). Furthermore, to flesh out her description of travel to Nubia, she incorporates Amelia Edwards's account, which was not written until the 19th century.
Wolff organizes her book geographically, as one would if one were making the journey by sea across the Mediterranean. After disembarking in Alexandria, a city renowned throughout the civilized world, she moves her reader upstream to Cairo, the “meeting place of comer and goer,” where there are visits to the Citadel, neighboring pyramids, and mummy fields. From there, one travels by caravan east to Sinai and the monastery of St. Catherine or south into Nubia. This compression indicates the boundaries of her subject; this is the material on which the individual descriptions of her story, like patches of color, are stitched and woven to form a narrative quilt. Wolff's material is organized and presented in sensible form. Working from the various accounts, each with its own selective information and individual timeline, she splices together the various observations into a coherent whole. She has paraphrased the records so that her narrative has a single voice, informal and easy to read and often with a dry turn of phrase. When necessary, she elaborates and amplifies from her own research so that her portrait of former times is rich and engrossing.
Wolff deals with footnotes efficiently so that they do not intrude on her story. The bibliography lists her primary and secondary sources, and in the “notes” at the end of each chapter, she indicates the applicable topics and pages from these books. The vast majority of writing travelers were merchants and pilgrims, but her list also includes a nobleman, an ambassador, a doctor/naturalist, and an impressed European slave. In an appendix she lists her sources chronologically: date, name, profession, and reign of Mamluk or Ottoman sultan. The travelers divide evenly between the two periods: eleven during Mamluk times, and twelve for the Ottomans. The index provides suitable cross-references so that the reader can easily look up a particular person, reign, or item. The illustrations she has chosen—more than sixty of them—complement and enliven the chapters.
A few corrections should be made when the book is reprinted. The Great Mosque in Damascus is of Umayyad, not Ayyubid, origin (p. 15). In Cairo, the tombs of the “Circassian Mamluk lords” are located to the north of the Citadel, not to the south (p. 119). In Old Cairo, it is inserts of carved ivory that enrich the sanctuary screens rather than “sheets of ivory” (p. 140). The Emperor Justinian, the great patron of St. Catherine, died in 565, not 548 (p. 209). In the same section (p. 219), the Amir “Abu al-Mansur Anuchtakim” (sic) is far more commonly referred to as al-Afdal Shahanshah.
Wolff was born into the world she describes—her father was a cotton merchant who lived for five years in Egypt—and she has great empathy for her subject. In presenting this little-known travel literature, she has made it both informative and fun to read. At a time that travel is as easy as boarding a jet, and group travel eliminates initiative and rigor, this book gives the reader the flavor of travel as enterprise and adventure. Her accounts belong to an era when it took a convoy of seventy camels to carry what now can be moved by a seventy-ton mechanized truck and one of the challenges to writing was to describe something never seen before.