Kate Elswit's Theatre & Dance is an endlessly useful book. Recently released in Palgrave's Theatre And series, Elswit's text manages the difficult task of distilling with energy, clarity, and insight an interdisciplinary and often contentious conversation about performance histories, aesthetics, and practices. Her introduction alone—which parses persuasively yet concisely the ways in which, across theory and practice, “embodiment” has come to be the terrain of dance and “theatricality” the domain of theatre (7)—makes a strong case for this volume's inclusion on the syllabi, bibliographies, and bookshelves of anyone interested in the study of performance in its myriad forms. The recent energy in our fields around practices (dance dramaturgy, for one) and scholarship (Nadine George-Graves's 2015 The Oxford Handbook of Dance and Theater, among others) that foreground the “entanglements” (2), as Elswit puts it, between dance and theatre is well framed and clarified by this slim but potent volume.
Elswit marshals a vast array of international examples throughout her book and organizes them via a bipartite structure: the text alternates among three overview sections (“Interconnected Histories,” “Expanding Forms,” and “Overlapping Methods”) and five interludes. The interludes highlight particular practices of companies as evidenced in performance. Elswit's analyses of these performances—Canadian company bluemouth inc.’s 2009 Dance Marathon, British-based DV8 Physical Theatre's To Be Straight with You (2007), US American Trajal Harrell's Antigone cycle (ongoing) at Judson Memorial Church, US-based choreographer Doug Elkins's 2006 work Fräulein Maria, and the Argentinean Berlin-based choreographer Constanza Macras's Hell on Earth (2008)—are notable for their clear descriptions of movement and for the inclusion of the perspectives of performers, spectators, critics, choreographers, and directors. The interludes foreground contemporary examples, an emphasis that is enormously useful when it comes to locating media (online, video, and so forth) to illustrate Elswit's close readings.
The three overview sections encompass both a larger historical period and a wider geographical range than do the interludes. These sections support Elswit's overarching claim that “the ampersand between theatre and dance has such a long history that it might in fact be more useful to consider their currently accepted separation to be the anomaly” (3). Elswit's investigation is not motivated by disciplinary infighting (though conflicts of cultural prestige, allocation of resources, and aesthetic values are not ignored) but rather by the desire for a vocabulary that is nimble and attentive to theatre and dance's interanimation and that can more accurately describe “a past and a present in which the two are inextricably intertwined” (3). This vocabulary, continuously developed and deepened throughout the overviews, is put in effective service in the interludes.
The first overview, “Interconnected Histories,” poses a vital “concern about the complexity of historical practices that has been left unexamined” by an adherence to a rigid bifurcation between theatre and dance (19). This overview focuses on artistic practices as, in Elswit's terms, “ecosystems” developed by various “network[s] of interlocutors who shared a wide range of referents and experiences” (20). Elswit traces contexts of training, work, and influence through several examples. One of the most compelling is her analysis of Robert Wilson. Elswit claims that the critical understanding of associations between Wilson and dance artists (Lucinda Childs, Meredith Monk) often assigns the “dance” category to Wilson's collaborator, which “risks not seeing Wilson himself as also a dance-minded person” (24). In a relatively short but impressively thorough treatment of a lineage of German performance culture from Wagner's Gesamtkunstwerk to postdramatic theatre, Elswit enacts her larger argument that we should take a long view of performance histories in order to see more clearly their interconnectedness across forms: “Once presumptions about form are suspended … all sorts of histories in the borderlands begin to emerge, and with them larger ecosystems of practice” (28).
The second overview, “Expanding Forms,” focuses on mostly contemporary examples, anchored by a close reading of the categories of the New York Dance and Performance Awards (the Bessies) and their multiple redefinitions in recent years. In order to make sense of contemporary expansions of form, Elswit includes the insights of dramaturgs Katherine Profeta and Marianne van Kerkhoven as she explores “the increasing overlap in both training and devising for theatre and dance, and how these processes impact the work” (37). Hopping from Pina Bausch to Judson Memorial Church back to Wilson, Elswit usefully summarizes this network's theory that “a form is more than a collection of technical skills” (39). Elswit also marks the rise of devising, referring to SITI Company, Viewpoints, and Action Theatre as employing processes that both “lend themselves to promiscuous formal developments” and also acknowledge the habits of technical training that participants may likely fall back upon in “the continual need to produce new material” (41). By way of Elinor Fuchs's “‘small planet’” (44), Elswit concludes the section by turning to aesthetic legibility and the challenges to spectatorship that expanding forms present, arguing for a model of spectatorship “that is not about knowing in advance, but instead about observing and finding out” (44).
“Overlapping Methods” is the final section and the one most concerned with the academic institutionalization of theatre and dance. Elswit offers the long overdue caution to “consider disciplines not as absolute, but rather as defined by who was in the room at any given time, much like artistic practices” (52). Practice-as-research has gained in popularity and saturation in the past decade. Elswit demonstrates a complementary and highly effective tactic for the shared aim of minimizing polarity between research and practice by emphasizing developments in scholarly criticism as both in tandem and in conversation with developments in artistic practice. Her approach is not dismissive, however, of the ways in which capital and cultural prestige affect disciplinary formations, and her readings of significant theoretical developments, particularly of Hans-Thies Lehmann's postdramatic theatre, are sharply attentive to the often hierarchical power dynamics between theatre and dance. Elswit concludes with a call for readers to generate their own lists of what she terms “ampersand performances” (70). I hope such future lists, focused on practices, performances, and ideas that do not congeal theatre and dance but rather “reveal the entanglements that have been going on between them all along” (67) expand the geographical scope of Elswit's timely exploration.
