After a visit to the Roman Forum in 1906, James Joyce famously commented to his brother, ‘Rome reminds me of a man who lives by exhibiting to travelers his grandmother's corpse.’ Gazing directly at the ruins that constitute the ‘corpse’ of Rome seems to have had similarly potent effects on writers from Jerome to Gibbon, compelling each to use the remains of one city as a metaphor for the fall of an entire empire. Carlos Machado's new book investigates the late antique history of the city of Rome from the reign of Aurelian (a.d. 270–275) to the Justinianic invasion of Italy (a.d. 535), examining its topography, monuments, social organisation, cultural personality and religious identity. M.'s exceptional new monograph tracks the changing relationship between the Roman elite and the urban spaces of Rome, arguing that Romans within the senatorial ordo increased their social and political capital by redefining Rome's urban spaces to a degree unknown since the late Republic.
The book is divided into three parts with seven chapters, an introduction and conclusion. Part One addresses the definition of urban space in Rome, first by mapping the power grid that was Late Antique Rome and next by addressing building within the city. Following the lead of André Chastagnol, M. shows how political and institutional reforms in the late third and early fourth centuries changed Rome by concentrating power on the urban prefecture. Urban prefects and their administrative officials began to have more intimate effects on the daily life of Romans. At the same time, the reconsideration of the annona––the food dole––would also redefine the city socially and spatially. M.'s dissection of the Praefectura Urbana––Rome's main prefectorial offices––illustrate this transformation, as does the refurbishment of buildings such as the Temple of Peace into a space that functioned more as a forum than a temple from the beginning of the fourth century. Late antique Rome was more than imperial palaces and churches; its buildings also reveal an increase in social services often connected to the food supply. Aristocrats were connected to this emerging cityscape both as imperial officials and through private euergetism.
Interweaving a masterful mix of epigraphic and legal evidence, M. revises the narrative surrounding spoliation and reuse in late Rome's building industry. The uniquity of Rome's finances and the responsibility of urban prefects for dispensing them meant that the Urbs was somewhat more vulnerable to corruption and fiscal mismanagement. Effective organization and patronage of Rome's workforce via patronage of collegia within the city became an important outlet of honour for the senatorial elite once again––although M. misses the chance to bring in the comparative material from the late Republic which further demonstrates his argument that this is in many ways a return to the Roman patronage of yore.
At the end of Part One, M. remarks that ‘[u]rban space is not defined by physical structures and political institutions only, but also by the ways in which power operates in its spatial setting’. Part Two illustrates this assertion through examination of changes to the Roman Forum, geolocating the ephemeral but potent role of ceremonies and celebrations and pinpointing the redefinition of Rome's religious landscape. The senatorial takeover of the Forum in the early decades of the fifth century in particular indicates the role of the elite in self-interested rebuilding following the sack of the city in 410 and again in 455. M. uses close examinations of late antique work on buildings such as the Basilica Aemilia as telling stratigraphies that reveal wider political transformations in the late fourth and fifth centuries. Restored buildings must also be understood alongside the re-emerging honorific landscape of statues dedicated to senators in places like the Forum of Trajan, as well as the physical movement of aristocrats through the streets of the city. In Part Three, the final piece of the power grid is surveyed: the social and political role of elite houses. Aristocratic takeover of public spaces and structures mutated the urban fabric and created new symbols of power that occupied an area between the modern constructs of public and private. It is only by understanding late antique senatorial Rome that we can then understand the emergence of a new social order dominated by the bishop, i.e. the pope.
The volume is well illustrated and provides useful, meticulous maps. Its content and visuals pair well with an earlier digital project, the Last Statues of Antiquity (LSA) Database (http://laststatues.classics.ox.ac.uk/), to which M. contributed. Although historians can often view the shifting urban landscape of the late antique Urbs as a mirror reflecting mutations among the senatorial aristocracy, the emperor, and the populace, M. notes that the city was ‘both a product and a producer of this social order’. The topographical study ends with a quote from bishop Gregory I, who in the late sixth century addressed his congregation by lamenting Rome's place as the former ‘mistress of the world’, whose bones had wasted away. As those senators and non-elites listening to his words surely realised, the city and her aristocracy were no longer the same. The Rome that would emerge following Gregory's ascendance to the papacy would become a different city altogether, a shift perhaps illustrated in the later conversion of the Curia to the Church of S. Adriano under Pope Honorius I (a.d. 625–638). M.'s mix of archaeological, epigraphic and literary evidence recreates a living and breathing Rome that bears little resemblance to the vestiges of greatness lamented by Gibbon. The volume deftly reveals the city as strategy in the late Empire and in so doing brings a much maligned and misunderstood ‘corpse’ back to life.
